Rate That Signature!

[CXC]

panzrfan: 8.6/10

[Ryosuke]

So many people's siggy got removed
~

Cyz: 10/10 - Ama-san = full points *bias rating*
panzerfan: 7.5/10 - Love the soft colour tone but the white moving blob in the backgound is kinda weird
CXC: 8.5/10 - My eyes are distracted and couldn't give a proper rating
~

New nyoro~n siggy... spend more time making the first panel than the actual sig itself

[NightwishFan]

lol like it. 10/10

[KiNA]

@ Panzer .. Not bad.. but still the colors >.<

@ CXC .. Good.. Nice name placement.. tht guy in the box could use a sharpen a bit tho.. too blurry

@ NightwishFan .. LOL .. is the NW in ur name the mod here? Simple animated sig .. looking it too long makes my eyes go e_e

@ Ryoo .. LOL, you and your 4 skooma strips =3 .. Ryooron~~ Nice 3D cheese btw

@ KiNA .. yey .. Kaede .. Much much better animation from the previous Ginsama ..

[Pellissier]

Ryosuke: Gotta love those Ryoro~n signatures 9/10

KiNA: Her neck is pixelated, couldn't you photoshop it a bit? It's not very good since it seems to be the only flawed part on the whole sign ... You could have put a bit more effort on the bg, while the animation is really nice. 8/10

NightwishFan: I don't like signs with psychedelic effects like that. They're eyes-hurting. An 8:1 ratio between width and height also doesn't seem to work. 5/10

panzerfan: agreed with KiNA. No rating since considering it a work in progress.

[panzerfan]

KiNA: 9/10. I am amazed at your splitting technique, although its Achille's heel turns out to be the differences in compression standards. It a great answer to use only what you need to animate. I stole that idea and edited my Ayu signature, thus easing the woes of the ugly head of compression.

I recommand you to turn the lower piece into into 2 pieces instead, and isolate the moving sign.

Pellissier: 8.3/10

[Cyz]

KiNa: Another Kaede sig? Well, not that I'm complaining or anything. 8/10

-> New sig made by Cats. This Lucia Nabashi from Venus Versus Virus

[Zerokule]

Sarcasteak - Love the chibi Haruhi! MOE 9/10

[Riker]

@ KiNA: I think if the text colour was white it'll contrast better with the bg, no? 9/10

@ Cyz: Cats will kill me for this but I prefer a more interesting bg. :x 8/10

@ Zerokule: I really like the quotes, but I don't really know how it relates to the bg. 7/10


Please rate this sig I made in the Kanon avatar/sig thread instead of my current sig. :x

[Pellissier]

Riker: it's very nice because by manually doing the effect it ends up to be smooth (and that scene was so problematic). And biased yay for animated! 9/10

[Nightfly]

riker:
nice effect you did there 8/10

Pellissier:
7,5/10

[leofish]

the chibi haruhi sig is megas win....

nightfly - 7/10 ; small and too the point, but being at that size, the scanlines create too much visual tension and overwhelm the image


I want one of the phones from manabi straight :X

[Cheerful]

@Riker: Thats a really nice effect teach me to do it 9/10
@Pellissier: I like the loop animation 8/10
@Night: Its kinda small and dont see much really 6/10
@leo: the renders are nice but...why orange? lol 7.5/10

[Cyz]

Nightfly: a little small no? 7/10
Riker: I like the animation as always. Too bad Mai's img was cut off. 8/10
leofish: It would be nice if the top isn't cut off. Still, a nice sig. 7/10
Cheerful: Blurry but points for the cool BG and the nice pic. 7/10

[KiNA]

@ Zerokule .. Nice quote.. but the pic is too blurry

@ Riker .. Fail for unreadable kanji -.- .. Also I prefer for you to extend the animated part so it reach both side =_= .. Half head got a minus point too jk =3.. GJ on fitting it under 50K

@ Nightfly .. too small 3_3

@ leo .. too plain x_x

@ cheerfull .. too blurry @_@

@ KiNA .. too bright >,<

__________________

[Takeru]

Riker~ very nice, but use a better japanese font, it's making my eyes bleed. Even after 4 years of seeing my own handwritten kanji. :x 7/10

KiNA~ hey, I know that brush! Only thing I have against your's is that the brushes make her face look like it's been attacked by a paper shreader 7/10

Cyz~ I'm still disappointed I can't see your's, especially since you say it's VVV.

Sarcasteak~ why you smoosh roomaji together? Makes it hard to read. Plus for chibis though. 8/10

O_o I feel like I'm being over critical on my ratings today.... -.-;;;

[Zoahr]

To tell the truth, if I had to rate people's signatures, it would be rather difficult.
Most of them are well-made, impressive at times.

All Kanon signatures however merit a 9/10, if it was only for me.
All signatures with the picture of any girls also need to earn 9/10.
Since most them are rather cute to watch.
Well, I don't give a 10/10, because I don't trust perfection. Altho, I may be very very surprised to see one .

If I had half the knowledge to make a picture to put as signature,
I doubt that I can do better than most people there.
Well, if I really need to make a rating for a signature, then here.

Panzerfan 9/10. Kanon girls, also my favorite, shiori .

About my own signature... they say a picture worth a thousand words.
Well, I don't want to be that vast, so I wanted to focus on those words :P.
But actually, I am searching for a proper signature (picture) and avatar.

[GuidoHunter_Toki]

Nightfly~I think it's okay. 7/10

[Cyz]

@ Raiju32: You can't see my sig? Hmm, I can see it just perfectly and so are the others. Maybe your PC is blocking it or something?

KiNa: I like your last one better. 8/10
Raiju32: 8/10

[Wandy]

Kira - 7.5/10 the sig looks nice...I prefer not having the arrows above her face rather have it behind her face

Cyz - 7/10 lol enough said :P

Cheerful - 7/10 toy with the sharpen function XD it's too blurry


P.S booo I don't know why there are white "borders" on my png avvy >_>

2nd P.S. I'm using firefox T_Ti dont know how it's showing these white "borders" XD