Rate That Signature!

[ganbaru]

Haruyan 8,4/10 simple but the artwork is good

[Rikimtasu]

@Haruyan 9/10 Nice render used there,by the way,can you PM me the full ver of the render?
@Hs Vi Germania 8.9/10

[Shadow_maste]

Riki - 8/10
Haruyan - 8.5/10 Very nice artwork.
Drake - 9.5/10 Very great quality, and the artwork is very cool.
Hs Vi Germania- 8/10
Katocchi - 8.5/10

[Katocchi]

Haruyan - 8/10 Cute Simple Siggie .. :3

[Dist]

-The Chaos. Lol where's is that from ? I'll give you minus points though for having exact same animation as your sig and avvy. 6/10.

- Drake. Great as always. Girls with guns <3. What anime/manga/other are your avvy and sig from at though o.O. 9/10

[Mon Cheri]

Rikimtasu: Looks good 8/10
Shadow_maste: Mikuu! 7.5/10
Katocchi: I don't like Nunnally D: That's not going to change the rating though 8/10
Dist: I like it. Especially the background 8.7/10

[ganbaru]

Malin 9.2/10 love it, especially the choice of the color.

[grylsyjaeger]

Drake: 9.5/10, cute girls with guns. Win.

Originally Posted by Dist

- Drake. Great as always. Girls with guns <3. What anime/manga/other are your avvy and sig from at though o.O. 9/10

I'd like to know this too!

Haruyan: Very interesting. I guess that butterfly is a template of some kind since I've seen it floating around here a few times.

My only suggestion is that the signature could use some sort of boarder to help break up the outline of the character from the forum background.

8.5/10

[Sinfully Naomi]

Haruyan~ 8/10 I think it would look absolutely perfect if the forum's skin was black.

[capture]

Sinfully Naomi ~ just asking is that rena? 9/10
fallschirmjager ~ interesting 8/10
ganbaru ~ just as always ganbaru's work 8/10

Mine hmmmmm nahh nevermind


__________________

[Sinfully Naomi]

Yes, yes it is.

Yours is wonderful. 9.5/10

[Katocchi]

capture - 9/10

[Haruyan]

Sinfully Naomi - 8.7/10 Might look better without the glow on the frame.
Katocchi - 9/10 very pretty

[Sinfully Naomi]

Actually without the glow, the border doesn't go to well. IMO at least.

[Haruyan]

I just don't think it fits the picture very well.....maybe the glow in red? Or a thicker line for the border?

[ganbaru]

Haruyan 7.9/10 why such a focus?
capture 9/10 interesting background

Originally Posted by capture

ganbaru ~ just as always ganbaru's work 8/10

How am I supposed to interpret this ?

[escimo]

Haruyan - 7/10 - In a way it's intriguing but essentially just a crop of a render.
ganbaru - 7/10 - Using that much text in a sig is a design challenge. Doesn't really work this time around. Remove the renders from the background, they're just distracting.
capture - 9/10 - Good colors, good design, good composition. Yes a good sig. Not a huge fan of the font used for Asuna though.
Malin - 9.5/10 - Can't think of any complaints. Good job.

[Katocchi]

ganbaru - 7.5/10
escimo - 9.8/10

[grylsyjaeger]

escimo: Oh bloody hell that's too good. 10/10

Mind if I ask the source?

[ganbaru]

Escimo 9.8/10 few are at your level, good luck for the SOTM

Originally Posted by escimo

.
ganbaru - 7/10 - Using that much text in a sig is a design challenge. Doesn't really work this time around. Remove the renders from the background, they're just distracting.

You are rightabout that , I was about 50/50 about the background about keeping it simple or not, I should have asked some suggestion.