AnimeSuki Forums

sezen_atacan · 2007-04-05, 23:09

Has anyone actually watched both the DVD and TV version of the first two series?? I heard the DVD was better but would you call it a HUGE improvement? And since we are in the image thread does anyone have screenshots comparing both DVD and TV version???

Another thing is does anyone feel that the art in episode 5 of the first series is a bit off? Is this changed in the DVD version?

Riker · 2007-04-06, 00:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by guest

I am always amazed at how wonderful you guys' photoshop skills are.

That is one heck of stunning (in many ways) pic. I also would like to see what nanoha is like when she is mad mad. ha ha

Thanks, but I'm not the one who shopped it. ^^;;
I suck at photoshop, but good at finding weird random pics, like this:

"Why Lindy retired early"

:x

Quote:

Originally Posted by sezen_atacan

Has anyone actually watched both the DVD and TV version of the first two series?? I heard the DVD was better but would you call it a HUGE improvement? And since we are in the image thread does anyone have screenshots comparing both DVD and TV version???

Another thing is does anyone feel that the art in episode 5 of the first series is a bit off? Is this changed in the DVD version?

Here's the Nanoha A's DVD vs TV comparison.
http://lolipuni.com/list/review/nano...haAs_DVD1.html

Ottocycle · 2007-04-06, 01:04

LOL thats comedy gold...*pictures it with voices* Like in the Generic Discussion, Chrono's now being the Kyon to Nanoha's Haruhi(in the Legend of Galactic Heroes ep)[*Hides from LoGH fans, if any]

PS:Chrono's dark scraggly pupils a la Busou Renkin own.

Anymore? XD

Chaos2Frozen · 2007-04-06, 01:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Riker

Thanks, but I'm not the one who shopped it. ^^;;
I suck at photoshop, but good at finding weird random pics, like this:

"Why Lindy retired early"

Even though I've pictured it in my head a hundred times, seeing any variations of it is still funny

EDIT:

@humbug23
Actually, I've brought it up several times that Hayate is more suited to be the 'Haruhi' in this

Ottocycle · 2007-04-06, 01:16

True, and I've read your, and Skane's comments regarding that issue, but I doubt we have seen Hayate going, 'Zenryoku Zenkai!!' or other shounen power-ish quotes.

And that being an integral part of Haruhi's head-busting, straightforward ways, I'd say for just this aspect, Nanoha would fit better.

Hayate's more the strategist as well, maybe that can be seen from the team battle?

Riker · 2007-04-06, 01:23

Ramsus's latest sketches:

Poor Carol. ;___;

Shadow Angel · 2007-04-06, 02:10

Two of Fate, one of Hayate and one of Lutecia

MeganeShounen · 2007-04-06, 06:54

Last pic somehow reminds me of Disgaea, for some reason..

Demon Eyes · 2007-04-06, 08:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by Riker

Here's the Nanoha A's DVD vs TV comparison.
http://lolipuni.com/list/review/nano...haAs_DVD1.html

Hmmm...

Good thing I got the DVD version.

I have to re-watch it for I don't remember seeing this scene here:

Spoiler:

FallenAngel · 2007-04-06, 09:32

easy photoshoping

NA*NO*HA!

JediNight · 2007-04-06, 11:04

Takamachi Nan-to-ka!

The irony is that Takamachi is harder to say than Nanoha, so I don't know what Vita's problem is

Riker · 2007-04-06, 13:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by humbug23

Anymore? XD

I just found more 4komas by this artist and I must say I approve of his sense of humour.
These strips had me in stitches. :3

Spoiler for length:

Village Idiot · 2007-04-06, 13:52

^^
I demand translations

FallenAngel · 2007-04-06, 14:07

made me buy one >=(

Shadow Angel · 2007-04-06, 14:29

Riker · 2007-04-06, 15:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by Village Idiot

^^
I demand translations

I'll try my best. :x

Spoiler:

Panel 1:
Subaru: "Instructor! Your sacrifice will not be in vain! Leave the rest to me!"
Nanoha: "But I'm S+ rank..."

Panel 2:
Subaru + Teana: "Instructor! Investigator! Your sacrifices will not be in vain! Leave the rest to the two of us!"
Nanoha: "But I'm S+ rank..."

Panel 3:
Subaru + Teana + Caro + Erio: "Instructor! Investigator! Commander! Your sacrifices will not be in vain! Leave the rest to the four of us!"
Nanoha: "But I'm S+ rank..."

Panel 4:
From the old characters' perspective:
Nanoha: "But I'm S+ rank..."
Fate: "When they're using Game Shark (plot devices?), it doesn't matter what rank you are."

Panel 1:
Nanoha: "Good job, Subaru! Now leave the rest to me!"
Subaru: "Instructor is so awesome!"

Panel 2:
Nanoha + Fate: "Good job, Subaru, Teana! Now leave the rest to the two of us!"
Subaru: "Instructor is so awesome!"

Panel 3:
Nanoha + Fate + Hayate: "Good job, Subaru, Teana, Caro, Erio! Now leave the rest to the three of us!"
Subaru: "Instructor is so awesome!"

Panel 4:
From the new characters' perspective:
Subaru: "Instructor is so awesome!"
Teana: "Shut up!"

Panel 1:
Nanoha: "Let's go, Stars Squad! No holding back!"
Subaru + Teana: "Yes, Instructor!"
(Small) Boss: "How can you do this?"

Panel 2:
Nanoha + Fate: "Let's go, Stars Squad! Lightning Squad! No holding back!"
Subaru + Teana + Caro + Erio: "Yes, Instructor! Investigator"
(Mid) Boss: "How can you do this?"

Panel 3:
Nanoha + Fate + Hayate: "Let's go, Section 6 (6th division?)! No holding back!"
Rest: "Roger!"
(Final) Boss: "How can you do this?"

Panel 4:
From the bosses' perspective:
(small) Boss: "But I've only showed up for 10+ episodes..."
(Mid) Boss: "I have less than 10 episodes of screentime!"
(final) Boss: "...I'm defeated in 1 episode..."

Panel 1:
Nanoha: "Let's go, Stars Squad! No holding back!"
Chrono: "Stop! At this rate this country will..."

Panel 2:
Nanoha: "Let's go, Stars Squad! Lightning Squad! No holding back!"
Chrono: "Stop! At this rate this planet will..."

Panel 3:
Nanoha: "Let's go, Section 6 (6th division?)! No holding back!"
Chrono: "Stop! At this rate this dimension will..."

Panel 4:
From the Time-Space Administration Bureau' perspective:
Chrono: "You knew this was going to happen, that's why you stepped down, didn't you?"
Lindy: "My, my, you sure know how to talk now that you're all grown up."

Translations I'm not too sure of are bracketed (). :x

Village Idiot · 2007-04-06, 15:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by Riker

I'll try my best. :x

Spoiler:

Panel 1:
Subaru: "Instructor! Your sacrifice will not be in vain! Leave the rest to me!"
Nanoha: "But I'm S+ rank..."

Panel 2:
Subaru + Teana: "Instructor! Investigator! Your sacrifices will not be in vain! Leave the rest to the two of us!"
Nanoha: "But I'm S+ rank..."

Panel 3:
Subaru + Teana + Caro + Erio: "Instructor! Investigator! Commander! Your sacrifices will not be in vain! Leave the rest to the four of us!"
Nanoha: "But I'm S+ rank..."

Panel 4:
From the old characters' perspective:
Nanoha: "But I'm S+ rank..."
Fate: "When they're using Game Shark (plot devices?), it doesn't matter what rank you are."

Panel 1:
Nanoha: "Good job, Subaru! Now leave the rest to me!"
Subaru: "Instructor is so awesome!"

Panel 2:
Nanoha + Fate: "Good job, Subaru, Teana! Now leave the rest to the two of us!"
Subaru: "Instructor is so awesome!"

Panel 3:
Nanoha + Fate + Hayate: "Good job, Subaru, Teana, Caro, Erio! Now leave the rest to the three of us!"
Subaru: "Instructor is so awesome!"

Panel 4:
From the new characters' perspective:
Subaru: "Instructor is so awesome!"
Teana: "Shut up!"

Panel 1:
Nanoha: "Let's go, Stars Squad! No holding back!"
Subaru + Teana: "Yes, Instructor!"
(Small) Boss: "How can you do this?"

Panel 2:
Nanoha + Fate: "Let's go, Stars Squad! Lightning Squad! No holding back!"
Subaru + Teana + Caro + Erio: "Yes, Instructor! Investigator"
(Mid) Boss: "How can you do this?"

Panel 3:
Nanoha + Fate + Hayate: "Let's go, Section 6 (6th division?)! No holding back!"
Rest: "Roger!"
(Final) Boss: "How can you do this?"

Panel 4:
From the bosses' perspective:
(small) Boss: "But I've only showed up for 10+ episodes..."
(Mid) Boss: "I have less than 10 episodes of screentime!"
(final) Boss: "...I'm defeated in 1 episode..."

Panel 1:
Nanoha: "Let's go, Stars Squad! No holding back!"
Chrono: "Stop! At this rate this country will..."

Panel 2:
Nanoha: "Let's go, Stars Squad! Lightning Squad! No holding back!"
Chrono: "Stop! At this rate this planet will..."

Panel 3:
Nanoha: "Let's go, Section 6 (6th division?)! No holding back!"
Chrono: "Stop! At this rate this dimension will..."

Panel 4:
From the Time-Space Administration Bureau' perspective:
Chrono: "You knew this was going to happen, that's why you stepped down, didn't you?"
Lindy: "My, my, you sure know how to talk now that you're all grown up."

Translations I'm not too sure of are bracketed (). :x

LMAO XD XD XD

Ashlotte · 2007-04-06, 17:32

Haha thanks a whole lot for the translations riker. Those strips are cute as-is but I couldnt stop laughing after I read the translations.

*puts a cookie into the avatar*

Village Idiot · 2007-04-06, 17:38

Hopefully someone can scanslate those in english

JayF · 2007-04-06, 19:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Riker

I just found more 4komas by this artist and I must say I approve of his sense of humour.
These strips had me in stitches. :3

Spoiler for length:

Source of 4komas?

2007-04-06, 02:10	Link #1687
Shadow Angel Hellraiser Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Within The Shadows of Darkness Age: 41	Two of Fate, one of Hayate and one of Lutecia __________________

2007-04-06, 13:52	Link #1693
Village Idiot Fate/ Stay Night Join Date: Jun 2003	^^ I demand translations __________________ Sig removed by Mod (xris) because at 65,726 bytes it exceeds the limits as requested in the forum rules.

2007-04-06, 14:29	Link #1695
Shadow Angel Hellraiser Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Within The Shadows of Darkness Age: 41	__________________

2007-04-06, 17:32	Link #1698
Ashlotte Clockwork Join Date: Oct 2006	Haha thanks a whole lot for the translations riker. Those strips are cute as-is but I couldnt stop laughing after I read the translations. puts a cookie into the avatar __________________ No matter what enemy. No matter what ally. Mowing everything down with maximum destructive power. That is... "The White Devil of the Administration Bureau"

2007-04-06, 17:38	Link #1699
Village Idiot Fate/ Stay Night Join Date: Jun 2003	Hopefully someone can scanslate those in english __________________ Sig removed by Mod (xris) because at 65,726 bytes it exceeds the limits as requested in the forum rules.

2007-04-05, 23:09	Link #1681
sezen_atacan Senior Member Join Date: Feb 2007	Has anyone actually watched both the DVD and TV version of the first two series?? I heard the DVD was better but would you call it a HUGE improvement? And since we are in the image thread does anyone have screenshots comparing both DVD and TV version??? Another thing is does anyone feel that the art in episode 5 of the first series is a bit off? Is this changed in the DVD version?

2007-04-06, 01:04	Link #1683
Ottocycle Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2006 Age: 37	LOL thats comedy gold...pictures it with voices Like in the Generic Discussion, Chrono's now being the Kyon to Nanoha's Haruhi(in the Legend of Galactic Heroes ep)[*Hides from LoGH fans, if any] PS:Chrono's dark scraggly pupils a la Busou Renkin own. Anymore? XD

2007-04-06, 01:16	Link #1685
Ottocycle Senior Member Join Date: Jul 2006 Age: 37	True, and I've read your, and Skane's comments regarding that issue, but I doubt we have seen Hayate going, 'Zenryoku Zenkai!!' or other shounen power-ish quotes. And that being an integral part of Haruhi's head-busting, straightforward ways, I'd say for just this aspect, Nanoha would fit better. Hayate's more the strategist as well, maybe that can be seen from the team battle?

2007-04-06, 01:23	Link #1686
Riker Peek a boo Graphic Designer Join Date: Dec 2005	Ramsus's latest sketches: Poor Carol. ;___;

2007-04-06, 06:54	Link #1688
MeganeShounen Huh? Join Date: Nov 2004	Last pic somehow reminds me of Disgaea, for some reason..

2007-04-06, 09:32	Link #1690
FallenAngel ~ I must protect.... Join Date: Jan 2007	easy photoshoping NANOHA!

2007-04-06, 11:04	Link #1691
JediNight キズランダム Join Date: Apr 2003	Takamachi Nan-to-ka! The irony is that Takamachi is harder to say than Nanoha, so I don't know what Vita's problem is

2007-04-06, 14:07	Link #1694
FallenAngel ~ I must protect.... Join Date: Jan 2007	made me buy one >=(