Fullmetal Alchemist - Requests for new threads

[Kirarakim]

Originally Posted by White Manju Bun

I was thinking about that earlier, Ed, Al and Roy Im cool with, since Im not up to date with the manga does Winry deserve her own thread?? Just asking really but the other three Im cool with. Ill make the others asap.

Those are just names I threw out. But I am fine with just Ed, Al, and Roy for now.

[White Manju Bun]

Originally Posted by Kirarakim

Those are just names I threw out. But I am fine with just Ed, Al, and Roy for now.

Ok cool, if she gets more adaquate screen time we can always make one.

Character Discussion - Edward Elric is open, I have to switch computers but Ill open the others in a moment.

Edit:
Character Discussion - Roy Mustang
Character Discussion - Alphonse Elric

[Vicious108]

Maybe one for all of the Homunculi would be nice too. Though not necessarily now, might still be too soon into Brotherhood for that, just suggesting for some time in the near future maybe.

[Shiroth]

Originally Posted by Endless Twilight

Maybe one for all of the Homunculi would be nice too. Though not necessarily now, might still be too soon into Brotherhood for that, just suggesting for some time in the near future maybe.

I say start the Homunculi thread after

Spoiler for this sunday's episode:

they make their official appearance.

[blewin]

Just wondering, are there threads on Winry and impression on the current FMA series? (FMA 2)

[White Manju Bun]

Originally Posted by blewin

Just wondering, are there threads on Winry and impression on the current FMA series? (FMA 2)

There are no thread on Winry at the moment, I gave my reason a few posts above. As for impressions either use the weekly epi threads or the Full Metal Alchemist 2 Confirmed thread which seems to be where people are giving impressions. I might even change that thread title to General Discussion.

Also I have no problem with the Homunculi thread either, I was just waiting til a few more showed up. Or at least revealed themselves.

[Shiroth]

Originally Posted by White Manju Bun

Also I have no problem with the Homunculi thread either, I was just waiting til a few more showed up. Or at least revealed themselves.

Yeah like i said, should create that thread after next weeks episode.

[Ziziphus]

Is there any manga chapter instruction thread?
That would help a lot if we want to confirm a certain event that happened in the manga but we can no longer remember which chapter has it.

[Shiroth]

Originally Posted by Ziziphus

Is there any manga chapter instruction thread?
That would help a lot if we want to confirm a certain event that happened in the manga but we can no longer remember which chapter has it.

Spoiler & Specualtion thread would work, though then again having a thread just for that topic would be nice. Upto the mods though.

[Shiroth]

Episode 11 thread please. Episode has already aired, and we have a few members ready to discuss it.

[Mystique]

Based on the few posts and confusion that occured here:
http://forums.animesuki.com/showthre...88#post2452088

I'd like to request a generic music discussion thread alike the one for
Eden of the East - Music discussion (OP/ED & OST, etc.)

Feel free to discuss any music related subjects for Eden of the East here (OP/ED & OST, etc.). As the usual rule, NO POSTING LINKS TO MP3s OR ASKING FOR THEM. You may buy them at the usual place such as cdjapan and what not, but DO NOT ask for or post links to any music downloads. This includes, but isn't limited to:

* any RAR, ZIP, 7-ZIP archive
* Torrents
* The names of other BT sites that list music torrents
* Direct downloads

Seeing as this series will run for quite some time, (15 eps in and already a new OP &ED) it seems it'd be easier to discuss all OP and ED news, artists and related music videos into one thread, where info would be easier to access, rather than it getting lost in the 'general chat' thread or wandering around this forum a little lost for music related titled threads.

[White Manju Bun]

Originally Posted by Mystique

Based on the few posts and confusion that occured here:
http://forums.animesuki.com/showthre...88#post2452088

I'd like to request a generic music discussion thread alike the one for
Eden of the East - Music discussion (OP/ED & OST, etc.)

Seeing as this series will run for quite some time, (15 eps in and already a new OP &ED) it seems it'd be easier to discuss all OP and ED news, artists and related music videos into one thread, where info would be easier to access, rather than it getting lost in the 'general chat' thread or wandering around this forum a little lost for music related titled threads.

I think the current music thread is fine, Ill just edit the title of it since it was made before FMA was mod only threads.

[Konpachi]

Requesting a thread pretty much identical to Fullmetal Alchemist Timeline thread but for the manga.

I was gonna make a mention in the thread itself but it's locked.

[White Manju Bun]

Originally Posted by Konpachi

Requesting a thread pretty much identical to Fullmetal Alchemist Timeline thread but for the manga.

I was gonna make a mention in the thread itself but it's locked.

Hmm ok, first why cant it just be done in the manga thread? Not shooting it down but just wondering. If something like this does take its own thread, someone is gonna have to make the timeline since Im WAY behind in the manga

Also since we're nearly to epi 15, I was hoping to put together the first list for Favorite Characters poll. We only have 20 spots and 1 is always for Other so 19. Obviously all the mains will get a spot but who else should get in or shouldnt?

[Vicious108]

In my opinion, these should be the candidates for the poll:

Edward Elric
Alphonse Elric
Winry Rockbell
Roy Mustang
Riza Hawkeye
Maes Hughes
Alex Louis Armstrong
Izumi Curtis
Scar
Lust
Gluttony
Envy
Greed
Wrath/King Bradley

That's a suitable main list I think. I left out some characters who haven't been featured much yet like Roy's subordinates, Maria Ross, Father, etc. but maybe they could be included too since there are spots available... A second opinion on this would be nice I guess.

[Shiroth]

I agree with Endless Twilight's list. As for the character you suggested should be added, i say save them for the second poll which will be made later on.

[White Manju Bun]

Ok will be making character poll shortly.

[Karna]

Originally Posted by White Manju Bun

Ok will be making character poll shortly.

Adding Ling Yao to the list would be good aswell.

[Vicious108]

Well he's only been in one episode so far, but yeah why not.

And man, so much for "shortly"

[Shiroth]

Adding a character who's only been in one episode so far doesn't work, so he should be added to the next character poll after he's had more screentime.