Nanoha Manga Discussion

[prescience]

Lolicon Rin? That's an ... interesting thought

[Sakome]

Rin should turn into her Mahou Shoujo form with Ilya and team up with Nanoha and Fate! When is this spinoff supposed to come out anyway?

[Demi.]

I really cant see why Nanoha/Fate and Saber/Rin would clash in the first place. If I had to guess, it's probably a misunderstanding and they end up fighting the true 'mastermind' together. Unless they make something up. Nanoha and Fate could join the holy grail war~ They better replenish their mana well after each and every battle.

[RadiantBeam]

Originally Posted by Demi.

I really cant see why Nanoha/Fate and Saber/Rin would clash in the first place.

Rule of Cool. Any reason is a good reason as long as we get to see them fight each other, heh. Though who ultimately wins will be iffy with how loved both sets of characters are.

[Demi.]

mM maybe, though you'd think neither would fight without very good reasons given their personalities. Rin aside

[RadiantBeam]

Well, we'll have to see how it's all explained when the manga starts running and producing chapters. Until then we're kind of just playing a guessing game.

[Demi.]

Which should be tomm. if I'm not mistaken.

[00-Raiser]

Sure would be something if Rin had Zeltrech with her. That thing basically fires off Starlight Breakers fueled by alternate realities with zero time lag.

[Keroko]

Originally Posted by Demi.

I really cant see why Nanoha/Fate and Saber/Rin would clash in the first place. If I had to guess, it's probably a misunderstanding and they end up fighting the true 'mastermind' together. Unless they make something up. Nanoha and Fate could join the holy grail war~ They better replenish their mana well after each and every battle.

Random reason from the top of my head: Saber and Rin are fighting in the Holy Grail war, the TSAB detects the magical combat and sends Nanoha and Fate to investigate. They find Rin and Saber and try to stop them, and with neither master nor servant willing to stop fighting in the war, combat ensues.

[Fuyu no Sora]

Originally Posted by Keroko

Random reason from the top of my head: Saber and Rin are fighting in the Holy Grail war, the TSAB detects the magical combat and sends Nanoha and Fate to investigate. They find Rin and Saber and try to stop them, and with neither master nor servant willing to stop fighting in the war, combat ensues.

It's a bit of a shame that it's not following Heaven's Feel but Unlimited Blade Works. I'd seriously like to see what Nanoha and Fate would do against Saber Alter.

Still, if we get to see Rho Aias, Caladbolg and Rider taking off her Gorgon Breaker, I'll be a happy camper. :3

[RadiantBeam]

Originally Posted by Fuyu no Sora

It's a bit of a shame that it's not following Heaven's Feel but Unlimited Blade Works. I'd seriously like to see what Nanoha and Fate would do against Saber Alter.

I think Heaven's Feel is a little too dark to mesh with the MGLN universe. I think it would be epic in so many different ways if they did it, but it would also probably rob Nanoha and Fate of their innocence and kindness much sooner.

... Actually, that's not such a bad idea...

[Rising Dragon]

... and RB's love affair with angst goes into full swing once more. >.>

[00-Raiser]

Heaven's Feel is just too awesome to place in the same league as Nanoha. Fate and Nanoha would get consumed by the shadows and that would be the end of that. Even the mighty Gilgamesh was nothing before Sakura's might!

[Kikaifan]

No way, one of them would spend the whole season making friends with Sakura and then she'd... feel bad when she ate them. And stop. It worked in A's.

[Sheba]

Originally Posted by 00-Raiser

Heaven's Feel is just too awesome to place in the same league as Nanoha. Fate and Nanoha would get consumed by the shadows and that would be the end of that. Even the mighty Gilgamesh was nothing before Sakura's might!

Actually, when you think about it, the sheer despair Heaven's Feel is a good occasion for Nanoha and Fate to have their beliefs, goals and means to achieve those questioned. Kinda like how Vash's quest for Love & Peace have gone downhill the instant Legato entered the scene.

[Nya~n]

them runts need a reality check. because the world isn't all about friendship and Starlight Breakers. nothing like angst to slap them out of their ignorance

[RadiantBeam]

Originally Posted by Nya~n

them runts need a reality check. because the world isn't all about friendship and Starlight Breakers. nothing like angst to slap them out of their ignorance

I approve of this idea oh so much. Going through Heaven's Feel would make the cast of MGLN wonder why they felt so damned bad for Fate when confronted with Sakura.

[Demi.]

One tragedy does not negate another.

[00-Raiser]

But it does put things in context. Some one might think it's the end of the world because they broke a nail, but when they see some one else with an amputated finger, a broken nail is hardly a big deal.

But yeah, take what happened to Fate, crank it up to 9011, and you have Sakura's life. Fate she be thankful she got away with just a whipping

[Sheba]

Originally Posted by 00-Raiser

But it does put things in context. Some one might think it's the end of the world because they broke a nail, but when they see some one else with an amputated finger, a broken nail is hardly a big deal.

But yeah, take what happened to Fate, crank it up to 9011, and you have Sakura's life. Fate she be thankful she got away with just a whipping

Like comparing 1st Half of 1st Season Jewel Seed Sealing Nanoha with the Winchester Bros.

I'd personally watch all the shit the brothers goes through, any day of the week.