Rate That Signature!

[konstargirl]

@hinakatbklyn: The siggy is cute 10/10
@CuXe: YAY!! SOUTH PARK!! lol 10/10
@ganbaru: lol not really into bikini pics but it's a cute siggy? 9/10
@Riza-chan: SANAE!! lol It's hard to read the text though. 8.5/10
@The Chaos: Who's that guy lol 9/10
@Arbitres: Hehe yuki?? 9/10
@Haladflire65: awesome sig. The text blends well with the sig and it's readable, although I do not understand kanji 9.5/10

[ganbaru]

psycho luny 8,3/10 a few suggestions: avoid to put text over the render(s), cutting the render less choppily ( I can clearly see the pixels on the back of his head and coat) and remouve a few pixel of the top (the render don.t touch the top of the sig)
konstargirl 8,4/10 I don't remember if I rated yours before.

Originally Posted by konstargirl

@ganbaru: lol not really into bikini pics but it's a cute siggy? 9/10

What bikini ? I don't see any bikini.

[konstargirl]

Oh it look like she was wearing one. lol Sorry about that.

[Arbitres]

@Arbitres: Hehe yuki?? 9/10

No. Shirogane Naoto.

The Chaos - 8.9/10: No idea what Coffee house is but it looks sort of... Funny. I like the background, though it's hard to make out at first.

CuXe - 9/10: I liked your 'Do not mess with the Wendy' one. But this one is pretty funny. The best part is Kenny being bobble head. Good job shrinking and fitting it in the forum rules.

[Haladflire65]

Arbitres: Cute and simple 8.7/10

[xavior686]

Haladflire65: The tried-and-true combo of black and blue can't be beat! The eyes are immediately drawn to the central character. He looks like he just woke up and found his HD entirely erased. 8.0/10!

[Aryu]

Riza-chan 8,5/10 Really nice one, but it's not AS safe
Arbitres 9/10 So cute, will you let me hug her ?
CuXe 8,5/10 Good, more South Park
psycho_luny 8/10 Quite good, maybe it would be better without text.
konstargirl 8,5/10 Nice one
xavior686 8/10 He always creeps me out

[ganbaru]

xavior686 8,1/10 not a bad picture

[The Chaos]

Arbitres..Nice one..8.5/10

[psycho_luny]

Originally Posted by ganbaru

psycho luny 8,3/10 a few suggestions: avoid to put text over the render(s), cutting the render less choppily ( I can clearly see the pixels on the back of his head and coat) and remouve a few pixel of the top (the render don.t touch the top of the sig)
[B]

thanks for the advice...i'll try to change it as soon as possible...
maybe i'll post it again once i've changed the flaws of it....
but for now...here's a new 1.

Aryu: a bit chaotic with all the colors, but i like it a lot 8.6/10

[Haladflire65]

Aryu: Looks good. 8.8/10

[ganbaru]

psycho luny 8,4/10try to keep it at one ( or 2 if ''interracting'' with each other) render, and the lightnin g could be better.

[The Chaos]

psycho_luny..I agree with ganbaru about the lightning but the text look good ..8/10

[Haladflire65]

psycho_luny: I agree with everyone else... 8/10
Can you do me the liberty of rating another one of my PS newbie friend's sigs? Thanks guys

[ganbaru]

Haladflire65 used 8,7/10 nice effect
posted: 8,6/10 I like that kind of artwork

[Rennir]

Halad- 8.8/10 I have no criticisms...so nice job
Regarding you friend's- 8.4/10 I feel that more effects could've been used/there's a lot of empty space and also lighting is a bit too intense in some parts. But overall good job.
________
Uggs

[hinakatbklyn]

@Haladflire65 - (Alchemist Sig) Kind of bright on one side although I still see the text. But very good effects overall. 8.9/10
(Currently used) Great job 9.1/10

[The Chaos]

Halad-chan.. Ed Sig..very nice work on it ..8.7/10
Gintama sig ..good effects ..9/10

[JRendell]

Halad: Posted - Looks like the filters have been a little excessively used, but it looks ok. Text is bordering on unreadable. 8/10
Used - Great work on the brushes. Thumbs up for the lighting too 9/10
Arbitres Very kawaii. Border is a wrong choice of colour however. 8.8/10
psycho Contrast is wayy too high. Bit empty on the left as well. 7/10

[CMSensei]

Halad Posted - 8/10 look okay, text needs to be darker.
JR - 8.6/10 Chibi!!!!!