Rate That Signature!

[Kelisidina]

Ayu-sempai: 5/10. It looks like you just cropped and played with saturation and the text looks out of place

[ganbaru]

KimmyChan 8/10 the sig is over-weight and the render don't go well with the renders
Ayu-smepai 8,4/10 the choice of the colors is discutable and the text sound odd to me.

Originally Posted by Miko Miko

Am I the only person who goes back and sees what others rate my signature, is that the level of my sadness or am I not alone?

No, I also do it. It's a way to have some C&C, but of course some comments have more weight than others...

[Chaho-Chi]

Same here. Comments, sometimes can hurt more than improve depending on who you are and what you say.

ganbaru: 8/10 The render really looks out of place, and the text color doesn't look good. I like the glow though.

Kelisidina: 7.9/10 The yellow near her face looked like something blew up inside her ear .___.'' The render is really out of place also.

[Miko Miko]

No, I also do it. It's a way to have some C&C, but of course some comments have more weight than others...

Same here. Comments, sometimes can hurt more than improve depending on who you are and what you say.

Ahh, I see. I'm not alone I was beginning to think I was stranger than the normal AS member

ayu-smepai -9/10

[The Chaos]

ayu-smepai..Look Really Good..9.3/10

[xKyonkox]

Miko Miko- 8/10, green day lyric?
The Chaos- 10/10 very good quality

[Hs Vi Germania]

Kelisidina: 8/10
ayu-smepai: 8.5/10
KimmyChan: You could insert more. 8/10

[Haladflire65]

ayu-smepai: 8.5/10
Hs Vi Germania: 9/10

[Kelisidina]

Haladflire65: 5/10 It looks like it was just a crop, try adding some lighting.

[ganbaru]

Haladflire65 8,2/10 I have to agree with Kelisidina on this one, it look like a crop, but not a bad one.
Kelisidina 8,2/10 Do you remember the Rule on this formu about signature ?

[apatpower]

hi.. ganbaru .. 7/10 .. to much word i think..
Kelisidina .. 8/10 .. its o k ..
germania .. 9/10 ..
Haladflire65 .. 5/10 .. ya just a crop ..

[Chaho-Chi]

apatpower: 8/10 There's just something I don't like about it...

[Kelisidina]

apatpower; 6/10 it looks like you just copy/pasted on a texture and added text

[The Chaos]

apatpower..Look Really Good with Animation in it ..8.5/10

[Katocchi]

ayu-smepai - 8.5/10
Kelisidina - 7.5/10
Chaos-san - 8.5/10

[The Chaos]

Kato-Chan..Nice SE Sig..8.5/10

[Evil Rick]

apatpower: Oh, lol 8.5/10
ayu-smepai: The text is wrong placed and looks low definition. 6/10
Kelisidina: Verty nice 7.5/10
Katocchi: Nice 8/10

[ganbaru]

Evil Rick 9,4/10 great background

[grylsyjaeger]

The Chaos: Man that signature looks unbelievable. Love it. 10/10
Evil Rick: Just as you made the above rated signature this one is also unbelievable. As ganburu has already said, the background is great. 10/10
Katocchi: Aw, where'd Azusa and Yui go? 8.5/10


Made some alterations to mine to reduce some of the white.

[Evil Rick]

ganbaru: I like cute little girls. 8.5/10
fallschirmjager: That's beautifull. 9/10
btw, thanks for the coments.