(L) Fairy Tail Manga Discussion Thread

[amjzz]

Just read the chapter in english.



Fairy tail chapter 199: The worst chapter of fairy tail.

Spoiler for fail:

So magically lissana soul was sucked to edolas giving her a new body, while her body was left on earthland.

What a pathetic excuse for revive a character that is not supposed to be there.

It was a very weak explanation, the worst part of fairy tail.


Everything looks so "forced" to fit for what the fans want that makes the whole manga plot to look bad. Its disappointing.

Fairy tail has dropped on my list of good mangas.

[Mazus]

Originally Posted by amjzz

Just read the chapter in english.



Fairy tail chapter 199: The worst chapter of fairy tail.

Spoiler for fail:

So magically lissana soul was sucked to edolas giving her a new body, while her body was left on earthland.

What a pathetic excuse for revive a character that is not supposed to be there.

It was a very weak explanation, the worst part of fairy tail.


Everything looks so "forced" to fit for what the fans want that makes the whole manga plot to look bad. Its disappointing.

Fairy tail has dropped on my list of good mangas.

I...think you need read the chapter again.

Granted, it was a head scratcher, but you totally read it wrong.

Spoiler:

Basically her WHOLE body was sucked into Edolas, if you noticed her wounds are the same before and after she got sucked in. Plus, it was Anima that sucked her in and there was nothing said about it only sucking souls.

[amjzz]

Originally Posted by Mazus

I...think you need read the chapter again.

Granted, it was a head scratcher, but you totally read it wrong.

Chapter 199 makes me think all this is just to please the fans, making the plot fit for what the fans want.

Spoiler for ch 199:

So an anima sucked lissana SOUL and gave her a body in edoras (it can't be edoras lissanas body because it was a dead body, broken). Also, the same anima didn't sucked mirajane, how convenient.

[konart]

Originally Posted by amjzz

Just read the chapter in english.



Fairy tail chapter 199: The worst chapter of fairy tail.

Spoiler for fail:

So magically lissana soul was sucked to edolas giving her a new body, while her body was left on earthland.

What a pathetic excuse for revive a character that is not supposed to be there.

It was a very weak explanation, the worst part of fairy tail.


Everything looks so "forced" to fit for what the fans want that makes the whole manga plot to look bad. Its disappointing.

Fairy tail has dropped on my list of good mangas.

She never died in first place. Also - I suggest you drop FT if you didn't see it coming, lol

[amjzz]

Originally Posted by konart

She never died in first place. Also - I suggest you drop FT if you didn't see it coming, lol

Spoiler for 199:

She died, her body was "dead" and in a grave.

[Anh_Minh]

A body isn't necessary for there to be a tombstone. It's weird they never mentioned the absence of body, yes, but that doesn't mean there was one.

I didn't actually dislike the chapter. Yes, it doesn't make a whole lot of sense, but the actual delivery's pretty touching, considering.

[amjzz]

I doubt mirajane saw the body of her sister being sucked by a misterious hole in the sky and completely ignored it, never mentioned anything about it and even made a grave for her.

Don't make fanon for fill the holes on the plot.

[cyberdemon]

here's the deal with 199

Spoiler:

Lisanna was dragged completely into Edoras. Both body and soul. Mira was holding her while she was being sucked in, that is all, her body WASN'T left in EL. They have a grave but it is EMPTY. She never died, merely passed out before being sucked in which is why Mira likely thought she died. They probably looked for a long time before eventually giving up hope.

likely next week will go into full detail on the matter.

[Kafriel]

Spoiler for 199:

Although I knew it was a possibility, I really didn't want this to happen, as it opens up lots of inconsistencies:
1) Why wasn't Mirajane Edo-abducted as well?
2) Didn't she notice the freaking sky tearing up and snatching her sister?
3) How did Lisanna escape lacrimafication under the rule of the ever-greedy Faust, since she had a magically imbued body?
4) It also negates the siblings' remorse on her death, since at least one of the two must have known she was alive...and it will only get worse if Lisanna is proven to have Phoenix soul takeover magic.
Aaaaanyway, although this is very bad, I'll live with it, can't call myself a fan if I can't take one bad chapter every 200 releases

[cyberdemon]

Originally Posted by Kafriel

Spoiler for 199:

Although I knew it was a possibility, I really didn't want this to happen, as it opens up lots of inconsistencies:
1) Why wasn't Mirajane Edo-abducted as well?
2) Didn't she notice the freaking sky tearing up and snatching her sister?
3) How did Lisanna escape lacrimafication under the rule of the ever-greedy Faust, since she had a magically imbued body?
4) It also negates the siblings' remorse on her death, since at least one of the two must have known she was alive...and it will only get worse if Lisanna is proven to have Phoenix soul takeover magic.
Aaaaanyway, although this is very bad, I'll live with it, can't call myself a fan if I can't take one bad chapter every 200 releases

Spoiler for 199:

1. Likely the anima could be adjusted to take anywhere from single targets to cities. Single targets are good for testing though because it becomes less likely that people will find out about it until they are ready.
2. She probably did but didn't have a clue what it meant. She could've perhaps thought it was some new magic by some dark wizard. It could depend on who they were fighting that caused the rampage.
3. I believe the anima was only completed when FT was sucked up at the beginning of the arc. Likely there were some glitches and rather than put her in lachryma it instead sent her to a random location in Edoras.
4. not really. The 2 of them grew from it until now. Elfman eventually learned to control his takeover magic mostly as a result of this.

[Bonta Kun]

Spoiler for 199:

That was something, it works, simple yea but it works and fits together so no probs from me.
Don't really care about all that anyway, we got Lisanna back and thats all that matters

But thing that interests me here is Mira-chan's little smile, I get a odd feeling it might mean more than she is happy to get Lisanna back.
I think Mira-chan might have knew or somewhat guessed what happened to Lisanna but maybe hid it from Elfman and rest.
Maybe theres a chacne we'll see some of the old Mira-chan again

Well looking forward to whats to come but I like this chapter, was quite touching.

p.s I love Gaz-kun and how he defends his "cat" now, it's actually pretty darn funny

[Slayerx]

Originally Posted by amjzz

I doubt mirajane saw the body of her sister being sucked by a misterious hole in the sky and completely ignored it, never mentioned anything about it and even made a grave for her.

Don't make fanon for fill the holes on the plot.

This is what i think is most important... Lisanna gets sucked up into the sky, and Mirajane and Elfman decides she's DEAD? Wouldn't most people consider her MIA? wouldn't they be more likely to assume that some magic managed to transport her somewhere?

And even if they try the excuse that they tried some form of location magic to find her and determined she was dead when they could not find her... first there is the possibility that she has been captured and hidden away somewhere; afterall it would be foolish to assume that she was taken away by random (even if that was the case) and as such should think it very likely someone kidnapped her... second of all, why would Elfman beat himself up over her death? i mean, sure he can blame himself for hurting her, but it wasn't him who "killed" her, but the giant hole in the sky that sucked her up. All in all it acutally makes more sense for her body to get left behind... ofcourse then we have to ask about her soul getting pulled up and somehow being given a new body like her old one...



Oh and how about asking this... why did she not get turned into a crystal/Lacryma when she was teleported to edolas like EVERYTHING else that anima sucks up?... that is the whole purpose of the anima; suck up magic and turn it into crystals

Honestly i would have much prefered if they just said she disappeared 2 years ago, instead of telling us she's been dead... or if this was actually Edo-lisanna; frankly it might have still provided some interesting development with everyone trying to relate with a twin... this just feels like an enormous asspull/retcon

[konart]

Originally Posted by amjzz

Spoiler for 199:

She died, her body was "dead" and in a grave.

Spoiler for no dead body, thus no dead:

They haven't seen the body. Mira left her while she was retreating.

[Xellos-_^]

Originally Posted by konart

Spoiler for no dead body, thus no dead:

They haven't seen the body. Mira left her while she was retreating.

Miria was holding onto lisanna's body while it got suck up by the amina.

[ShiroiRyu]

For me ... If that not the explanation who is good (the one who you spoke on this page), i have one name : Mistogan.
He know so much about the Anima, Lacryma ...
And his power can put some person to sleep ...
If he can modify thought ... We have the answer.

Spoiler for 199:

But i don't remember when they said/saw not the body of Lisanna.
But actually for me, i'm happy ... I really loved Lisanna.

For the "crystal"... And if she was ... a Dragon Slayer ? :s
Don't kill me please.

[konart]

Originally Posted by Xellos-_^

Miria was holding onto lisanna's body while it got suck up by the amina.

You can't really know that. What we see in the chapter - is only Lisanna's "I probably...".

If you remember how she was "killed" - Elfman was in his beast form, I seriously doubt Mira had enough time to simply go to where Lisanna's body was etc.

[Kir]

Rather than confirming her to be dead, they should have confirmed her to be missing since they witnessed her body being sucked into mysterious hole in the sky.

I'm sure somewhat deep in your hearts that you know she was only brought back because the Japanese fanbase and the Anime staff love her.

[Xellos-_^]

Originally Posted by konart

You can't really know that. What we see in the chapter - is only Lisanna's "I probably...".

If you remember how she was "killed" - Elfman was in his beast form, I seriously doubt Mira had enough time to simply go to where Lisanna's body was etc.

thats the point if they couldn't find the body while did they list her as KIA and why bother with a false grave.

No Body =/ death.

and Miria was holding on to Lisanna both in the pervious flashback and the lisanna flashback.

[Wargumm1i]

This is great she is alive guess Natsu is finally going to get his crush back and she is finally back to have a crush on him :P

[konart]

Originally Posted by Kir

Rather than confirming her to be dead, they should have confirmed her to be missing since they witnessed her body being sucked into mysterious hole in the sky.

I'm sure somewhat deep in your hearts that you know she was only brought back because the Japanese fanbase and the Anime staff love her.

"she was only brought back because of fanbase and the Anime staff love her."

fixed for truth

I can't remember Mira & Elfman seeing her being sucked into the sky. Anyway - she is alive or some kind of iZen technic, or even Gerard(Jelal? How should I call him now?)