AnimeSuki Forums

Keimaru · 2007-01-16, 05:48

yeah Saber FTW

Skeithis · 2007-01-16, 08:29

Wait a moment. Why has Archer so many votes?
Even that drunken irish shorthair is better =(

*voted for gil , saber and sakura*

mlai · 2007-01-16, 14:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skeithis

Wait a moment. Why has Archer so many votes?

GAR factor.

HurricaneHige · 2007-01-16, 16:49

Saber +1
<3 Saber

BlackIce'd · 2007-02-10, 20:32

CHARACTER BASHING TIME!!!!

Meh. Saber is SOOO Pasé... It would be obvious that she'd be popular being the main character in the animé. That's why I prefer the game(Haven't played it yet, waiting for English translation), where Saber is a secondary character as the other folks.

Then, Rin. What's so interesting? She gets PWNED hard At the last part of the animé, maybe the only part that interesting and she was protagonizing it... (Or perhaps the scene at the abandoned house in Berserker's Act...)

Archer. Shirou from the Future, He kicked Berserker five times (Or four?) Asides from having the knowledge of the future of what would happen and HOW EXACTLY to motivate his past self to do as he wanted, and his UBW, he has nothing more interesting.

I won't go into the Ilya territory, since I really can't say something that would hurt someone's feelings (At least more than what I already did...). It's just that her childish attitude (She's supposed to be older than Shirou for goodness' sake!) isn't what I'd expect from a girl that has seen a lot of deaths.

Shirou? He gets everything he knows from getting his butt kicked around by Saber (I really can't understand how a person can improve that way in sword-fighting without having a BASE idea of how it goes...) and suggestive comments by Archer (Already commented on that before.).

Sakura....Well. Her naivety persona really gets on my nerves. Only in Heaven's feel does she really make an achievement in calling my attention. And, of course by resigning her Command Spells to her "brother".

Gilgamesh. COME ON! He gets PWNED by a freaking SCABBARD! How pitiful is that? Even though his Gate of Babylon is pretty cool AND he whipes the floor with Shirou and Saber together....

Taiga...No. No bad comments, but strange as hell!

I join the lynching Shinji team. Where do I apply?

CHARACTER BASHING ENDS HERE!!!

Suichirou might be the only Master that can really fight on his own, even without counting Caster's little help with hardening his fists. I didn't vote him though. Dunno why...

Caster, or should I say, Medea? The only part I really feel sorry for her is when she does ABSOLUTELY nothing while Assassin and Suichirou do all the work, and when she gets pwned by Gil. She didn't deserve that, since the trio had worked hard to get to that point for suddenly from out-of-nowhere, Gil appeared and SERIOUSLY overpowered them. No fair.

And finally, Rider. What can I say? She only lost for two reasons: SHINJI IS THE SORRIEST (Doesn't exist, but it is fitting!) MASTER THAT EVER EXISTED, since he couldn't give ANY mana to her, therefor, severely relenting her power. And the other reason, Have you ever seen her use her Breaker Gorgon Phantasm in the animé? As far as I know, she used them on Berserker and PWNED him without even sweating!

Sorry if you felt bad, annoyed or insulted in any way while you read this, but I had to get it off my chest, and this was the best place for.

Demongod86 · 2007-02-10, 21:52

I do agree with the analysis on Rider. If you think Saber got the shaft...give Rider a good master and well...GFG anybody. She'd ninja them 20 times over!

BlackIce'd · 2007-02-10, 22:06

Why ninja them? Simply go to the basics. She'd give them the Evil Eye, without the blindfold, of course. That's a sure recipe for PWNING EVERYONE!

Demongod86 · 2007-02-10, 22:10

Servants are immune to that aren't they? Otherwise, she would have done it to Saber.

BlackIce'd · 2007-02-10, 22:15

Actually, they AREN'T immune to that. Proof of that is this image.

Spoiler for Watch it! This is an interesting fight!:

PS

o you have any idea how was the code for thumbnailing?

EDIT: One more reason to be a Rider fan!!!

Type-Moon has announced the winners of the 2nd character popularity poll.
1. Saber
2. Tohsaka Rin
3. Archer
4. Rider
5. Matou Sakura
6. Lancer
7. Karen Ortensia (Hollow/Ataraxia)
8. Illyasviel von Einzbern
9. Bazette Fraga Makremitz (Hollow/Ataraxia)
10. Caster

Demongod86 · 2007-02-11, 14:09

Well if she did that to Saber, we wouldn't have much of an anime now would we...though she shoulda just done it to Shinji =X

anselfir · 2007-02-11, 16:36

i dont really care about rider, caster, or the loli because their characters were nto done well in teh anime. this is judging from their presentation in the show, of which only a portion is screentime related.

capture · 2007-02-12, 23:34

Quote:

Originally Posted by anselfir

i dont really care about rider, caster, or the loli because their characters were not done well in the anime. this is judging from their presentation in the show, of which only a portion is screentime related.

Agree ....
but the loli is definitely kawaii!!! I mean Illyasviel.......

Rin_Tohsaka · 2007-02-17, 23:33

Rin,illya,and saber are tops on the favorites lists

Demongod86 · 2007-02-18, 01:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by anselfir

i dont really care about rider, caster, or the loli because their characters were nto done well in teh anime. this is judging from their presentation in the show, of which only a portion is screentime related.

Yes, but you are assuming the anime was done perfectly if you're going to judge them that way, and it certainly wasn't.

I mean 75% of the stuff we know about the servants comes from outside info rather than watching the anime...the only thing we saw about Rider in the anime was that she was hott as hell and had this ninja-ey style of fighting and got completely shafted by a master, and well, Caster, she was just an antagonistic bitch with an obsession for Kuzuki.

But when we get some outside info, we like them a lot more.

BlackIce'd · 2007-02-18, 11:37

Can't agree with you more. And after some research I came to like more Heaven's Feel scenario in comparison to Stay Night. At least the characters are better developed. And we see more new characters such as Dark Saber and Dark Sakura. And a lot more.

I hope they make THAT scenario in animé instead of Hollow Ataraxia. I haven't read much about HA, but I'll try to.

snisni · 2007-03-16, 18:12

Saber, Archer and the last one Sakura.
I just love their personality.

shiro83 · 2007-03-19, 10:46

Saber and Rin.
Unbeatable.

kamikazex · 2007-03-19, 21:43

seriously. how can you beat saber or rin

Demongod86 · 2007-03-20, 20:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by kamikazex

seriously. how can you beat saber or rin

With a 5'7" lavender-haired goddess with a 36DD cup size and hair length longer than her height, that's how.

Suiton! · 2007-03-27, 16:36

# Well for me its Gilgamesh hands down. A hell load of skills, and a hell load of weapons, and extremely talented. And the winner of the previous holy grail (as I remember), I think he was by far the strongest one. I didn't really liked how saber beat him, doesn't make a whole lot of sense, but good must win thats the lame rule of media. Plus he's like a historical icon, he is not the 1st king as he stated, he's the 5th one (as I read). He's the oldest servant, from a mighty civilization (uruk/babylon). Gilgamesh ftw!

# My second choice would be Archer, I love that guy, he kept hiding his power, and he had a lot. And he sacrificed to save the others. And he kicked berserker's ass (well for a while). He's rational, and the most adult-ish of the servants.

# My third choice would be Rider, because she's amazing, the most character that took my attention, she's very dark and depressed, she was controlled by a loser. She in my opinion has the second most strongest technique (after gilga). And she's the reason I hated saber AS HELL.Man I had hoped she had a fight with gilgamesh oh well. Her burst (like she said) no other servant can stop and thats pretty much true, what seemed to me was that she was not that interested in the whole thing, she looked spaced out thru the whole holy grail thing (I bet she had a brutally depressing history). If she was more interested and determined, and had a normal master she would've kicked serious ass. + she has kick ass hair, and overall appearance (had to say it).

# Oh man I can't believe I forgot Assassin, this is like my 9th edit (since I watched the anime long ago). Assassin also comes at the top of my list. Basically any one with long katana gets my upmost respect. Plus he's the most masterful weapon wielder thru the whole anime. And he's hiken tsubame gaeshi is uber.

PS: Saber sucks. oh and lancer was great too.

View Poll Results: Favourite F/sn Character Poll (Multiple Choice allowed!)
Emiya Kiritsugu	52	5.36%
Emiya Shirou	190	19.59%
Saber	577	59.48%
Tohsaka Rin	477	49.18%
Archer	443	45.67%
Ilyasviel "Ilya" von Einzbern	229	23.61%
Berzerker	31	3.20%
Matou Sakura	121	12.47%
Matou Shinji	13	1.34%
Rider	197	20.31%
Kuzuki Souichirou	17	1.75%
Caster	85	8.76%
Assassin	112	11.55%
Kotomine Kirei	38	3.92%
Lancer	124	12.78%
Gilgamesh	165	17.01%
Fuji Nee (Fujimura Taiga)	65	6.70%
Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 970. You may not vote on this poll

2007-01-16, 16:49	Link #144
HurricaneHige Uguu~ Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Canada	Saber +1 <3 Saber __________________ Sig's coming soon ~_~ (since 07....) My rant blog (omg i'm blogging now, and not just anime)

2007-02-10, 21:52	Link #146
Demongod86 Gundam Boobs and Boom FTW Join Date: Dec 2005	I do agree with the analysis on Rider. If you think Saber got the shaft...give Rider a good master and well...GFG anybody. She'd ninja them 20 times over! __________________ Signature stolen by a horde of carnivorous bunnies. It is an unscientifically proven fact that they are attracted to signatures which break the signature rules.

2007-02-10, 22:10	Link #148
Demongod86 Gundam Boobs and Boom FTW Join Date: Dec 2005	Servants are immune to that aren't they? Otherwise, she would have done it to Saber. __________________ Signature stolen by a horde of carnivorous bunnies. It is an unscientifically proven fact that they are attracted to signatures which break the signature rules.

2007-02-10, 22:15	Link #149
BlackIce'd ~CopyPasta!~ Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Uruguay Age: 36	Actually, they AREN'T immune to that. Proof of that is this image. Spoiler for Watch it! This is an interesting fight!: PSo you have any idea how was the code for thumbnailing? EDIT: One more reason to be a Rider fan!!! Type-Moon has announced the winners of the 2nd character popularity poll. 1. Saber 2. Tohsaka Rin 3. Archer 4. Rider 5. Matou Sakura 6. Lancer 7. Karen Ortensia (Hollow/Ataraxia) 8. Illyasviel von Einzbern 9. Bazette Fraga Makremitz (Hollow/Ataraxia) 10. Caster Last edited by BlackIce'd; 2007-02-10 at 23:20.

2007-01-16, 05:48	Link #141
Keimaru Kei ^_^ Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Boston	yeah Saber FTW

2007-01-16, 08:29	Link #142
Skeithis Von Einzbern Join Date: Oct 2006	Wait a moment. Why has Archer so many votes? Even that drunken irish shorthair is better =( voted for gil , saber and sakura

2007-02-10, 20:32	Link #145
BlackIce'd ~CopyPasta!~ Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Uruguay Age: 36	CHARACTER BASHING TIME!!!! Meh. Saber is SOOO Pasé... It would be obvious that she'd be popular being the main character in the animé. That's why I prefer the game(Haven't played it yet, waiting for English translation), where Saber is a secondary character as the other folks. Then, Rin. What's so interesting? She gets PWNED hard At the last part of the animé, maybe the only part that interesting and she was protagonizing it... (Or perhaps the scene at the abandoned house in Berserker's Act...) Archer. Shirou from the Future, He kicked Berserker five times (Or four?) Asides from having the knowledge of the future of what would happen and HOW EXACTLY to motivate his past self to do as he wanted, and his UBW, he has nothing more interesting. I won't go into the Ilya territory, since I really can't say something that would hurt someone's feelings (At least more than what I already did...). It's just that her childish attitude (She's supposed to be older than Shirou for goodness' sake!) isn't what I'd expect from a girl that has seen a lot of deaths. Shirou? He gets everything he knows from getting his butt kicked around by Saber (I really can't understand how a person can improve that way in sword-fighting without having a BASE idea of how it goes...) and suggestive comments by Archer (Already commented on that before.). Sakura....Well. Her naivety persona really gets on my nerves. Only in Heaven's feel does she really make an achievement in calling my attention. And, of course by resigning her Command Spells to her "brother". Gilgamesh. COME ON! He gets PWNED by a freaking SCABBARD! How pitiful is that? Even though his Gate of Babylon is pretty cool AND he whipes the floor with Shirou and Saber together.... Taiga...No. No bad comments, but strange as hell! I join the lynching Shinji team. Where do I apply? CHARACTER BASHING ENDS HERE!!! Suichirou might be the only Master that can really fight on his own, even without counting Caster's little help with hardening his fists. I didn't vote him though. Dunno why... Caster, or should I say, Medea? The only part I really feel sorry for her is when she does ABSOLUTELY nothing while Assassin and Suichirou do all the work, and when she gets pwned by Gil. She didn't deserve that, since the trio had worked hard to get to that point for suddenly from out-of-nowhere, Gil appeared and SERIOUSLY overpowered them. No fair. And finally, Rider. What can I say? She only lost for two reasons: SHINJI IS THE SORRIEST (Doesn't exist, but it is fitting!) MASTER THAT EVER EXISTED, since he couldn't give ANY mana to her, therefor, severely relenting her power. And the other reason, Have you ever seen her use her Breaker Gorgon Phantasm in the animé? As far as I know, she used them on Berserker and PWNED him without even sweating! Sorry if you felt bad, annoyed or insulted in any way while you read this, but I had to get it off my chest, and this was the best place for.

2007-02-10, 22:06	Link #147
BlackIce'd ~CopyPasta!~ Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Uruguay Age: 36	Why ninja them? Simply go to the basics. She'd give them the Evil Eye, without the blindfold, of course. That's a sure recipe for PWNING EVERYONE!

2007-02-11, 14:09	Link #150
Demongod86 Gundam Boobs and Boom FTW Join Date: Dec 2005	Well if she did that to Saber, we wouldn't have much of an anime now would we...though she shoulda just done it to Shinji =X __________________ Signature stolen by a horde of carnivorous bunnies. It is an unscientifically proven fact that they are attracted to signatures which break the signature rules.

2007-02-11, 16:36	Link #151
anselfir Style Über Alles Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: NYC/Chicago	i dont really care about rider, caster, or the loli because their characters were nto done well in teh anime. this is judging from their presentation in the show, of which only a portion is screentime related. __________________

2007-02-17, 23:33	Link #153
Rin_Tohsaka Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Espoo	Rin,illya,and saber are tops on the favorites lists

2007-02-18, 11:37	Link #155
BlackIce'd ~CopyPasta!~ Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Uruguay Age: 36	Can't agree with you more. And after some research I came to like more Heaven's Feel scenario in comparison to Stay Night. At least the characters are better developed. And we see more new characters such as Dark Saber and Dark Sakura. And a lot more. I hope they make THAT scenario in animé instead of Hollow Ataraxia. I haven't read much about HA, but I'll try to.

2007-03-16, 18:12	Link #156
snisni Junior Member Join Date: Feb 2007	Saber, Archer and the last one Sakura. I just love their personality.

2007-03-19, 10:46	Link #157
shiro83 Senior Member Join Date: Jan 2006	Saber and Rin. Unbeatable.

2007-03-19, 21:43	Link #158
kamikazex Senior Member Join Date: Jan 2006	seriously. how can you beat saber or rin

2007-03-27, 16:36	Link #160
Suiton! Akabane ftmfw! Join Date: Mar 2007 Age: 37	# Well for me its Gilgamesh hands down. A hell load of skills, and a hell load of weapons, and extremely talented. And the winner of the previous holy grail (as I remember), I think he was by far the strongest one. I didn't really liked how saber beat him, doesn't make a whole lot of sense, but good must win thats the lame rule of media. Plus he's like a historical icon, he is not the 1st king as he stated, he's the 5th one (as I read). He's the oldest servant, from a mighty civilization (uruk/babylon). Gilgamesh ftw! # My second choice would be Archer, I love that guy, he kept hiding his power, and he had a lot. And he sacrificed to save the others. And he kicked berserker's ass (well for a while). He's rational, and the most adult-ish of the servants. # My third choice would be Rider, because she's amazing, the most character that took my attention, she's very dark and depressed, she was controlled by a loser. She in my opinion has the second most strongest technique (after gilga). And she's the reason I hated saber AS HELL.Man I had hoped she had a fight with gilgamesh oh well. Her burst (like she said) no other servant can stop and thats pretty much true, what seemed to me was that she was not that interested in the whole thing, she looked spaced out thru the whole holy grail thing (I bet she had a brutally depressing history). If she was more interested and determined, and had a normal master she would've kicked serious ass. + she has kick ass hair, and overall appearance (had to say it). # Oh man I can't believe I forgot Assassin, this is like my 9th edit (since I watched the anime long ago). Assassin also comes at the top of my list. Basically any one with long katana gets my upmost respect. Plus he's the most masterful weapon wielder thru the whole anime. And he's hiken tsubame gaeshi is uber. PS: Saber sucks. oh and lancer was great too. Last edited by Suiton!; 2007-03-27 at 16:57.