2004-05-26, 20:20 | Link #202 | |
Bubbly and super fun
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Doesn't look like Kansas
|
Quote:
Now that doesn't mean that you can't use these ablities to do something else, in this case using your eyes to develop a particular fighting style such as the Jyuken. To emit and control the chakra are the two main points of the Jyuken, and the Byakugan helps to do that simply because you can see the chakra, how it moves, etc. Spoiler:
For a Hyuga who has masterized the Jyuken style such as Neji (it's not a given though, a regular Hyuga who can't even see the tenkentsu can't do that) it's just a simple task. MidoriShinobi firstly Kakashi never says that the Byakugan was better than the Sharingan, he merely said that the Byakugan has a better insight, that's all. Then what Neji did with Hinata wasn't really a particularity of the Byakugan the whole thing of reading the face of people to know about what they think is a well known stuff, you don't need the Byakugan for that. |
|
2004-05-26, 21:05 | Link #203 |
日本語を食べません!
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: San Francisco
Age: 41
|
MidoriShinobi, the Sharingan may have evolved as an offhsoot of the Byakugan - but that really tells us nothing about the two as relative in strength.
It doesn't even mean that the Sharingan, as the "newer" eye, is better - unless the Byakugan has not evolved at all since the time of the split (which is possible, but unlikely). To have the Byakugan does NOT mean you have total control over your own chakra - since Neji couldn't learn the Lotus (or even be able to speed up his own chakra flow enough to fake it). To me, this almost defies belief, but it's there. |
2004-05-27, 01:19 | Link #204 | |
Member
Join Date: May 2004
|
Quote:
|
|
2004-05-27, 05:23 | Link #208 | |
Member
|
Quote:
The sharingan may be stronger against other users, but not against Hyuuga, as they won't be able to use anything against Hyuuga (If Gai, a person who doesn't have Byakugan, can fight the Sharingan by not looking Itachi In the eyes, then I would say that person just as skilled as Itachi just with Byakugan instead, would stand a really good chance), but their infirior insight and their abillity to not copy their unique fighting style as they don't have Byakugan wow...that was a strange sentence i just made there. Gotta stop using those parantheses |
|
2004-05-27, 05:43 | Link #210 |
Member
|
Yes..i know...but bloodlines should not be evaluated on who has them, but on their abillities. If a person just as strong as Itachi was fighting him with Byakugan instead of Sharingan, I definitly think The Byakugan would win.
With the control of the eyes that the Byakugan gives the user don't you think that if he just knew he shouldn't look directly at the Sharingan he could do it? Byakugan might give the user the abillity to see 360 degrees around, but it doesn't mean the user has to focus at everything around him. Mange Sharingan only work if you look directly at the Sharingan |
2004-05-27, 07:56 | Link #211 | |
Master(Vicious)'s Padawan
Join Date: Nov 2003
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2004-05-27, 10:10 | Link #212 |
Member
Join Date: Feb 2004
|
Nine Devils. It's the other way around. Sharingan is ineffective against the byukagan. They can't use their own moves back on them because they can't do it. They can predict moves, well byukgan can see through object all around them and like HIashi did before sense their intent(killing intent with Hizashi in the flashback).
Hunter. YOu said the amatseru(spelled wrong I think) and the other jutsu is on a different level than the byuakgan moves. Look at the kaiten huge, fast and doesn't waset chakra. 1 hit kills, who knows Hiashi or other jounin hyuga's may be able to do lots of them without wasting their chakra. While just doing those 2 Itachi got tired. Also the more powerful the user the more powerful the moves in terms of the byukgan. As seen by comparing Hiashi's kaiten(manga kaiten) to neji's. |
2004-05-27, 11:49 | Link #213 | ||||||
Bubbly and super fun
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Doesn't look like Kansas
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||||
2004-05-27, 12:59 | Link #214 |
Member
|
Hunter--> What I meant was that if gai, a person not having Byakugan are able to move against the Sharingan, then a person with that much control of the sight can do the sam. A user of Byakugan could properly focus at everything but the head of the Sharingan user, meaning that the Sharing couldn't hypnotize him and kill him inside the world of sharingan. You say that Sharingan can predict their moves, but you forget that Byakugan is even better at doing that.
And I didn't say that Gai had a chance against Itachi. What I stated was that this thread is about what bloodline is strongest and not which possesor of a bloodline is strongest /Terriator |
2004-05-27, 13:19 | Link #215 | |||
Bubbly and super fun
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Doesn't look like Kansas
|
Quote:
Gai can fight without looking at all at the eyes of his opponent because he's an incredible Taijutsu specialist, you can't do that because you have the Byakugan but only if you're as good as him in Taijutsu. Quote:
Quote:
|
|||
2004-05-27, 13:26 | Link #216 |
Kaizoku + Shinobi
Join Date: May 2004
|
Cool looking yes+ move copy vs. 360 degree view+inside view (literally)
If i could, i would take the Sharingan mostly coz of the ability to copy moves plus the eyes just look cool. I owuld hoeever be missing out on seeing someone's insides and a 360 degree view of things (bummer). Damn, not easy to pick is it?
|
2004-05-27, 13:26 | Link #217 | |
日本語を食べません!
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: San Francisco
Age: 41
|
Quote:
Hunter, the Byakugan's susceptibility to genjutsu is still unknown. We still don't know for sure whether or not Tsukiyomi would work - since from what we've seen, Byakugan interprets the world in a COMPLETELY different way than regular eyes or even the Sharingan - which still gives you enhanced real-world sight. As much as we want to say that this discussion is about the bloodline itself, it really does come down to the users. It is not unreasonable to say that a Byakugan user will often be faster than a Sharingan user, just like how you can also say that a Sharingan user will pretty much always know more ninjutsu than a Byakugan user. This comes into play most notably when you begin talking about chakra and stamina - the two techniques referred to as the best trump cards of the Sharingan are ridiculously chakra-intensive, which may render them unusable when facing multiple opponents (This is before I mention the other copied jutsus, which may or may not consume large amounts of chakra). A Byakugan strategy, when facing multiple opponents or a really, really long fight, can conserve chakra by using quickness and taijutsu for repeated hits rather than the all-or-nothing gambles. |
|
2004-05-27, 13:31 | Link #218 |
StrykerX
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Everett, WA
Age: 42
|
Well, sharingan's definitely my best attack related ability. And it'd be great because you can reflect your opponents back at them. Because you can also copy Neji's 360 degree maneuver. And even that one guy that had a tornado type of attack which wiped out the enemies.
__________________
|
2004-05-27, 14:18 | Link #219 | ||||
Bubbly and super fun
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Doesn't look like Kansas
|
Quote:
Quote:
And it's true for everything in the manga, to say that the Byakugan would be immunized against the Tsukiyomi is as untrue as to say that Kabuto is immunized against it because he has glasses. And besides the manga doesn't show that the Byakugan interprets the world in a completely different way than regular eyes (except for the almost 360° thingy of course) Spoiler:
Quote:
When Gai states that Sasuke was about Lee's speed after just 2 weeks of training he was just saying : 'So that's the Uchiha clan', as it wasn't really surprising for one of them. Anyway I completely agree that a ninja such as the Hyuga who are heavely specialized in Taijutsu will be often faster than other ninjas, simply because it's one of the main point of their training. But the Uchiha can learn Genjutsu and Ninjutsu almost on the spot, literally in a glance, actually, to train their body's capacities (such as speed, reflexes, chakra control and emission, amount of chakra, etc.) are the only thing that they must train all the time because they can be copied. Quote:
But I understand your point, against a huge amount of opponent these jutsus aren't the most useful, that's the reason why I still think that Itachi is better than the Sannin in a 1 vs.1 fight but not in a 1 vs. X number of people (until the manga shows that Itachi has some incredible huge area effect jutsu or Godzilla-class summon anyway). But a Sharingan master isn't forced to use these 2 jutsus all the time, an explosive Kage Bunshin or any of the multiple jutsu that he knows can deal with this kind of situation. |
||||
2004-05-27, 15:08 | Link #220 |
Master(Vicious)'s Padawan
Join Date: Nov 2003
|
Why does everybody think that Itachi has only 4 jutsu's :/ he just only showed 4. He is a ninja who probably has coppied many jutsu's so ofcourse he can deal with x amount of users. Its just stupid to assume a Sannin is better in vs x amount of enemy's. They never showed a Sannin using a jutsu who wiped like 10 people. Well againts a strong person then. Cuz assuming just because Itachi showed some high jutsu's who seems effective on 1 vs 1 fights is because he actually only been in 1 vs 1 fights. Anyways i big fight will happen soon i hope.
__________________
|
|
|