Rate That Signature!

[Hs Vi Germania]

Kelisidina: It's good one at all. I am just unsure whether you really need that caption. 9/10

[ganbaru]

KimmyChan 8,2/10 Too black for my taste
Fujikira 8,3/10 interesting
Fraility 9,2/10 great art and coloring
Kelisidina 8,5/10 I would just remouve the '' la lala la...'' thing

[Hs Vi Germania]

ganbaru: It's a really nice one. I am impressed. 9/10

[Kelisidina]

His Vi Germania: 7/10. Nice effects, but feels empty without a more tagged background, text font and color is out of place.

[The Chaos]

Kelisidina..Nice Sig you have..9/10

[KimmyChan]

Kelisidina - 10/10 Kawaii
Hs Vi Germania - 10/10 (Shock horror)
ganbaru - 10/10 (Shock horror again)
The Chaos - 10/10 Still mightily impressed

[The Chaos]

Kimmy-Chan..that look Good..8.5/10

[KimmyChan]

Fujikira - 10/10 (I almost missed yours out on this page)

[ganbaru]

Kelisidina 8,8/10 nice one
KimmiChan 8,2/10 those kind of sigs are not of my liking.

[KimmyChan]

ganbaru - 10/10

(Fair enough, I appreciate your opinion & honesty all the same though)

[grylsyjaeger]

ganbaru: You're getting really good at this, ganbaru. 9.5/10
KimmyChan: Hardcore J-Rock? 8/10
Kelisidina: Very beautiful. Love the border. 9/10
Frailty: Cute girl, really like the way the lighting is strong to the left. 9.5/10
Fujikira: Interesting collage you have going there. Meshes together nicely. 8.5/10

[Frozy-chan]

fallschirmjager
Yuri. o_o;; Ah well, it looks neat.
8.5/10

[KimmyChan]

fallschirmjager - 10/10 (Yep, that's Girugamesh for ya)
Frozy-chan - 9/10

[Kelisidina]

KimmyChan: 8/10 lacks background and it's a bit too long for my taste.

[KimmyChan]

Kelisidina - 10/10

[Kelisidina]

KimmyChan: 8/10

Guys, how's the standard of rating here? I mean, I wore this set on Janime and the highest I got was an 8/10.

[ganbaru]

Kelisidina 8,8/10 great color for the background
Frozy-chan 8,2/10 is the head attached to nothing?

Originally Posted by Kelisidina

Guys, how's the standard of rating here? I mean, I wore this set on Janime and the highest I got was an 8/10.

Everyone have his own standard for rating. For example, somes peoples are very influenced by who are on the sig, others by the effects or the artwork etc... Sometime you can even expect the reaction of the others just by experience.

[Hs Vi Germania]

Kelisidina: It's anything about goddess or something like that, right? 8/10

[Fujikira]

KimmyChan I liked the last design you had 8.5/10
Hs Vi Germania The colors kind of seem out of normality, but it somehow works 8/10

[Hs Vi Germania]

Fujikira: Which of the always changing signatures did you mean? xD 8/10