Rate That Signature!

[herbert]

@Riker - Holy ****, one of my favourite scene from PaniPoni. I can't help, a direct 10/10.

Edit:
@Kira_Naruto Perhaps you are right. I am a big Kagami fan, so I may really do it... Anyway, I did another more-chewing one, still AnimeSuki-friendly, you can see yourself how many frames are there.


2nd Edit:
@Pellissier
I use the 34-frame one only because I want to let her, the diet girl, eat as quickly as possible. Kagami, eat more, grow heavier!

[Pellissier]

Cyz: I really liked your previous sign, which I could't manage to rate .. this one is a step behind, but it's not bad either ^^ 7/10

ShadowVlican: Yay for Bokura ga Ita! But really, why all that noise ? ... and the text is sort of plain, something more stilish would fit better. A bit of bias rating for the choice of the scene and characters. 6/10

herbert: (and KiNA too) A gif shouldn't be judged by its number of frames alone. It's easy, when the sequence has little wided motion and the size only 100x100. However I prefer the 49 frames one because the movement looks more natural. So 8/10 to the one you posted and 7/10 to the one you're using ^^

[deathreape98]

riker: 8/10 for it being ufnny
kira naruto: 8/10 shes cute

[Cyz]

@ deathreape98: points for having Saber in it. Minus because the quality is a little bad and other stuffs. 6/10

[ShadowVlican]

Originally Posted by ChaosTheory

@!ShadowVilican!
Nice and simple,very cute too.
8/10

thanks

Originally Posted by ~Tsukuyomi

@ShadowVlican
Too much noise... 4/10

Originally Posted by Pellissier

ShadowVlican: Yay for Bokura ga Ita! But really, why all that noise ? ... and the text is sort of plain, something more stilish would fit better. A bit of bias rating for the choice of the scene and characters. 6/10

i was trying to use noise to portray the sad emotions throughout the anime... if you have another idea please let me know!

as for the text, i guess it's preference, i'd rather let the picture do the talking a picture is worth a .........

@Cyz
7/10: nicely framed, minimal text.... too bad i dunno who she is

[Cyz]

@ ShadowVlican: It's C.C from Code Geass.

@ ShadowVlican: I like the pic. I never seen Bokura ga Ita though. Anyway, the whole noise thing (or whatever you wanna call it) is a little distracting and it's taking the attention away from the img IMO. 6/10

@ Tsukuyomi: The "Shut" part is harder to see. Perhaps making it a little lighter will do. 6/10

[MoMo ^.^]

Cyz: 9/10 shes quite pretty. i like her green hair.
Islaya: 7/10 cute. alot of pink though.
Azami: 7/10 cute aswell. though theres alot of color.
Quiltygerax: 7/10 cute a bit scary though. lol.
#Asprek8#: 7/10 very nice. beautiful eyes.
Shadowangel: 9/10 i like it. quite lovly.
KaWaitress: 8/10 funny. though theres alot going on
Tsukuyomi: 8/10 it's funny. i like her face.
ChaosTheory: 7/10 looks like hes really thinking. lol
Riker: 8/10 love it. its extreamly funny
Kira Naruto: 7/10 funny. very colorful.

[piro-pin]

ShadowVlican - 6/10, I agree with Cyz, the noise thing is distracting. XD;;

Cyz - 8/10, delicious C.C. *___* Points for that, and it's just really cute in general.

MoMo ^.^ - 6/10, It's cute but it really doesn't hold my attention~.

[ChaosTheory]

Changed my sig. Something that isn't stolen.
@piro-pin-Whoah. That is sweet beyond belief. Everything fits perfectly. 9/10
@MoMo ^.^ :Heh,nice,the background's kinda plain though. 8/10

[kira_lacusXX]

ChaosTheory: OBJECTION! it's eye-catching all right! Bit plain and more like picture than a sig, and it would be cooler if the white background is transparent

piro-pin: oou, I like it a lot! the writing and the clouds and random patterns on the sky is a nice touch and the image is cropped in just the right place the colours are also very pretty!

MoMo ^.^: it's cute but I think you can do more with the background maybe your name too? welcome to AS by the way

Cyz: C.C!! I see you're going for the plain and simple sigs these days. Name could do with another font, but its good anyways


I thought this image was really cute, so yeaupp here it is! (As you can see in my avatar, I'm supporting Ichigo ;3 I've always liked strawberries better than oranges anyways.) The text is a bit blurry I know, but that's just the way I want it to look

@Mueti (bottom), yeah I'm looking at it.. the black borders don't really match for me either after looking at it for awhile. Changed

[Mueti]

ShadowVlican: Not too fond of the amount of noise...also the fonds are quite plain 5/10
Cyz: Clean image, I'd prefer a different color for your name in the sig, not really sure which though 7/10
MoMo ^.^: Looks cute enough but somewhat random 6/10
piro-pin: Strangely yellowish and too bright 4/10
ChaosTheory: ok-ish quality, a transparent background would be better than the white one. Plus I don't particularly like the subject 4/10
kira_lacusXX: I'm not too sure about the thick black border at the top and at the bottom, other than that it looks too white to me 6/10

[ChaosTheory]

[changed forthe last and final time]
@kira lacusXX:Heh,sweet,funny as hell,I don't see anything really wrong with it. 9/10
@Mueti:Cute.The background is very nice expecially,hard to make out the blue text though. 8/10

[SweetHoney]

KiLa: sweet 9/10

Riker: Aww 10/10

KiNa: Pretty nice 10/10

BEFORE you rate mine I'm well aware the tiny speckles around Mais bunny ears but l i can't do anything about it so please don't go OMG speckels minus rating by so much. Kay thx for yr time hope i didn't sound harsh

[KaWaitress]

Apparently giving out high scores to everyone has become a sign of weakness xD

kira_lacusXX: Nice overall, feels like it has overlay set on it. 7/10

Mueti: very crisp and refreshing, borders + UFO = win 7/10

SweetHoney: I hardly noticed the specks around her ears, since this is a white BG forum afterall. The bunny girl seems somewhat squished though, but the BG is very well made. 8.5/10

[Necrodeath]

Originally Posted by SweetHoney

BEFORE you rate mine I'm well aware the tiny speckles around Mais bunny ears but l i can't do anything about it so please don't go OMG speckels minus rating by so much. Kay thx for yr time hope i didn't sound harsh

OMG speckels! Minus rating by 6!
I'm j/k of course.

I've always liked the idea of rain in a signature, never quite got it to work properly though.
Having said that, I think it's not perfect in your signature either
Other than the rain though, it looks quite good (and you're 13...I remember when I was 13...yeah...let's not go there)

So I'll give it a 4/10! (Nah 7.5/10 )

So yeah, it's been a while since I've been here. Was surprised to see my account still alive ^.^
Because I've been gone for a long time, I have absolutely no idea what sig I have...

Let's check!
*Clicks "Submit Reply"*

Not the one I want ratings for to be honest :P so I'm changing it ^_^

[xxmimixx]

@Everyone: All of you guys signatures are awsome. The average I will give you guys (since I wasn't on here for a while), umm... about 8/10 because some were kinda weak (like mines j/k).

[Cyz]

Originally Posted by kira_lacusXX

Cyz: C.C!! I see you're going for the plain and simple sigs these days.

That's because I'm still learning KiNa's quick mask tutorial...thing. So far, I haven't mastered it...yet So for now, cropping the img to a sig is the best I could do

@ kira_lacusXX: quite the funny img. Poor Rukia got stuck in the middle 8/10

@ piro-pin: Brings back memories....8/10

[KiNA]

LOL.. take it easy, cropping takes skills too

@ cyz .. Since you are now making your own, .. cropping work is good, you have the eye to get a good capture.. the picture itself is meh .. but then again, I prefer fanart which stay close to the original.. with the exception of tan/chibified version.. You gonna need more font collection too .. CC's twins looks kinda flat here =/ .. your previous yuffie/lulu sig crop is an excellent crop sig btw ^^b

@ mimi ... O_O .. lots of pwetty faces =3

@ Necro .. stars overload IMO ..

@ KaWai .. .. at least erase those on her face laa =/

[Cyz]

@ KiNa: Lol! Thanx for the advice I'll keep working on my....cropping skills She looks flat? Well, yeah, I guess she is.

@ Necrodeath: the big BG and the small img is making the entire sig a bit empty. 6/10

@ mimi_girl: 7/10

[kira_lacusXX]

Originally Posted by Cyz

[color=#339966][font=comic sans ms]That's because I'm still learning KiNa's quick mask tutorial...thing. So far, I haven't mastered it...yet So for now, cropping the img to a sig is the best I could do

@ kira_lacusXX: quite the funny img. Poor Rukia got stuck in the middle 8/10

ooh, the quick mask! I learned that from KiNa too! It's really easy after awhile, and right after I learned it a made a gazillion sigs with it.. kinda got bored fo it after awhile :/
haha, and I think they are fighting for Rukia, go Ichigoooo


KiNa: hearts! I like the effect on it I like all the different colous and th erandom light streaks :]

mimi_girl: I like where you put all the four girls, but too bad the first one's elbow's cut off I think if your name and border were a lighter, less bright, green it would be even better! Cute :3

Necrodeath: I agree with KiNa, stars overload xS There would be more focus on the person if the sig was less wide I like the font ^^b

KaWai (Can I call you that?): I like all the swirls and lines and the right side gives kinda a traveling in time feel. It would be even better if her face was clear and your name was more curved with the background kinda so you can see all of it but overall it great!