2007-08-13, 21:58 | Link #22 | |||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
|
Quote:
Quote:
Wars change characters and hence it is not a soap opera? I do not follow this logic. They characters are IN a war with people dying left and right.. it is of course logical that it has a more significant effect than a fight with a girlfriend... Quote:
Quote:
When I say "not to be taken seriously", I mean "do not expect logic in this show"...... shows like FLCL, for example.. Quote:
Incidentally, I do recall speaking with you about ZZ Gundam and the crazy characters with you..(random chick who got sexually excited for no reason). That show was still far better than Turn A. [quote]Call me an optimist.... I refuse the belive politicians who live on earth with their families....would give an asteroid to the main who has already killed millions by dropping two other asteroids onto the earth. Their selfishness, if not their wisdom, should preclude this ..... |
|||||
2007-08-13, 21:58 | Link #23 | ||
Naysayer?Fanboy?Wiseacre?
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
I have never been much of a Gundam fan (I have watched SEED. GSD and a dozen episodes of Zeta) or a mecha fan in general, yet I thoroughly enjoyed Turn A Gundam, although I am not sure exactly why. It probably had to do with the mecha designs which were a lot more appealling than just about any mecha I had seen in anime. The odd setting. The brilliant music. The atmosphere. The ani-war message - yes, of cours,e it's cliche but I think it was put forward in a very impressive fashion, often having quite an emotional impact on me. For instance, something so simple and on paper so silly as Loran using his Gundam to wash the bloodied clothes made for a stunnningly beautiful and emotional scene, IMHO of course. Or maybe it had to do with Diana Soriel being like 12819231938 times more interesting character than her counterpart Lacus of SEED (not that this is much of an achievement in itself, if you aks me) and with a supporting cast of intersting personalities (though I wish Keith and Fran Doll's stories were developed better). With Harry Ord being liek the avatar of coolness, yet staying human. OK, OK, enoughincoherent praise for now.
Quote:
And yes, the plot is full of holes and makes it hard to suspend disbelief, there were a few too many episodes and there were too many battles of the "OK, time's over, we shall resume our fight five episodes later because for some inexplicable reason we don't feel like fighting to win today". Quote:
__________________
|
||
2007-08-13, 22:03 | Link #24 | ||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
By the way, I felt that the Militia was sort of retarded from the very beginning. Their incompetence (and that of every other fighting force) was sort of the point of the show. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||||||||||
2007-08-13, 22:07 | Link #25 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
|
Quote:
Quote:
I already addressed the issue with the interior... the fact that they are in a space war precludes that criteria from being upheld. |
||
2007-08-13, 22:14 | Link #26 |
勇者
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Tesla Leicht Institute
Age: 34
|
Seriously? You thought Turn A was the worst Gundam? I thought it was pretty good, the fight scene was decent and it was better then damn Seed where there were so many reused scene you thought you were watching the same battle over and over. Now you said about Fed being stupid in CCA however politician in prior to WW2 were way dumber then them and their action was similar to the politician in CCA. Now switch between Dianna and Kihel I really didn't had any problem with that it add interesting character development for both Kihel and Dianna. And if you want to talk about plot hole you should look at your beloved Seed it is full of them. I can't really talk about the character since it's been while I watched Turn A and I don't really remember them well. The side story was little weird and I thought they could have done it without them. The mech design was funky but it had it's own style. And do you even like Gundam in general? it seems that you really don't like most of them, and I can't believe you thought Destiny was better than some of the Gundam. In my opinion Destiny was the worst Gundam ever created it brought shame to Gundam name (I maybe over exaggerating little though).
__________________
|
2007-08-13, 22:42 | Link #27 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
My favorites: 1. Victory - Lots of great moments and lots of bizzare/goofy moments. Easily the most enjoyment I had watching Gundam. 2. Turn A - Superb setting and good character interaction. The ending was a little weak, but it doesn't really detract from the whole. 3. Seed - Plenty of compelling drama marred by some bad writing. I found the characters very appealing. 4. Destiny - Flawed; but it still presented the most interesting ideas in Gundam. It made me think the most, and I like that. Enjoyable: 5. Mobile Suit Gundam - A solid show; it has one of the best depictions of war in Gundam. 6. Gundam X - I liked the characters, but it doesn't really live up to its setting. 7. Zeta Gundam - A pretty decent show, but it's sort of dragged down by the ending and some of the directorial choices. 8. Gundam Wing - I thought that it was pretty bad, but I still liked it. Not enjoyable: 9. ZZ Gundam - I didn't mind the beginning, but I hated the ending. 10. G Gundam - A pretty good show, but none of the characters worked for me. I might as well add the shorter works: 1. 08th MS Team - Good atmosphere overall. The Shattering Mountain episodes were also some of the best episodes in Gundam. I even liked the last episode. 2. 0080 - A very interesting character piece. I especially liked the portrayal of the kids' reactions to the war. 3. Endless Waltz - Better than Wing. Dorothy and her eyebrows make the movie version better than the OVAs. 4. 0083 - Lots of eyecandy, but I don't think it has as much substance as it could have had. Nina Purpleton is my least favorite Gundam character. 5. Char's Counterattack - I didn't buy the ending at all.
__________________
|
||
2007-08-13, 23:03 | Link #28 | |||
Naysayer?Fanboy?Wiseacre?
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||
2007-08-14, 00:39 | Link #30 | |||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
|
Quote:
Point me to precisely what in Gundam Seed do you regard as utterly stupid as Dianna giving her power to an earthling? In seed terms, this is roughly equivalent to Patrick Zara handing over command to some natural he barely knows... or Azrael handing over command to some coordinator. Quote:
Make no mistake, I present 3 main complaints, and several others ... I'm not calling it a bad show *just* based on the lack of action... Quote:
Kihel / Dianna switch is NOT a plothole.... it is stupidity of the highest order... I think this may even rival episode 39 of Monster (or some episode thereabouts). I'm no Gundam fan (in terms of being a fanboy of the franchise). I've seen essentially everything the franchise has to offer... (no I will not watch G Gundam) I like Seed and the MSG movies as I've mentioned. Almost every other Gundam show was mediocre IMO.... Yes, I ranked Destiny above 2-3 other Gundam shows.... Last edited by avmoghe; 2007-08-14 at 00:49. |
|||
2007-08-14, 02:04 | Link #31 | |
Banned
|
Quote:
|
|
2007-08-14, 02:33 | Link #32 | |
Retweet Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: ニュー・オーリンズ、LA
|
Quote:
Dude you're thinking too linear and too hardlined...she forged a bond with the impostor and it was shown through her development with Harry Ord that she embodied the qualities Dianna herself had or wanted to have...Dianna wanted to live like the world she longed for in her sleep and the romanticizing experience of the man she met while there (Symbolism can trump practicality)...Some would say having a pink-haired idiot-savant captain a ship in the battle of Yachin Due is far dumber than the symbolism this storyline was trying to achieve... Oh and while you're asking that incredibly silly question about what in SEED is stupider than the Dianna switch, hmmmmm.... Kira not dying in Strike Mwu not dying in Strike Strike's head blocking Dominion's main weapon Milly falling for Dearka after wanting to murder him... 20 year old kid named Azreal being in control of basically the Earth's military cause he was pi$$ed some coordies beat him up when he was 7, so he wants them ALL dead... Newtypes who aren't newtypes SPAAAAAAAAAAAAACE WHAAAAAAAAALES!!!!!! You simply missed the boat on Turn A and that's fine...It is a series far more grounded in themes, heritage, character development, and adventurous wonder...You went in hoping for a Soopa-cool mecha designs and a story fit for your less than ideal thinking of Gundam just being some toyline...So in-turn the series should resemble the same generic qualities as you feel are needed for something as pedestrian as Gundam?? ...People like you and 4tran to a lesser extent can watch these shows like mathematicians trying to solve the x variable or you can look at these things with a certain sense of passion and wonder for what Gundam is (Your not a fan or a fanboy so why would you understand some the more subtle expressionism that you want me to explain when it's easy to see and in nearly every episode?)...Turn A in actuality devoid of being a Gundam show still works on story alone, but it's the Gundam brand name and the competent desire this program had to tie all those stories of the legendary white mobile suit together that elevates it's appeal to many...It was suppose to be the final story that ties everything together... avmoghe I kinda forgot who I was speaking too when I first responded, and your an alright fellow (Hell I've leeched many a Gundam show from your fserve in the past), but I think I have a read on what you seem to enjoy and it ain't really found in this genre...Switching sides, switching appearances, switching themes, switching roles, is a commonality found in so many G-series and your inability to compute the symbolism and or//artistic expression found in this show points to your very strict, logistical longings...Heck you even seem to think Gundam shows are so devoid of plot that one that actually has one is some strange occurrence not in line with your overview of never watching gundam for plot or characters (As if the consensus of Gundamites hopes you don't mind as we laff at that)... You honestly wanted something outta Turn-A that it never wanted to or even tried to provide...So in-turn I guess you'll always have SEED to provide you with that straight-forward beam-spraying and plotless character dynamic that makes Gundam just a little more than a mediocre throwaway of a program for you...Based upon your conjecture and your overall opinions on Gundam in general, I understand completely why Turn-A and even Gundam for that matter is some bull$hit toy saga for you...So fans like me for instance, can see a little more meaning where you see frustration for lack of l33tness... Spoiler for older quotes about the show I've made:
__________________
|
|
2007-08-14, 03:10 | Link #33 | |||||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
|
Quote:
Also, this is why I pointed to the animenfo (also anidb by the way) polls... which have nothing to do with how many people have seen the series.. but simply take the average of the available votes.... Should these polls not work the the opposite way? Only hardcore fans interested in the series would go seek out old series, and consequently, their ratings should be higher. Not a single one of these shows Seed being beaten by any other series. Again, the purpose of this is not to argue that mass appreciation is true quality of a show...it is merely to show that liking Seed is quite common... Quote:
Quote:
These are flaws yes.. but not stupidity in the extreme by any means... Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
You obviously do not understand what I mean by "stupidity in the extreme"... We aren't talking about people escaping with their lives....(Char, Rosamia, that one other chick in ZZ).... we aren't talking about retarded newtype miracles.... we aren't talking about Seed eyes for the cast.... we aren't talking about non-newtypes exhibiting newtype traits for no reason... we aren't talking about dumbass strategies by armies....We aren't talking about Yazzan being turned into a moron....We aren't talking about women getting sexually excited by mobile suits.....We aren't talking about Tomino's half assed defections to enemies (ala Reccoa, random ghosts switching sides for no reason).... We aren't talking about Gundam Wing boys surviving when they should not.....Hell, we aren't even talking about handing over Axis to Char... We are talking about stupidity so extreme that a director should not even have considered it. As I said above, we are talking about something like Patrick Zara handing over power to a natural.... something SO completely idiotic and nonsensical, that the director should be SHOT for even thinking about it. Or, something like the Earth Alliance officers broadcasting their military intelligence all over the Earth for everyone to see... Or something like Char saying "screw Earth", I'm going to nuke a few colonies.... Or Amuro just saying....screw it.. I'm just going to kill everyone onboard the white base.... We are NOT talking about general Gundam flaws... which is what you have listed above for Seed. Quote:
In either case, look at what this has lead to....You've been reduced to pointing out flaws in Seed without actually directly responding to my complaints... The only real response I've heard from you is "ignore those complaints, look for the supposedly important symbolism".... Quote:
Last edited by avmoghe; 2007-08-14 at 03:29. |
|||||||||||
2007-08-14, 04:32 | Link #34 | |
Retweet Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: ニュー・オーリンズ、LA
|
Quote:
If you can't come to the realization that Dianna sincerely felt that Kiehl Heim had become the leader she couldn't be then you'll never accept it...Less you forget the whole time they had switched places Keihl Heim was making natural decisions on behalf of Dianna that were in line with what she wanted but didn't necessarily have the heart for...Even Harry acknowledged her decision making (Harry the top advisor to the Queen who knew of this signed off on this because he believed in her when he didn't quite know she was an impostor--If Harry thought that was crap he never would have allowed it)... Heim was also the female companion of one Guin Lineford and was quite privy to negotiations with earth and space and the dynamics that differed between them...Just being a wallflower to Lineford's knowledge gave her perspective (and that's ignoring the physical and emotional attachment she felt for Dianna after they shared stories about her life on earth prior and up to meeting Will Game (I know soap opera bull$hit to you, but sets up a deeper connections for others)...The symbolism is found in the fact that these two girls looked just alike and each was giving the other a chance to tap into the part of their personality that was never quite satisfied (Dianna's longing for just being a normal earthling and Keihl Heim's desire to find a future beyond that of just a pretty face who didn't really have a role in the world)..That means it wasn't just a chance but perhaps a fated meaning (Dullindal didn't get Kiel Heim a tit-job and pink extensions to look like Lacus Clyne, These two woman looked naturally just alike--there was a deeper meaning for their fated encounter...If you can't jump that hurdle then that's what it is...I almost feel foolish for trying to shed light on this when you said you don't watch Gundam for plot or character, just for_____________???? Oh BTW I find STRIKE's head blocking a positron blast with the pilot surviving, and a pink haired pop-singer commanding a battle fleet far stupider than anything you're talking about (Oh but wait since Kira and Mwu are brought back because of popularity then somehow that's not under your stupid heading? Your whole ideology on this subject is topsy-tervy)...Your definition of flaw has flaws...I also am a very avid veiwer of HBO's The Wire owning all four season's on DVD...But let me share with you, the Wire is a social commentary transposing 3 layers of dynamics inwhich The Police examine the streets and the streets examine the police while the governmental aspect of the story shows to be as corrupt as the criminals they target and how they all function together creating an endless cycle of dysfunctionality...Deep concept I know, but the plot's not that deep, it's the characterizations, reality based concepts, and the palpable moral dilemmas' that make this show tick...Cops try to get the bad-guys as the governmental based system screws each side up (While the viewer desides what's B & W and what's grey) --That's the basic plot...It's not deep, it's just executed amazingly (What you think because characters like Brotha Malzone comeback to finish a plotline from a season before that's deep plotting?--That's basic coherent plotting)... Season 1: Introduction into the streets and the nuanced cat and mouse game that is the drug-game Season 2: Solve who killed the dead strippers, find the greek Season 3: Find a way to curve crime by creating a test sample to legalize drugs alla Hamsterdam Season 4: See how the allure of pressure from the streets shapes and takes kids with the prospect of failing school systems being an integral part of that problem... The plot is very straight forward, they just analyze the systematic levels that keep each entity (streets, Police, government) engaging one another...It doesn't hurt that the cast is amazing and they create a gritty and desperate world far closer to the one we actually live in(Rather than the stereotypical world most dramas try to convey)...But I digress as this and Gundam are literally worlds apart in everything under the sun...If you're searching for this in anime you might wanna shelve anything with a big robot on the DVD cover...
__________________
|
|
2007-08-14, 05:27 | Link #35 | |||||
Ancient Member
Join Date: Apr 2002
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
The whole point was to show how selfish and evil politicians can get. And this wasn't the first time they acted this way in Gundam either. Quote:
Quote:
But anyway, he's admitted that the reason why there are no Newtypes or colonies in the show are all due to this "dislike" of Gundam fans and the way they treat everything so seriously and literally. Sort of like what avmoghe is doing in this thread.
__________________
|
|||||
2007-08-14, 07:49 | Link #36 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||||
2007-08-14, 08:22 | Link #37 | |
Retweet Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: ニュー・オーリンズ、LA
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
2007-08-14, 11:00 | Link #38 | ||||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
At this point I'm quite sure you're arguing for no reason.... we aren't talking about flaws Gundam has been filled with for the last 20+ years... we are talking about stupidity that should not be seen in any anime.. let alone Gundam. Not a single anime Gundam show that I've seen.. NOT ONE.... has committed the stupidity of this Dianna/Kihel switch. I've seen the flaws you mention throughout Gundam.... and not a single one of them represents absolute retarded-ness on the part of a well love leader character. Quote:
If you're automatically defining 'deep plot' to imply "must have random symbolism that you believe you see", I certainly am not willing to argue about it. Arguing about something as abstract as symbolism (and art in general) is a waste of time IMO. (Hell, you can search for the shows reviews yourself and find plenty of people claiming it has a deep plot) I only presented the Wire as an example of a show I watch for the plot... Quote:
You obviously can't remove the war and the fighting from a previously made show... But what would remain after you remove the war and the fighting is indeed a soap opera. Like it or not, Gundam deals with personal relationships that a young man has with people his age, and authority figures (when you hypothetically remove the fighting). Often there is some crappy romance, jealousy, pissed off girls, etc..... staple soap opera. Obviously the above just happens in the context of a war. I'm not sure how familiar you are with TV... but even the Sopranos has been called a soap opera with its meandering focus on personal relationships (lack of focus on the criminal aspect). We sure as hell do not need Days of our lives type shows for a show to be classified as a soap opera.... Quote:
Of course your underlying assumption seems to be that since one completely unrelated movie managed show antics in the movie means Turn A Gundam was justified in doing the same... The assumption is completely false. What works in that move with its set of characters is irrelevant to whether Turn A Gundam should have been taken seriously... Do you actually want me to start listing series that DO deal with serious issues and DO NOT turn into a miserable parody like Turn A? Quote:
Let me put this in modern terms.... What we saw in CCA was roughly equivalent to the U.S. government reaching an accord with a known terrorist who has attacked the US multiple times in the very recent past.. and giving him a nuclear weapon in exchange for him turning over his associates. Actually... scratch that.. this isn't even a nuclear weapon.. this is something far bigger, since one single use can wipe out the entire Earth.....So, for a concrete analogy... just picture someone like George Bush handing over a nuclear bomb big enough to destroy the entire USA to Osama Bin Laden....I'm no fan of Bush by any means, but even he will not do something such as this... Last edited by avmoghe; 2007-08-14 at 12:49. |
||||||||
2007-08-14, 14:38 | Link #39 | |
Retweet Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: ニュー・オーリンズ、LA
|
Quote:
Does Patrick Zala have a dead ringer that's willing to behold the ideals of doing right by the people of the Moon and the people of earth? Your Zala comparison is flawed because you are looking at the comparison simply academically, devoid of layers the characters represent...Devoid of the journey between Diana and Keil Heim to get to that point...Have you never seen a work where a leader gives their power to someone who they believe represents the values and ideals they believe in? Or simply believe they'd make a great leader? Prince and the Pauper, Gladiator, King Arthur's Court just to name a few off the top of my head...Your claims of insanity are just that, insane...As if the switch-a-roo has no source material to consider (Yeah i know you don't care)... You clearly hate Turn A....You clearly went into to show expecting something totally different, you clearly got out of it the same basement-level complaints of animation and mecha designs (which is superficial since you seem to think Gundam should only be this), and you clearly lack passion for Gundam which makes this series a whole lot sweeter in those apex moments (Bull$hit blah blah blah moments for you)... So what else can be said really? If I breakdown symbolism, it's bull$hit..If I breakdown expressionism it's bull$hit...Because like Johnny 5 before he got hit by lightning you see 1's and 0's not levels of characters, not symbolism, not emotional expressionism (You don't even understand the context of this show which is not strict in the area you are breaking down...Hell I might let an ape switch places with Aggripa Maintainer he was such a caricature)...That's why all your superfluous overblown comparisons (Osama Bin Laden, Patrick Zala, etc.) fall flat...Hey preach that $hit to the school kids all day I don't have a problem with it, but you won't make me sip that Kool-aid because I'm simply beyond that lock-boxed type of thinking...I for 1 understand that they're levels to this $hit and one action by one character doesn't equal the same action by another character just because they are in a similar position (THIS JUST IN BTW)...That's trite, that's easy, that's flawed mathematics...I'll continue to stay after class and erase the board of your less than tangent equations, if I must...
__________________
|
|
2007-08-14, 15:47 | Link #40 | ||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
|
Quote:
Quote:
The Zara analogy boils down to this: Zara picks a virtually unknown natural who knows nothing about Coordinators or military tactics to lead his military against the Earth forces, while he goes around playing Golf. Only if Seed (or any other Gundam) managed to pull something this utterly stupid do you have the ability to call the show just as stupid. Quote:
And on top of this.... this unfreaking-believable show has the balls to try and make me sympathize with Dianna!!?? "It is all my fault" Dianna cries while the chumps around her console her... Fsck you beeatch... if you make decisions like abandoning your people to an earthrace leader during wartime and hoping she does okay..... you deserve to be shot in the face not consoled by the chumps around you... Quote:
Do you realize what you're saying? What Dianna did is equivalent to Churchill picking someone from the SS and going off to play golf.. Not a single fictional work I've ever read or watched has been quite this stupid... Quote:
Most works have numerous places where this logic is lost (normal Gundam flaws fall into this category).. But what Turn A has done is ascended into absolute abandonment of even an attempt at logic... This has combined with the atrocious fighting... the irrelevant subplots...and Tomino's bad habits.. ALL of these combine together in order to make me hate the show... Quote:
Last edited by avmoghe; 2007-08-14 at 16:09. |
||||||
|
|