Rate That Signature!

[Akito Kinomoto]

ganbaru--Eh, the book sticks out a little too much. 8.3/10
Unonithy--Maybe you could have used a different font. Points for making borderless work though. 8.3/10
Krytonis--Can't quite tell what the background is supposed to be. 8/10
Miko Miko--Perfect text is perfect. 8.5/10
Triple_R--It looks like you tried to give them the same lighting, but putting two aesthetically different franchises together on a visual level is just a hard sell. It also reminds me of this fanfic I read one time... 8.2999999/10
ninryu--Stylish bright and cool watercolors, nice focus, perfect text. A winrar is you. 9/10

[Rennir]

ganbaru: 8/10 Style's stayed the same even after all this time, eh?
Pat-chama: 8.5/10 Really like what you did with the typo but I think you could've chosen a better bg or adjusted it more because the depth and perspective gets screwed up when you look at everything holistically.

[Kotohono]

Akuma Kinomoto: 10/10 perfect with that new name, sig, and avatar combo , nothing else to say.
Rennir: Pretty good, did you add the SAO text on the sword or was it always there? Anyways pretty good 8.5/10.

[HeartlessEponine]

Konakaga 9/10 ;w; This one's quite cute x3

[ganbaru]

Akuma Kinomoto 8,6/10 good focus
Konakaga 8,5/10 nice looking
HeartlessEponine 7.9/10 too small

[ArabianLuffy]

ganbaru: 5\10
HeartlessEponine: 1\10
Konakaga: 5\10

__________________

[ganbaru]

ArabianLuffy 8,6/10 it would be interesting to see more green on the sig beside her eye, even if used only for effects.

[Triple_R]

Akuma Kinomoto - 8.9/10 Justin Timberlake would be proud of Homura. She's bringing sexy back.
Rennir - 8.8 ...And Asuna is looking rather nice herself. A border might make the sig even nicer, though.
Konakaga - 8.8 Very nice work by Auxilism there. Good matching gifs.
HeartlessEponine - 8.5 I agree with Ganbaru. It would be good if you could enlarge it some.
ArabianLuffy - 8.6 Again, I agree with Ganbaru. Very nice image, but could use a bit more of a color other than red. And I say that as someone who's favorite color is red.
ganbaru - 8.8/10 Lovely mixture of red, green, and whitish yellow. Very nice texture effect.

[DevilHighDxD]

Triple_R - 5/10 Sorry my friend, but with a loli like body and short hair that as much as you can get from me.

[RRW]

Triple_R 7/10 bit too simplistic
DevilHighDxD 8/10 the picture could be more up

[milan kyuubi]

Miko Miko: 8,4/10 It's a cute sig. Tho I think the blue color is to much. Never the less the border looks very good on it. maybe a little darker would be even better. But thats just my opinion!
Krytonis: 8,8/10 First you get brownie points for Kaneki sig! I like the setting and color disposition!
ganbaru: 9/10 You sigs always look more like paintings. I like that about your style! The colors are also used very effectively.
Unonithy: 7/10 It's good. But to simple. The girl imo should be more blended with bg. And the bg needed some more effects.
Akuma Kinomoto: 7,2/10 Simple, but I like the ecchi part!
Rennir: 10/10 Amazing! Ok I am a big fan of Asuna! xd And I am biased. But I really like it. The text is perfect. You get points for Asuna!
Konakaga: 9,5/10 I like the animation. And looking it. You can feel emotions those two characters express!
HeartlessEponine: 7/10 Nice idea. But simple just to small. making it larger would be great.
ArabianLuffy: 8,3/10 The effects are amazing. I like the whole red/black you got going there. Tho the girls face somehow feels of to me. Like it doesn't belong there idk...
Triple_R: 8/10 Cute and simple. When done good, sometimes that's enough.
DevilHighDxD: 8,9/10 I like it. It's not to simple or overly complex.
RRW: 8,2/10 I like the setting. But it it's to much "noise". The effects are done very good btv.

[ganbaru]

Triple_R 8.1/10 a bit too simple.
DevilHighDxD 8,2/10 remind me of my firsts sigs.
RRW 8,4/10 I kind of agree with milan kyuubi on this one.

[Triple_R]

DevilHighDxD - 8.6/10 Nice image, but I think it would be even better if it was slightly less bright.
RRW - 8.7/10 Good overall style.
milan kyuubi - 8.6/10 The text at the bottom seems a bit cutoff to me, though perhaps the problem is on my end. Otherwise, lovely image.

To those saying that my sig is too simple - Any specific suggestions? Do you think having "RRR" over on the side would help, in orange or blue text? The sig is intended to promote my two favorite anime characters of the past 4/5 years. Anything beyond that is secondary to me, but I'm certainly open to any suggestions, or anybody refining it if they wish.

[milan kyuubi]

Originally Posted by Triple_R

milan kyuubi - 8.6/10 The text at the bottom seems a bit cutoff to me, though perhaps the problem is on my end. Otherwise, lovely image.

Lol! The text below the image isn't part of the sig. It's a link to my twitter account. And the user who made the sig. And yes the text is cut in half, since those proportion lines were added to the forum!

[Akito Kinomoto]

milan kyuubi--It's slightly unbalanced toward the left, but that's a nice animation on the right to make up for it; really rewards the attentive. 8.4/10

Triple_R--There's an empty space on the right; shift the focus so the subjects are just off-center to make the asymmetry look intentional or balance out the blanks. Maybe a closer focus or a larger picture too; the size limit is 600x160, so there should be plenty of wiggle room to show a few more things. Text choice could stand to direct people to both shows though, and not just one. 8.29/10

[ganbaru]

Akuma Kinomoto 8,2/10 good picture used. I might had rotated it a little or cropped diferently but it's a question of personal taste.

[Rennir]

ganbaru: 8/10 I like the texture you used

[Akito Kinomoto]

Rennir--Borderless look is working, and there's enough going on at the right to make up for the text at the left. 8.6/10
ganbaru--8.4/10
Triple R--They really look like they're together, lovely font(s), and enough happening on the right to make up for the text. 8.8/10

[Clodial]

(Posting cuz I feel like getting heavily scrutinized BUT meh...)
Uhm... this is more, what does my logo look like, to you? (I use it on almost everything, so, any criticisms are welcome...)

anyways, since this is on top of mine: (since I feel like being a hipster, I'ma gonna use a 5-star system :P)
Akuma Kinomoto-- 4.3/5 -> I like the contrast between with the border and the web page's color. Also, with the background of the image. However, the blonde hair makes the text that runs over it hard to read, given that the text is also of a similar color to the background of the image. Regarding the text on the side, I like how you kept it blue since, like the border of the image, it contrasts nicely with the web page, making it easier to read...

Rennir-- 4.4/5 -> Now, this might just be me being a little too judgemental on the image and it being almost 2AM, here... Those eyes hurt... While, I like how the image, itself, has easy to read text, even the blue since it darkens out at the bottom and lightens near the top of the Z, just, the shade of the blue... Maybe my inner web designer is coming out, but the bright blue just isn't working. Maybe if the Z was the same color as the A? But, other than that, I like your sig. My bias is just more on my eye's comfort, given that I don't take too kindly to super bright things...

[Life's Swirl]

I don't exactly know if I did my signature right. Hope I did. ^_^;
Anywaaays....

Akuma Kinomoto- I love your sig because its softly inspiring and it also reminds of something my li'l sis would say. 5/5

Clodial- I can't quite put my finger on it, but your sig reminds me of a feeling I get just before I go to work. It's a feelin' like, "Goddamnit, I just wanna play more video games but I gotta go to work" so, 5/5 for illustrating it.