Naruto - Requests for new threads
 

Since the Naruto forum is limited (only Mods and Admin can create new threads), this thread serves as a way to request a new thread to be created.

Please post here if you wish to request a new Naruto thread. Please bear in mind that we will only accept reasonable requests, we wish to maintain the focus within the forum and cut down on the noise (so no pointless threads cluttering up the place).

Don't forget that you may still post in existing threads as usual, the only restriction is that you may not create new threads within this particular forum.

Well I have suggested this but i will post it here too and see if anybody likes the idea :

-- In naruto Q&A change it to 'frequently asked questions' then create new thread 'Manga unanswered questions' with questions which cannot be answered at the moment without the use of hypotheses. When you find the questions can be asnwered remove them from the thread and keep there only the questions which are non answerable. You can also apply restictions and rules on which types of questions you keep and which you delete. The whole bunch of questions woul be updated regularly and kept on the first post under a spoiler tag.

Function : You separate the manga from the anime watchers and also point at those key questions which generate speculation and discussion for other future threads. Just a thought.

In response to that request I'll create a speculation thread for manga readers. It serves the same purpose, but it is a whole lot simpler. (And it is consistent with how we handle such issues in other series discussion forums.)

While I'm at it, anime watchers can have their own speculation thread.

Enjoy!

I am not sure about the need to create a separate thread for that. Many of the unanswered questions are already being discussed in related threads.

But, if you are planning to create a thread like that, it would be better to initiate the thread with pointers to the corresponding threads - the questions/speculations and the threads created for their discussion. It is hard work, but, if keeping discussions organized is of high importance, that should definitely help.

In retrospect a different approach might be better here...

Maybe a thread with titled "Impact of Jiraiya on future plots" may present a nice discussion.

I would like to make a thread discussing the ranking of ninja.
are they based on their village ranks (genin chuunin jounin and kage)
or on the skills they know (D rank C rank B rank A rank S rank)
mainly because people keep using the term "kage level" when they are referred to in the manga as s-class.
A genin who knows a ridiculous S-class move is able to beat a jounin i believe.

I suggest a thread where we can have a poll to vote for or against the option:
We can create new threads like we used to... or Those who are fine how it is now...

I for example dont like it that our powers are all of sudden so limited... :(

I don't think disallowing people from creating their own thread is really efficient. Not to mention as Mr. Johnny 5 has mentioned it limits people's creative powers. At the same token I do think there has to be a way to clean-up the clutter. One site I saw did a ranking system based on posts. Rookies could not actually create a new thread until they reached a certain ranking within the forum itself. Of course something like this is still very limiting in nature, but it could be modified.

Basically it comes down to quality threads. Alot of threads in the freelance forums were very limited in the proper discussion they got. Alot of threads were deemed nonsense or useless and not just by mods but other forum members as well.

Actually disallowing creating threads has been very efficient in the newer sub-forums and thats why it was decided to made the other forums this as well. This is no different to anyone who posts soley in the Code Geass or Claymore threads. Sorry you are not fond of it but remember if you have a creative thread idea this is the topic to ask it in.

I would like to see a thread where people would make their own four/three ninja cell.

As White Manju Bun says. At this point every single series discussion forum is operating this way, so we already know that the system works well.

Some of you may find that it is inconvenient not being able to create your own threads. Look on the bright side. At least you won't have the inconvenience of posting in a thread only to have it deleted after writing up a long and clever post. How many of you have experienced that heartbreak? The other day I rescued a rather long post of which someone was quite proud, in hopes that they could repost it in other thread. We delete a heck of a lot of pointless threads in this forum. By never creating such threads, we actually make things easier on both you and ourselves.

Edit: This is not a debate, so I have just deleted a bunch of replies. If you don't agree, take it up in the Forum & Site Feedback Forum, not here.

Sorry, but we'd rather not have such "Make your own Naruto" threads. This is a discussion forum, not a role-playing forum.

I guess the only thing that I'm curious about is how the "create new thread" issue works? If someone has an idea for a new thread, they post it here. If that idea is deemed worthy of a new thread, one is created. But how does it work for the person who requested the thread? If his request was made a few days before approval, would he still be allowed to have the opening post? Clearly, there was a reason for him requesting a new thread, and not allowing him the OP might open that thread to ridiculous commentary right from the start, before interesting conversation/debate can even be stimulated. I guess I'm just wondering how the mods will reconcile the requests with the creations, by way of the people who ask.

If you want to have the opening post, then just post it here and we can magically transform it into the first post of a thread -- if we think you do a good job. If you only generally describe the thread or don't do a good job of thread creation, then we'll make it ourselves based on your description. If your reason for suggesting a thread is the egoboo of seeing your name in the first post, then go away. We have to delete a lot of threads that only exist to boost the ego of the thread creator.

Fair enough...like I said, I was just curious. I don't have any ideas for good threads, I just wondered how the creations would go.

How about a tread pertaining to various theories in the Naruto Universe?

We've already got a lot of threads about theories. Is there some particular theory that needs a thread?

I meant a thread in which we can compare and contrast the various theories, but now that I think about it it's kind of redundant

I know it isn't a discussion thread.
I was just stating why Ryuuchi is wrong (thus why it doesn't deserve a thread) since I don't think all the mods posting here are up to date with the manga and able to say if it deserve a thread or not.

Thanks. I think we'll let hunter make this call.

Maybe an official Ending Thread where people could write their perfect ending.

Well since nothing is offical we have speculation on how naruto will end thread.

how about an If you could choose an artist to do a volume of Naruto who would you choose thread?
And how about a thread about which of the other country would you like to see in Naruto...And to go with the artist idea we could also do one on which author would you like to see write a volume of Naruto...

I was thinking about having a thread comparing the characters improvements during the time-skip as well as comparing the skill of some of the new characters like Yamato and Sai to some of the older characters?

or how about a thread on which actors/actresses you would prefer to do the voice acting in the english dub of Naruto.
or a thread on how Naruto ranks compared to other animes/mangas?

How about a thread comparing

I think that it would be interesting to have a thread with all the characters, good or bad, where we can discuss what their names mean and what parts of their character is associated with that name. For example Naruto means Malestrom and we can say that he is as distructive as one.

Well, I got to thinking....And I would like to see a thread asking people what character they would like to see return for an episode or a small arc. Now..since some people would like to see someone like Haku come back, and this is supposed to be based as a future chapter/episode that would be cool to see, then they would need to put a logical reason in how this person comes back

I think the 380 thread is getting a little full of talk about Sasuke and how he matches up to various ninja (particularly Itachi). I know there are no "vs." threads allowed and there already plenty of threads about Sasuke, but maybe there should be a dedicated thread to speculation about Sasuke's current strength level. Then some of the posts cluttering the 380 discussion could be moved there.

can someone create the thread for Chapter 381? I want to post spoilers already.

Chap 381 discussion is up now. Also any discussion about Sasuke strength could probably be done in the manga chap threads since its current at the moment but Ill let Hunter be the judge of it.

The posts were moved in the [Manga] Will Itachi really lose to Sasuke.

I think this can take place in here.

It will just be listing threads and I don't think it can lead to any discussion.

We are weary about this so I will see first if people can discuss about this kind of thing in good intelligence in the thread above.

I think your idea is great.

is there a thread where you discuss the power of the mangekyou sharingan
Ex: What would follow the Tsukiomi?
Amaterasu, Tsukiomi then ?, I beleive it would be a taijutsu called Susanoo (the third and last Shinto God to be born)

if not, could you make one?

Actually, if you used the forum's search ability to look for threads in the Naruto Forum with the word "Sharingan" in the title you'd have found this:

[Manga] Mangekyo Sharingan 3rd Deity

Go read the first post and you'll see that it is the same thread you want to create. It even speculates that Susano would be a taijutsu. The similarities are amazing. Please continue that discussion.

---

Edit: Just found another iteration of the thread titled "Itachi's Third Jutsu" which also speculates that he should have a taijutsu named Susano. I'm merging the two threads. I've also found this thread twice on NarutoFan here and here, though I can't merge with those... yet. I take some small pride that our iteration of this thread predates NarutoFan.

how bout a thread that you can talk about your favorite Jutsu

i have a good thread how about who they think should die on there and never come back

how about the least favorite person on naruto

I think we can do without the first two and the one about your least favorite character already exist.
Also please do not triple post.

Would you still be proud if you knew our first iteration of this thread actually date back from 2003 and exists in dozens of other threads? :p

Please just learn how to search. We've already got those threads.

Here are a few of our thread about jutsus. There are many more.

• Favorite Jutsu Thread
  closed for being a pointless list of one sentence answers.
• [manga] In search of the ultimate jutsu
  A thread for comparing the power of various to find the strongest.
• [manga] worst/wothless jutsu
  Ragging on pointlessly weak jutsus.
• Your ideal jutsu?
  A "make your own" jutsu thread.

Threads about characters you dislike.

• Least Favorite Naruto Character
• Do you hate any of the characters?

One of the reasons that we made this forum limited acess for creating new threads is specifically because people don't realize we already have all these threads and refuse to search for them. Please search out these threads for yourself.

Edit: Beaten to the post by Hunter, but I take pride in being thorough.
Both proud and disgusted. It is a strange feeling.

do they have a thread that talks Just about Kakashi?? if they don't then i would like to make that tread.

As already stated...
Kakashi Speculation Thread : What Lies Beneath

Hasnt been posted in for a while but Im sure could still be used for character discussion.

A few other Kakashi related threads that are a bit more current
Is Kakashi a Hokage lvl ninja
[MANGA] Kakashi a spy for akatsuki???