Rate That Signature!

[Lunchboxx]

kagetsu..I like the one without the other characters better.....9.5/10 for it

[Thany]

Lunchboxx, quite funny and scary look I guess I like it : 8.5/10.

[Sid_Burn]

Luchboxx : Whoa!!! I like the EVIL look... 87/100

[Lunchboxx]

Sid Burn....dun really like the image....alittle to dark...7.5/10
Thany...Ultra cute blinking and V sign...nice border as usual...9.5/10

[aahhsin]

This Sig anygood? I got kinda lazy on it. I'll probably throw it in Chibi's shop and see if anyone wants to touch it up.



Lunchboxx = Vampires. A-
Sid Burn = Predator? Zergling? Protoss? Alien? A-

[Thany]

Originally Posted by aahhsin

This Sig anygood? I got kinda lazy on it. I'll probably throw it in Chibi's shop and see if anyone wants to touch it up.

Well that one would be a good change, it's far better than your current one and would earn a 8.5/10 from me ^^
Lunchboxx, wahhh! You changed it again! 9/10 for this one, I like the style

[Lunchboxx]

aahhsin..I like it better then your current one...but the way its turned horizontal looks wierd and the text is to plane.....7.5/10

[Secca]

Aahhsin - definitely looks better than your old one, altho looks kinda ecchi but that's perfect for you. - 9/10
Lunchboxx - wow new one, again, in one day. ^^ I kinda like the angry Arcu, but this one looks cool too, what's that from? Looks like alot of sharp things sticking on him. - 9/10

[Sid_Burn]

Originally Posted by aahhsin

This Sig anygood? I got kinda lazy on it. I'll probably throw it in Chibi's shop and see if anyone wants to touch it up.



Lunchboxx = Vampires. A-
Sid Burn = Predator? Zergling? Protoss? Alien? A-

Hmmm... It's a Protoss..., anyway dis sig is definately good... 85/100

[wnkryo]

Thanks to Lexander for my sig. >.<



Sid_Burn: Scary 7/10

[Secca]

wnkryo - nice I really like this one. All the characters profile has attitude and just cool all over. ^^ 10/10

Edit: lol wait except for Chopper, I cannot tell what he's thinking. ^^

[Sid_Burn]

wnkryo : this one looks much better... 87/100

[Ending]

@ Secca

Pretty good, "summerious." What? A rating? Okay: --5/20, just to fit to the general consensus. (Seriously though: it's "pretty good" as a # rating too )

@ Sid

Sub-zero and some Starcraft for change, eh? They look pretty good too, or better than those HALO models. 10/10

[Thany]

Originally Posted by Wirhe

@ Secca

Pretty good, "summerious." What? A rating? Okay: --5/20, just to fit to the general consensus. (Seriously though: it's "pretty good" as a # rating too )

The reason can be seen here *cheers NightWish*
Sid Burn, I like your new signature, it's way better than your last signatures, you get a 9/10.

[Ending]

Yeah, I read it, but isn't it nicer to give "constructive" feedback instead of a regular "10/10 or 1/10?" IMO, a simple word 'nice' beats the hell out of any "10/10."

Decend sig. 10/10.

[wnkryo]

Who ever brings up a Samurai Champloo sig. will automatically get 10/10.

(I prerated future signatures!)

[Lexander]

Lunchboxx - 10/10 for yesterdays (what anime was it from, looks badass)
8/10 for todays, not diggin it as much as your other ones


wnkryo - /10


Sid_Burn - oooo Zergilicious 9/10 for the Hydra and semioriginal theme

[GreenTze]

Hmm, I believe this is my second 3 post in this thred yeah! Ok, here we go:
Sid_Burn- I would have to agree with Lunchboxx I don't really like the image. Even though it is pretty dark, I still enjoy the colors incorporated into it. 7.5/10
Lunchboxx- I'll rate this the same way I rated your avatar. I liked Arc way better and I dislike the drawing style. 6.5/10
ahhsin-Ack, the font and the border look horrible. I'm sorry for saying this, but thats what I honestly think 5/10
Thany- I'm not really sure what to rate it. Try a different theme. 7/10
wnkryo- My rating will be bias since I absolutely love One Piece. 10/10
Secca- Has a weird old effect to it. Whats the anime called? 8/10

OK, the kind folks at Chibbi Workshop made these visually appealing sigs for me. I'm kinda fond of the one that Lexander made, but I just want to know what you guys think about the other two created by Secca and Fabian.

Secca

Fabian

[NightWish]

Originally Posted by Wirhe

...isn't it nicer to give "constructive" feedback...

I agree... ::nods:: "Constructive" comments are almost always better than a simple "rating by numbers"; as such I wouldn't delete a post that offered such feedback. When we ask people to rate we don't require the ratings to be numeric; we just want to keep the "HEY PPL RATE MY NEW SIG!!!111" posts away.

Anyway...
Lexander ~ Like most signatures I see it's too tall for my personal taste... still the picture is clean, crisp and works quite well. 6/10.

[Slade]

GreenTze- Hum they're all pretty decent the first one seems to have lost some quality in the processing the 2nd one is zoomed out a bit too much and the 3rd one has too much filter overlaying the picture... still, it looks nice though. Average score 8/10

wnkryo- Well well, master advertiser has fallen from his path and gone to the regular signatures! A nice one piece one... it captures each character relatively well in a compact signature. 9/10

Wirhe- Make the while transparent, the button itself darker and it should look much, much better. 6.5/10 as it currently is.

Sid_Burn- That's a classic picture. It's been around but still classic nevertheless. The red borders inside works well and it's simple. Terrans over Zergs anyday for me though 8.5/10

Lunchboxx- I have that wallpaper too, it's good art. A bit too long but high quality and simple border work. 8.5/10

-Edit

NightWish- Quote is still a valid signature indeed, I skip them unconciously sometimes though. Lets see... hummmmmmmm... A bit depressing of a quote but still, it's got good flow in the wording. I wonder where it came from? 8/10

New signature/avatar for me. SC is too cool not to make something out for.