Rate That Signature!

[Emerald Emblem]

Natsuki, it's a really nice looking signature. 9.2/10

Ganbarou, little has changed from the last one I rated. However i think both avatar and signature have improved. 8.1/10

[Hs Vi Germania]

Natsuki Hyuga: 8/10

[Chaho-Chi]

Natsuki Hyuga: 9.5/10 Nice signature
ganbaru: 9.4/10 You really have improved, but you keep on using the same colors over and over again.

[K. Yamato]

HS VI: Only complaint I have is the text, I can just barely understand it since it's your username of course but still nice 7/10 ^^

Ayu-smepai: Nice higurashi siggy, only complaint with this one is the extraction almost seems too sharp (like you just used the magic wand tool for it, which can be good sometimes but only if it's pure white). 6/10

[UltimaWolf]

K. Yamato: Kos-mos fan-ism I really like the techno feel to it, too bad it wasnt more colorful but it fits the feel. 9/10

[Evil Rick]

Natsuki Hyuga: That's an original style 8/10
ganbaru: Don't know which efect you used with the render but it makes it look LD D: 6/10
Hs Vi Germania: It's really good, can I ask the source? 9/10
ayu-smepai: Kinda too dark 7.5/10
K. Yamato: It looks really good 9/10
UltimaWolf: Funny 8/10

[K. Yamato]

Ultimawolf: Haha thanks, it was supposed to be desaturated to a point so that it would depict her personality. Anyways back on topic I love your C.C siggy, I'm such a hardcore CC fan + animated? Bonus points. 9.2/10
Evil Rick: I like that sig it looks awesome with the incantation circle (or is it? haha) 8/10

[KimmyChan]

Natsuki Hyuga - 9.5/10
ganbaru 10/10
Emerald Emblem - 10/10
Hs Vi Germania - 10/10
ayu-smepai - 9.5/10
K. Yamato - 10/10
UltimaWolf - 10/10
Evil Rick - 10/10

[ganbaru]

Hs Vi Germania 9/10 a bit hard to read
UltimaWolf I think I rated this one before ...
Evil Rick 8,8/10 intersting

Originally Posted by Evil Rick

ganbaru: Don't know which efect you used with the render but it makes it look LD D: 6/10

A little bit of tecture than the render and some brightening. I intended to make it look as a old drawing, is that a succes ?

[Hs Vi Germania]

K. Yamato: just 7/10 for me? however, I like your sig. The back ground fits the person very well. 8/10
UltimaWolf: Is that C.C.? I'm really not sure about it. ^^ 8/10
Evil Rick: I can't tell what it is. The signature itself is good but I don't really like that thing. 8/10

The source? It was just a random pic. Dunno if it's based on an anime or not.

Spoiler for Evil Rick Request:

[Haladflire65]

Hs Vi Germania:I really like the monochrome colours, and it has a nice layout. 9/10
ganbaru: A little too much text, but I like the green colouring. 7.5/10

[Katocchi]

Hs Vi Germania - 9/10

[Hs Vi Germania]

Haladflire65: Simple but nice. 8/10
Katocchi: It's better than the one by Halad. What shall I do? Hm well, I give you 9/10.

[KimmyChan]

Haladflire65 - 8.5/10

[Evil Rick]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

A little bit of tecture than the render and some brightening. I intended to make it look as a old drawing, is that a succes ?

I think no

If you're looking for that style, try this one out

http://forums.animesuki.com/showpost.php?p=1703057

Kimmy Chan: Geishas ... but looks LD 6/10
Haladfire65: Simple but efective 7/10

[KimmyChan]

Evil Rick - 10/10

[K. Yamato]

Aw HS VI, the only reason I rated it a 7 was because the text kills the sig, when you have something that stands out more than the scan than it can ruin it but it's still a good score!

KimmyChan: Heck yes! Ghost hunt wins! I love that show, 7.5/10 Basic but right to the point! =D

[ganbaru]

KimmyChan 8,4/10 look like some kind of pub
Haladflire65 8,3/10 nice

[Haladflire65]

I finally chose one to settle on...

Evil Rick: Great colours and layout. 10/10
KimmyChan: It's simple, but I like it. 8/10
K. Yamato: Really nice effects, but kinda empty at the sides. 9.5/10

[grylsyjaeger]

Haladflire65: Seems a little row res. Interesting image though. 8/10