2009-05-27, 09:14 | Link #5081 | |
All Hail Lelouch!
Author
Join Date: May 2008
Location: In His Majesties Service.
Age: 40
|
Quote:
Schenziel according to the show is the better strategist(Lelouch just read him better that one time) and Bismark is a better fighter than Suzaku(he just got shafted because Suzaku had a Jesus mech. If he had a 9th gen mech Suzaku is screwed). And so what if they make Suzaku a moron? Ever hear the phrase "evil wins because good is dumb"? I mean theirs nothing wrong with him being stupid. You don't need to be smart(or intensively trained apparently) to pilot a mecha in anime all you need is some form of plot aid(minosky particles, ultimate co-ordinator, spiral energy, gn particles the force(lol)), brains take a backseat to hotbloodness. |
|
2009-05-27, 09:21 | Link #5082 | |
Logician and Romantic
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Within my mind
Age: 43
|
Quote:
He finally did this later, when it should have been his first action to begin with. The fact that even though he suspect something is wrong with the people watching Lulu, Suzaku didn't try the most direct approach in finding out what's wrong, is a sign of decision making deficiency.
__________________
|
|
2009-05-27, 09:35 | Link #5083 | |
All Hail Lelouch!
Author
Join Date: May 2008
Location: In His Majesties Service.
Age: 40
|
Quote:
What he thinks the refrain'll do, i don't know. Maybe try and turn her into a junkie so she rats Lelouch out for her next fix or maybe just for the lulz of hurting someone Lelouch cares about, take your pick. Also it wouldn't be surprising if his emotions have interefered with his judgement. I mean its because of his emotions that Lelouch gets to carry the idiot ball most of the time in CG, why should Suzaku be any different? |
|
2009-05-27, 09:51 | Link #5084 | |
Logician and Romantic
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Within my mind
Age: 43
|
Quote:
There was nothing that prevents Suzaku from making a visit. He is high enough in the hierarchy to make an inspection unannounced. If you think something is wrong, you make a house-call. This is a standard first-response anyone should have done. The fact is, Suzaku had not believed for a second that "everything is fine", yet didn't respond properly. This isn't because of emotions, IMO; I view this as evidence that Suzaku has trouble dealing with being a manager and leader.
__________________
|
|
2009-05-27, 10:14 | Link #5085 | |
All Hail Lelouch!
Author
Join Date: May 2008
Location: In His Majesties Service.
Age: 40
|
Quote:
In his head if things are truly as they shouldbe or if they are completely compromised going to Ashford will only get him reassured once more that everything is surefine. Therefore he tries and gets outside confirmation that lelouch is Zero by turning kallen into a junkie. Also it has always been about emotions buggering up his decisions. I mean on one hand in EP 8 when Lelouch says "I'll bring 1 million people to the SAZ if you let me bugger off" Suzaku is like let a criminal escape? NOOOOOOOOOO. Then we have him in EP 1 telling Chuckie that "I'll be the one to kill Zero" contrasted with him in EP9 saving Zero from a deranged table humper and having to be told that "you're supposed to hate Zero" and in EP 17 agreeing to help Lelouch(who he knows is Zero by this time) even though he can tell Lelouch is lying through his teeth. Heck even in the last Ep when Lelouch gives him the mask and says you'll be the one to kill me, Suzaku is like "Lelouch do you really want to go through with this?" yet just after whacking mom and dad he's like "I'll kill u bitch 4 Euphie". Seriously Suzaku doesn't know what he bloody wants. He doesn't know if he wants Lelouch to be Zero so he can rage at him for what happened to Euphie or Lelouch not to be Zero so they can be semi-friends. If this doesn't show him as being emotionaly compromised in his judgement in relation to anything about Lelouch, I don't know what does. |
|
2009-05-27, 10:17 | Link #5086 |
Um-Shmum
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: at GNR, bringing you the truth, no matter how bad it hurts
Age: 39
|
Suzaku was hoping the drug would strip kallen of her will power and make her stop resisting and just admit what BOTH of them know that she is hiding (suzaku is certain of it). Given that most drugs have that effect, that doesn't make suzaku an idiot. Just a dick
__________________
|
2009-05-27, 10:19 | Link #5087 | ||
Logician and Romantic
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Within my mind
Age: 43
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||
2009-05-27, 10:30 | Link #5088 | |
All Hail Lelouch!
Author
Join Date: May 2008
Location: In His Majesties Service.
Age: 40
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-05-27, 10:59 | Link #5089 | |
Logician and Romantic
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Within my mind
Age: 43
|
Quote:
No matter what he does with Kallen, as long as the Intelligence Agency contradict him Suzaku would convince no one else. Suzaku need proof that the Intel is wrong, but you can't do that without confronting the evidence directly. Suzaku needed to request the surveillance logs, as well as checking for holes in the time schedule. The Intel team is telling him and everyone else that there is nothing wrong. Even if Kallen says otherwise, it is still the words of an enemy against the words of government officials. Suzaku need to prove the surveillance team is wrong, but he did nothing to that effect. All it took, in the end, was for Suzaku to visit them directly. It's what Lulu would have done.
__________________
|
|
2009-05-27, 12:21 | Link #5090 |
Um-Shmum
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: at GNR, bringing you the truth, no matter how bad it hurts
Age: 39
|
oh come on
say what you want about suzaku, but you cant really say that he was planning on turning kallen into a junkie do you expect me to believe he was PLANNING on TURNING her into a junkie (a long process that requires more then one injection, you dont get addicted on the very first use) and then use her addiction to get her to tell him what he wants ? it takes sheirly dying just to get him to gather the resolve to do anything other then ASKING her about lelouch and he cant even go through with THAT in the end putting aside the fact that there was no way in hell nunnaly would ever even let him anywhere NEAR kallen after the first time (kallen would have no reason to keep quite about something like that, she never told nunnaly becouse he didnt do it) doing what your saying is something pure EVIL and suzaku isnt capable of that at that stage (maybe after turn 19)
__________________
|
2009-05-27, 15:04 | Link #5094 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2009
|
Thanks to Blade, Morbo, and Frost for the corrections on my PD comments.
It's more of a possible plot hole than a jab at Suzaku's ability to follow the guidlines of the very system he supossedly is OCD about following, but I always wondered why nobody caught onto the fact that Lelouch got his memories back after he used his Geass to kill Carthage Team in Babel Tower and announced himself as Lelouch Vi Britannia. If the Thought Elevators allowed one to view the memories of the dead (like Charles was with Clovis apparently) then given the time Charles and V.V. spend in there, they should have checked on the soldiers' memories, at which point they would have known Lelouch was 'back.' |
2009-05-27, 15:42 | Link #5095 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
|
Quote:
|
|
2009-05-27, 15:46 | Link #5096 | |
Spinning Lotus
Join Date: Jul 2008
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2009-05-27, 16:34 | Link #5097 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
|
Quote:
I mean he probably drinks cofee that the soldiers took a piss in. |
|
2009-05-27, 16:50 | Link #5099 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
|
I have to go with Villeta, I mean in one episode she wears a bathing suit whose bottom is basically a string and then bitches about how she agreed to wear it, and the only thing holding her to Lelouch is the fact that he knows she once dated Ougi when she had amnesia. That's it, it's Lelouch's word against her word.
|
2009-05-27, 17:32 | Link #5100 | |||||||
Dreaming Sorceress
|
First I want to thank you, Betteroffer, for reading my post and giving a detailed and constructed answer, and no worries, as long as it's constructive I can handle any criticism of any character. I hope it's ok for to still constructively put some arguments to that.
I feel that you certainly have a point, but still, most of the examples you have given could be interpreted rather differently. Also I've read (ok, it was geasswiki, and that's why I'm asking) that in Knights of Round-centered light novels (and they do exist for sure since they're selling them on japAmazon) Gino is said to fall in love with their family's japanese (eleven) maid (although of course nothing good came out of this) when he was 14 and that shows that he didn't care about racial differences and that he, well, did take non-Britannian's for humans. I would be glad if somebody confirms that info. On the point of him (or others) being/not being skilled pilot, I thought about and... I wonder, who we consider "awesome pilot". Ok, we can say Karen and Suzaku belong to the category, and Bismark (and Marianne), and Li Xingke too. But seriously, who else? The way our standards are, we're saying that everybody else it's good enough. But well, there can't be just two good pilots in whole Britannian army *(and for others, it comes to be less), so maybe we're just setting standards too high. And from that point of view, both Gino and even Anya are tolerably good. And Jeremiah too, btw. They tell KoR about appeared Karen that she's the pilot who beated Lord Jeremiah implying she must be great and thus Jeremiah was a great pilot too, even before becoming a cyborg. Quote:
But what did worry me in that story with Zero is the way he thought Zero's deal is good one. Although he was true that without their leader rebels won't be a serious threat any more, but somehow it was low... But it could be explained as him not paying much attention to past sins like in Karen's situation later. Quote:
Remember how it all ends (happily) - she does to Ashford while having her favorite hair style and wearing Gurren's key on chain, and it means that she finally accepted both sides of her, both japanese and britannian. And Gino's act was kind of a step in that direction. Pointing out that she's not only japanese, but she's also britannian, and she could choose either side, it's just up to her. And I haven't seen Gino saying or implying he's stupid while he said all that. Plus about him ignoring others... Again, from his actions when stopping Bradly we may assume that he would probably done the same if he had seen it on the streets, although in my opinion it would depend on the situation. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
But about FLEIJA accident we should start with his shocked face after seeing the effect and saying "That's not war anymore..." It we combine in with his face's expression at the time I would assume the continuation was "but just a massacre". And that would be him actually caring about lives of civilians. About Suzaku - here it starts to stop making sense, but what I can say on it is the fact (which Gino most probably didn't consider though) that Suzaku is what in socionic (well, theory in phycology) is called introvert, person rather thinking just by himself then sharing his thoughts with others. So basicly he wouldn't talk with anybody anyway, and if he didn't share things worrying him even with Euphie (and one time with Lelouch in the end of ep.23 S1 was rather him declaring his decision than discussing something), he certainly wouldn't with Gino. Although again, I doubt it was Gino's train of thought. But then the whole idea of them playing pool after such tragedy. Ok, Gino, but Cecile is quite kindhearted person no matter how you look on it. It's either them getting this used to such tragedies (highly doubtful) or just... author's wanted a joke-relief moment (I rarely blame it on authors, but this might be the case, plus they needed the some of the ball falling into the hole in the critical moment). And when he did notice something was off with Suzaku he did try to say that he shouldn;t say all this, it isn't like that... And after things Suzaku said I wouldn't blame Gino for turning on him. Damn, he was proposing a coup d'etat, evenb Cornelia was shocked. And the situation (with Shneizel present expecially) didn't invite to try and convince him that "it's not like him, snap out of it". Suzaku was unstable, but it wasn't possible to convince him of that at the moment. And about him not caring about his friends... I just remember his seriously worried face when Anya fell (during fight with Chinese and BK forces arounf ep.9), much more than just replacable ally. And according to the posts (please tell the stupid me where did you get this translations, where is it from?) he did keep in touch with Ashford students) And also, when Karen was imprisoned, he did come to show her Suzaku's album and tell about him... I felt he tried to explain Suzaku's character to her so that she understood him better, and I see it like an act of a friend, caring one. Quote:
I'm just trying to find any explanation better than ordinary "luck". There are no coinsidences. Quote:
And also, after closely rewatching around 5 last eps of R2 I improved my opinion of him greatly. Seems like they didn't just support the two with Cecile, they support them after coming to know about the plan. I see it as quite honorable thing to do, expecially because it was both dangerous while before Zero Requiem and after because they might still suffer for supporting him (ok, maybe after they were almost executed it's off mark, but still)... He's great, adn Cecile too. But I started to see her a bit colder than I thought she was. And on the other note, about Suzaku, don't call him an antagonist! I thought this series is one of greatest example, together with Gundam SEED, of not supporting any side but showing things as they are, wtih different people and their different goals... And about him being stupid... it's not like he's not smart, but it's as Lloyd said, his inner contradictions are always dragging him down, contradictions between peaceful world he dreams of and reality, he tries to deal with hush reality while not letting go of his ideals because he knows that if he does, he'll loose himself (as he did for a while around ep.20, it's so cute that even in getting a little crazy he and Lelouch worked on pair). |
|||||||
|
|