2008-05-28, 22:59 | Link #481 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
|
Quote:
So, after he steals the spell sets of all 4 Forwards, and we generously assume he can use all of them reasonably well, he'll be a well-rounded A-rank mage that can do both melee and ranged! OK, he can summon, but I don't think he'll have the "contacts" to call up Voltaire (there seems to be something more to this than chanting the right incantation). Wow, an Mid-ending threat! In fact, depending on the situation, it is not even clear if he can win after that against a prepared A-ranking mage that has specialized in an area (it doesn't matter if you are good at both ranged and melee if the whole contest was kept at "ranged"). If he's faced off against a complementary pair, barring some pretty nice tactics he'll still be the one that's minced. And if he has the nice tactics, isn't his real strength really his tactical ability rather than this skill? If anything, if Com is trying to flap this borg up into even a demi-threat, he's going to have to get really creative. The borg will have to steal the really rare magics that are outside of the normal range of Midchildrans. For an unimaginative one, a spell that actually goes supersonic will be nice... (you see, I just can't get creative enough to actually write) but the point is that it has to be Special. The character is mildly interesting, but as a game-disbalancing threat? Just don't see it. As for technical plausibility, while Reinforce Eins is a Lost Logia, even a Lost Logia shows that such a thing is at least technically possible. Which actually places this idea higher on the "Is Supported by Canon" scale than many things that have been approved before, such as Aspect Magic or Cleric Knights or whatever. |
|
2008-05-28, 23:02 | Link #482 | |||||||||||||||||||
Nuclear Fusion
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Sky of stone, floor of flame.
Age: 37
|
Quote:
Quote:
Well, you're so damn fond of traps, so... Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
And I like the girl's look, too. We need more tanned girls. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Kha: OBJECTION!!! *runs* Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Keroko-kun is cursed!!! Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Which is probably why I liked her a lot...airhead, cyborg, brute strength, nice- *Revolver Knuckle'd* Quote:
Quote:
........I just hit Lv22...T_T And as I happen to be here, take a chill pill, guys. No point getting all worked up so soon after we started over.
__________________
|
|||||||||||||||||||
2008-05-28, 23:20 | Link #483 |
Secret Society BLANKET
Graphic Designer
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: 3 times the passion of normal flamenco
|
*me takes out wallet*
I think the problem people are seeing with Coma's Spell Copying Concept isn't that the concept itself is unbalanced... it's just that story-wise, it has the potential to be heavily unbalanced. All attack, ability and spell concepts put forward here are scrutizined with the assumption that they are operating under the ideal circumstances for their use, aka the best possible outcome for that spell to be successful and accomplish its designated function. From what I can tell, the most balanced abilities tend to still have logically exploitable weaknesses even if operating under such ideal circumstances. While Coma's spell does have weaknesses (as ark and keroko pointed out), under the ideal circumstances of its use it really does seem a tad H4XX, since if the ability was wholly successful, no one would really have a chance lest plot intervenes. And it's the degree of plot intervention necessary to counter a skill that makes it H4XX. The more that you need PLOT to justify your weakness, the more imbalanced it becomes, since by this point everything is to the whim of the writer, unless the writer is trusted and acknowledgeable enough to be able to keep his various plot devices sane and acceptable. *me throws 2 cents*
__________________
|
2008-05-29, 00:04 | Link #484 |
Slash!
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Oxnard, CA
Age: 31
|
Holy crap...a second incarnation...I never would have believed it....still, hey there guys, looks like this new thread's gonna be a bit better than the old thread.
Note: I'm not gonna be in this thread now...well, until school ends, which is about in a month or so. I'll be checking in, though. Later then. |
2008-05-29, 01:32 | Link #485 | |||||||||||||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Philippines
|
Commencing Intervention. =/
Quote:
Mind your language. Disregarding it is fine, but acting all ignorant to an annoying level about this fact will not do your reputation good. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Not all of us may be very friendly with you, but some of us are trying to cooperate as well. <Points at Keroko and myself (in IRC)> As such, keep your annoyance with Tk, Goose or whoever else away from others. Annoying us because of attitude rising from the fact that they annoy you is human, but it won't help you any. And I'm telling you, as a fellow human, I can choose to ignore someone I can help out if he annoys me. Quote:
Quote:
And BTW, I know this may be sarcasm, but I'm not sure. So there. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
And no, I think it matters that you get the person who said it correctly. This could act as black propaganda against the person you mistakenly assigned the lines to. Tk never makes racist statements as far as I'm aware of. And the IRC is non of OC's business if it's something that'll stir up trouble here. Don't bring online chat annoyances here. Bring it someplace else like PM's. And you know what? How about trying to deal with the attitude? Tk, however rude he may sound is still just being bluntly in-topic. he thinks the IDEAS are stupid. He never goes around blatantly calling people idiots or whatnot for their ideas. or simply to insult others. THAT is what I was trying to prevent. And Tk is NOT doing so, IMO. If you don't like his attitude, just ignore him. If you're getting insults from a bit more unreasonable reasons from people here in OC, than I'll help out. Is it fine? I'm worried about irrelevant annoyances and clashes, not about harshness in treatment (unless it gets out of the line). Laissez Faire is still mostly in effect since we can take care of ourselves anyway.=/ Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
But the points are very valid for the joint-as-close-to-canon universal regulations of the majority of OC. So these points are still to be kept in mind if anybody else going OCT-route makes use of the same ideas. Quote:
I don't think the idea is overly HAXX. Just a bit. Now, mind explaining how you plan to use it in the story in detail again while we look at it? Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
-_- Keep it down for a bit while I try to work things out, mkay? Quote:
Quote:
However, IF he is indeed here not to do his work properly and just get kicks from Tk's attitude, then even I must wonder as well why he even bothers. Quote:
Quote:
The POINT is, just what is your OBJECTIVE? If you want to join OC with the precept of joining in on what everybody else is doing, aka sticking to Canon, etc. That's all good. If you AREN'T here to do that and is instead here to throw as some ideas to hammer out while keeping your rules mostly to yourself as a liberal fanfic, that's FINE as well. BUT, you must make your point and objective clear so as to avoid annoyance from rising. And as for the base level of basic annoyance that can affect your reputation badly if you speak about it, keep it out of here and stick to PM's. I don't care if you want to do AU fanfic on a very liberal level, just don't go around doing it in a way that grates on other's nerves. And of course for the other side of the spectrum, I propose we give him a chance. Again, I'm curious on how he plans to pull it off. Oh, and keep the banter atmosphere down for a bit,everyone. (And you too, Comartemis) Let's cool down a bit and try to work things out. And again, I must make it a point that I believe everyone shares a bit of the cake called Faulty Forest (which is not a lie) here. So if possible, It'd be nice if some apologies and agreements to be nicer flies from both directions. Quote:
Last edited by Aaron008R; 2008-05-29 at 03:05. |
|||||||||||||||||||||
2008-05-29, 01:52 | Link #486 | ||||
~Night of Gales~
Author
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
2 or 3 years after StrikerS...
Vivio and co. enters the world of sports. :3 It's pretty basic, though there's some characterization problems on whether or not to make Vivio a 'challenger' type of person, to leave Sankt Hilde to face her own ex-comrades. Besides, I kinda wanna know if the name of the place Yuuno learnt magic from. I'm thinking of throwing in Blitzball and stuff inside too. :3 Quote:
Quote:
These are the kind of parts in books I dislike the most, especially if they're LOOOOOOOOOOOOONNNNNNNNNNNG. I feel that such reflection doesn't need to be explicitly over-pushed, personally. Quote:
Very nice. The backgrounds and stuff seem nicely fitted. Though I've got to ask... 21 year old Fate's details... link. Quote:
... :3 You really go all the way, don't you? And it's... "Legends Ends, History Begins." There was Jail's unsecured Relics in his glass box though.
__________________
|
||||
2008-05-29, 02:22 | Link #487 | |
Storm Vanguard
Graphic Designer
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Type-00
|
Quote:
I might redesign the Plasma Form later but I wont be editing the Sonic EXA Form since I like the design . |
|
2008-05-29, 02:40 | Link #488 | |
The Dang-meister
|
Quote:
Any chance you could do a full-body image of both her Sonic Form, and her Impulse, or whatever form that is that you've created, in colour? That would be cool of you could
__________________
|
|
2008-05-29, 02:48 | Link #489 | ||
Storm Vanguard
Graphic Designer
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Type-00
|
Thanks Ghaz. >_<
I would love to but I'm not good in terms of coloring T__T. I'll give it a try though. I'll sketch a full bodied image of both forms tomorrow. Then I'll post it once its done >_0 Quote:
Alright then, I'll post it. The sketch is not finished yet though. Quote:
Oh good, you're words are very reassuring. Thanks for the approval. now here's the sketch of one of the scenes that I'm going to include in my Fanfic. Basically, Asclei lost the battle and fell on the river that had a powerful current. Fate managed to save him but he's no longer breathing...yup...I can sense blood thirst right now for some reason.... P.S. the sketch is still incomplete and will be done by tomorrow. Spoiler for Warning! the image may cause murderous intent towards the artist if mentally and emotionally unprepared :
Last edited by Silvance; 2008-05-29 at 03:12. |
||
2008-05-29, 04:27 | Link #490 |
The Resurrector
Author
Join Date: Sep 2007
|
*jostles in from somewhere during an adventure in the Tales of the Abyss*
Just to give my two cent on the current hubris, I think we can rein in the hammers a bit. I don't know how you guys think of Comartemis thus far, but to me, he's certainly improved since his last attempt on Zero, which was practically mangled from all imaginable angles. Giving the many artillery flaks that he's received until now, I personally think that he's sober enough to control what he's going to introduce. I think he should be allowed some degree of freedom to introduce his story so that we can see how he's going to portray things, because right now, we're just firing our bullets at concepts and ideas that look flawed not because they're entirely flawed, but mostly because of the general lack of background story. Of course, the perfection of that particular story depends entirely on him. If it's not satisfactory to the majority ... then the hammers strike back. And Comartemis, I think you should've learned quite some time ago that whatever you do, you have to do it in moderation. Sure, uniqueness and specialty and rare skills make us "ooh"s and "aah"s (not all the time, though), but if it's going to cost you an arm and a foot to write a believable backstory for support, send those ideas to the guillotine immediately. There is no point in keeping those skills unless you're absolutely sure you can convince the readers that the skills are imperative. Yes, this sounds very cruel indeed, but for us who've written earlier, it's the best way to toe the line. The thread in general is forgiving for the most part, but if you cross that particular threshold, the wrath will be very terrible indeed. I am holding the belief that you can produce something memorable so long as you learn how to put creativity to full use and not just piling up ideas, hoping that one might hit the jackpot. It wastes yours and everybody else's time. Personally, I've maneuvered through the difficult times as well, so it's understandable that you're quite frustrated at having some of your ideas rejected. I even once had a full-blown debate with TK on some concepts. I was stubborn then, refusing to yield, and it led to some uncomfortable confrontations (though by forum outlook, it just seemed as if we're having some scientific exchanges ). But, after some considerations that don't affect the story that much, I decided to change. To tell you the truth, the change is a great improvement, not the reverse. If you can't compromise, then you'll find yourself to be in a very tight spot with very little room for improvement. Now, that's my two cent. *vanishes out into the Qliploth Sea* |
2008-05-29, 05:13 | Link #491 |
illusion control
Author
|
Sometimes I wonder how much my character-creation tendencies have been influenced by my background in pen-and-paper RPGs.
Just taking the HERO System 5ER, it's still entirely possible to completely overpower a character on 350 points (Disads included), but at least it's a start in balancing a character. This is also somewhat ironic, since the canon cast of the Nanoha-verse are not anywhere near balanced. Just try statting Hayate in HERO 5ER. Go on, I'll wait. Essentially, we're placing restrictions on ourselves which the original creators did not. Such is the price of playing in a borrowed world, I suppose. |
2008-05-29, 05:29 | Link #492 | ||||||||
Adeptus Animus
Author
Join Date: Jan 2007
Age: 36
|
Quote:
Besides, as I said before, so he copied Nanoha's spell list. And then? He's a B-rank mage, he won't be able to use 90% of Nanoha's spell-list because they are spells that require skills that are far beyond a B-rank (Axel Shooter, for one, requires above average control), not to mention the mana needed. Even if he is only able to use cantrips, so what? Having lots of spells does not make you more powerfull. Unpredictabillity can only reach so far. Nothing to refresh, I haven't written anything with him, really. It's all just plans. Quote:
<--- was walking around with 1200 gold at 60 doing little more then leveling. I'm not a raider.... partially why I'm jumping for joy at WotLK ... Can't recall. >_< Hmm, I suppose I could. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I figured those were plucked into something to power the massive fleet of drones though. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||||||
2008-05-29, 05:42 | Link #493 | |
Hi-Eternal
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Backyard of Moriya shrine
Age: 39
|
Quote:
|
|
2008-05-29, 06:12 | Link #496 | ||
the "Z" is for "Zeta"
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Portugal
|
Quote:
Quote:
*warps away*
__________________
|
||
2008-05-29, 06:27 | Link #497 | |||||||||||
~ I Do ~
Author
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: In the XV-8A Spartan "00"
Age: 38
|
Quote:
The question now is, does a Cyborg necessarily only have a Linker Core so small it cannot perform magic? Technically, yes. It's just like why 99.99% of Earth's population is Neutral, it wasn't in the genes or some heritable vector. I'm not too sure about the wider implications of your ideas, but I can say that yes Cyborgs can have Linker Cores large enough to process magic, it's just whether they are lucky enough to have one. Quote:
Combined with his megalomania, I could even say that the AMF was his snubbing of the mainstream, and that would further reinforce his lack of magic usage. I admit running counter to this is that Ginga was using both magic and scientology (for the lack of a better word; Science is a study, not an application, and Technology is freely available to Magic) in her battle against Subaru. However, you must note that effort was already spent by Ginga to use magic under AMF, and that would give her an edge over her one trick comrades. Why gimp yourself when its given free? By all means use it. Quote:
Given everyone's (except Keroko's) expectation, I guess my decision is akin to another moment of Zeroism? Then start saving. I made the mistake of spending too readily on AH gear while leveling, and hence ended up in this grinding mess. Had I been like my pals, I'd be mounted on Epic the moment I hit 70. But don't worry, the really important mounts for you will be your 40 and 60 ground mounts which have become so darn cheap. After all, you will be using them most of the time until you get epic flying. Quote:
Reminds me that I need to post less due to my exams coming... But... >.> Quote:
Quote:
Noted. But for the above, I was using Matrix 3's tagline, crossed with the tagline I used to promote the Student Council elections back when I was in school. :3 Oh yeah... Well maybe those boxes were made to contain the Relics, and are of a rather ubiquitous design, hence why everyone has it? Quote:
*is BISHed into the ground by ballistic hammer* Quote:
... ... OH MY FISTING GAWDS!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *grabs Fate and shakes her excitedly* We sooooo agree right here!!! In the original Khrack up to the 3 editions of Kha's profile, Fate's reply to Kha has been exactly like this! I'm not to sure if its the same here, but it sure looks like the "Kiss of Life" scenario. :3 While not exactly in manners of the tsun transitions before the final finish (sorry if that wasn't the case), it was Fate taking steps of her own; I felt it was a bit daring of Fate to be rather proactive. BUT! LOOK WHAT WE HAVE HERE! IT TOTALLY AGREES!!! XD And now that I think back, both Asclei and Kha have links to Fate's pater. Even MOAR agreement!!! XD XD XD *notices Fate is now all @_@ from the shaking* ...oops. But bottomline, that sketch was just awwwwww~~~ Too bad its AU to me. But we agree on how Fate's sweetheart is like, and I find great joy in that. :3 Quote:
At least you're level 60; you need 55 to have access to the Death Knight, which is about the only major level req content in LK other than the standard leveling to 80. I see. Guess we'd both be waiting eagerly. I do hope these don't completely replace the 5 man, because 10 men raids have more than 5 bosses, and hence tend to be too long for me to raid every day. Basically, I hope there will still be H Slave Pens and H Mechanar for me when I am 80. Because then I'd really be involved in my course, and can't afford too much time for fun... >< And I dread that day a little, cos while I'd finally be doing work I love, I'd have very little time left for Cadia Drei onwards... T_T Darn. I'd try shooting clues, but I'm a little short on ideas myseelf. I was thinking you don't actually. As it is, I see the situation as though its the Ashbringer wielded by Blazer as opposed to Morgrain himself. The weapon will still work, and its wielder would still be as powerful, but its just that the weapon wasn't intended for him. The subtle reason is that I know nothing about this Primarch, and any of Kha's lore referring to the Ces'rauva before him might be contradicted here... Keroko's chaotic bent. :3 Quote:
Needs certification!!! Anyone?! Quote:
Guess I'm that predictable eh? .............
__________________
Last edited by Kha; 2008-05-29 at 06:49. |
|||||||||||
2008-05-29, 06:36 | Link #498 |
RUN, YOU FOOLS!
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Formerly Iwakawa base and Chaldea. Now Teyvat, the Astral Express & the Outpost
Age: 44
|
In fiction, every evil geniuses falls to their own hubris and arrogance, ALL of them. Light Yagami is a recent example and I will not surprised if karma comes to bite Lelouch in the ass.
I mean come on, how long is it interesting to see flawless plans always succeeding? Wouldn't be funnier to see them fail and HOW and WHY they failed? Imo, a bucketload of Xanatos Gambit and Xanatos Roulette gets boring quick, and in poorly written fictions, they are an excuse for plot flaws. |
2008-05-29, 07:51 | Link #500 | |
illusion control
Author
|
Quote:
Dr. Doom has too complex a history to tell if his plans are "flawless". On the one hand, he's failed to accomplish his obvious goals of defeating many of the Marvel-verse supers. On the other hand, he's still alive and ruler of his own country, despite the best efforts of said Marvel-verse supers. Dr. Destroyer in the Champions setting just has really, really bad luck when it comes to plucky superheroes throwing themselves against him. He's killed many of them, and his plans have come close to success many times, but there's just too many heroes (see: Zerg rush). He did manage to destroy Detroit, and build two island fortresses. The same But More So for Istvatha V'han. Of course, I'll give you Mechanon being tripped up by his own hubris, especially considering how he got into the Galactic Champions setting. The main villain in Jade Empire (not going into specifics due to spoilers) would have succeeded perfectly if it weren't for what amounted to an end run by a deus ex machina. It's too difficult to separate fanon from canon in the case of Nemesis in City of Heroes, especially since fanon has a tendency to become canon. But he's the best example I can think of when it comes to making a villain who never seems to lose even though the hero manages (sometimes easily) to defeat him over and over again... until the next time, when it turns out that it's all part of the plan anyway. Done too much, and it turns cheesy quite quickly. ("Today my ham sandwich was three minutes late. This means that my plan is working perfectly!") But if the whole thing is planned beforehand, and if pulled off well, it can make for some very dramatic buildups. (I know you people like TTGL, so imagine it to be something like that. Put yourself in Lord Genome's place.) Remember: de l'audace, encore de l'audace, et toujours de l'audace. When writing a villainous mastermind type, always think big. Don't just use decoys to invade another dimension of telepathic aliens so that they declare war on the heroes; do it so that not only will the heroes be weakened, so will the aliens, letting you upload your consciousness onto their telepathic network in order to take it over, achieving immortality and absolute power over an entire race. That sort of big. And when you get tired of that, you can try writing up a version of Foxbat from the Champions-verse. He does have hubris, yes, but most of the time he fails because of his 25-point (Very Common, Total) Psychological Limitation: "Thinks He's Living In A Comic Book". - Question: how willing are you to click on story chapter links which are not on AnimeSuki? I'm wondering if I should repost my chapters in this thread (since I can't edit the old posts in the old thread), or if I should just dump them onto my Livejournal. Last edited by dkellis; 2008-05-29 at 08:24. |
|
Tags |
hayaurion, kaonland, keroland, khrack, original content |
|
|