2008-05-17, 01:07 | Link #161 | |
Μ ε r c ü r υ
Join Date: Jun 2004
|
Quote:
For Sasuke that was not the case. He was hyped and he met the expectations. But, that time might already be over. Now, it will be Naruto who will be pressured to exceed his father to overcome whatever difficulty he is going to encounter. Much like how Sasuke was. |
|
2008-05-17, 01:29 | Link #163 |
'One'
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Canada
|
8 pages, 8 PAGES!!!! and only one person has commented on how great this story is and how its really picked up!!!
I mean Kishi took one of the greatest philosophical questions and has somehow (pure genius) incorporated it into his manga, he's awesome!! I'll never doubt him again. Now, in all honesty those who can't see how Itachi is a hero are being foolish. First off a coup d'etat isn't some kind of public rally and announcement. Itachi most likely under the third leaked possible scenario's to his father and because of his hate for the Senju reducing the Uchiha and secluding them, wanted to take what was "rightfully" their's..... Status/Acceptance/their 'place', ect... Itachi saved countless lives but had to exterminate HIS own family and bloodline in order to do so, but couldn't kill his brother, he really was a hero. As stated earlier Madara is probably putting a spin on things, and the only reason Itachi wanted him dead was so that his 'truth' would not be leaked, he wanted to die and be forgotton and he truly cared for his brother. Killing Madara and keeping them seperated was obviously an attempt to keep Madara from emotionally charging Sasuke with the truth, leading his life astray, and turning Sasuke into a possible killer, oh the irony. And of course Madara would help kill the Uchiha, they turned on him, and what would really piss him off is the fact they insulted his pride and love of the clan, and made his brothers sacrafice a needless one, f*ck them. Itachi was far from emotional, he has the qualities and characteristics of a real leader, he was at the core peaceful, and righteous, I love the "I couldn't even imagine his mental state" and it's true you can't. Hell is a good word but it doesn't do justice to the (oh the irony) mental strain and hardest choice imaginable placed upon the only character who actually yearned for peace. He is the only character that actually had no alterior motives, for power, dominance, status ect......you know.....can't we all just get along........That's all he wanted, and Danzou took advantage of that, I hope he experiences the most painful death that I could imagine. What a prick job. Kishi really salvaged the manga, the speculation surronding its direction is crazy, and I have that sort of re-born faith :P |
2008-05-17, 02:01 | Link #164 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: East Cupcake
|
^Well, it depends on the truth of Madara's statements from the previous chapter. If what Madara has said about the birth of Konoha is true (i.e. a built in foundation of mistrust/hatred towards a specific clan/group), then Itachi is not a hero. Instead, he has seemingly killed off the only group of people that were being oppressed/subjected by Konoha before they had a chance to retaliate against their oppressors. To put it another way, he single handedly (more or less) wiped out a group of victims that were upset by how they were being mistreated. If Madara;s information is the "truth", then Itachi has become nothing more than a dictator (ala Argentine Dictator Videla and his destruction of 9,000 innocent civilians, many who opposed his regime but also quite a few babies and children, over a ten year period ) that kills off the people that possibly try or actively try and disturb what he considers peace. That is not being a hero, that is a vigilante at best or simply a mass-murderer at worst.
Again, this is all based around the notion that Madara's history is the "truth", and that Konoha is intrinsically a naturally oppresive organization set-out against the Uchiha clan. I do not personally believe Madara's story, but if it is true, then Itachi is not someone to admire or even pity. He deserves the death he received, and Sasuke should not feel any true guilt over said death (especially since he did not actually "kill" Itachi). Now, if Madara's story is false, and Konoha was not out to get the Uchiha Clan from the start, but the clan was still attempting a coup, then Itachi could be considered a hero. Since the Clan would be acting for selfish reasons only, then Itachi would actually be preserving the village from an unjustified threat (much the same as Minato defeating the Kyuubi). This is also the storyline that would have Sasuke actually feel guilt and sorrow for Itachi's death, even if it does not explain the death of the women and children. I will agree, though. These last few chapters have been fairly interesting, eaisily the best written chapters since...I don't know when (maybe when Naruto was studying under Yamato and Kakashi?). Last edited by james0246; 2008-05-17 at 02:48. |
2008-05-17, 05:15 | Link #165 |
Boss of Ecchi Yazuka
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Places
|
I think we are all asking ourselves....what is up with those stripes on his mask?
Also I just noticed something...Madara's vast amount of chakra lets him live for ever does that mean Naruto can live for ever (OH GOD!!!) |
2008-05-17, 05:52 | Link #166 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Hidden Village of Sake
|
Quote:
The only point where he probably lies is his own role in all this. He says he had nothing to do with summoning the kyuubi. The most problematic part of this story is Itachi's behaviour. He obtained MS at age of about 11, and he had totally defeated Orochimaru at about that time. He had two years to use his power, and lets be honest here: Itachi was the strongest ninja in the village, the who should have been made hokage, and he didn't succeed in his quest. How the hell couldn't he make his own will come true, when he was the strongest? Even idiots like Naruto have much stronger influence on the village. This is the part of the story that is quite nonsense. My main problem is that Kishimoto introduced this old shitty character of Danzou in a world which is ruled by power, and this Danzou has so much influence on everything?! That's nonsense, as Hunter already wrote the logical thing in a logical Naruto world would be that he was already dead decades ago. This old shit was Sarutobi's rilval to begin with, in a real world Sarutobi or his ANBU would have killed Danzou even before Itachi was born. Then we have this situation where Danzou works against Tsunade, another nonsense, in a logical Naruto-world Tsuande would already made him kill by ANBU or Team-Kakashi or Sai himself. Actually if Tsunade were a good leader she would give the mission to Sai, so that Sai proves his loyalty to the hokage and ANBU. So even unrelated to Itachi and Uchiha we can say that Danzou should have been killed decades ago. He is weak, weak ninja do not survive. A possible explanation why Danzou is so untouchable: Danzou is an elder of the Senju clan, and the Senju supremacy over the village that was created by them has still big influence on many of the important ninja leaders in the village. Thus not even a hokage can touch him. Suppose there was a royal-family like idea, something based on which Danzou and many others were thinking that Danzou as a Senju has more right to be the 3rd hokage. In this case making hokage a non-Senju Sarutobi means that Sarutobi has Danzou as a very delicate political issue, since he cannot touch Danzou without risking an uprising by all the supporters of Danzou. Unfortunately for this to be true we would need a large number of Senju still having important positions in the village, but apparently there are no Senju there. |
|
2008-05-17, 07:00 | Link #167 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2004
|
Quote:
At that yonge age, Itachi may have lacked that. Gaara being made into the Kazekage only happened because he was son of the last hokage and somehow had the "naruto"-like fan support. I highly doubt Itachi had that kind of charisma.
__________________
|
|
2008-05-17, 07:24 | Link #168 | |
Bubbly and super fun
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Doesn't look like Kansas
|
Quote:
|
|
2008-05-17, 08:24 | Link #169 |
Senior Member
|
even if konoha was really oppressive, considering the options set before him, he picked the best one. countless more lives would have been lost if uchiha hat attempted the coup.
I wonder how what itachi talked to naruto about relates to all of this. maybe madara doesn't know itachi made contact with naruto. and that is what will save sasuke from madara's grasp. then agian he could have just said to take care of sasuke
__________________
|
2008-05-17, 08:46 | Link #170 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Hidden Village of Sake
|
Quote:
What i say that in that particular situation the 3rd hokage should have made Itachi the head of the village even if it meant some internal struggle with people like Danzou. Considering what Itachi has done for the village it had to be clear for the 3rd that Itachi was absolutely loyal to the village, and if he made him hokage he would be the best person to negotiate between the village elders and the Uchiha. In that position he would be able to order Uchiha to STFU and work for the village as they did before the segregation. As a political solution the village would reinstate the Uchiha in their rights and end the segregation, on the other hand Itachi as an insider would make sure that Uchiha are pacified and loyal to the village. Of course Itachi would have to make a sacrifice to show the village his loyalty: he should bring his own father to justice for plotting against the village. As for the hokage title, with the help of the 3rd hokage and even people like Jiraiya and others loyal to the 3rd hokage, Itachi could force Danzou and other elders to officially retire (like Chiyo did), integrate root ANBU into the real ANBU. This would have been the logical solution, the only solution. But since the story of Sasuke and Naruto needed a different solution, Kishimoto made this not logical solution. It is similar to what happened to Haku, but on a much larger scale, thus the plot hole is more visible in this case. In the case of Haku we saw that Haku's death was rather unbeliveable, Kakashi's sharingan which should have seen Haku did not see him, Haku could have killed Kakashi with a kunai if that were true. It was specifically for the reason to have a perfect chidori attack that Kakashi did receive the sharingan eye, that was stated by Yondaime that chidori in itself is not perfect, and sharingan made it perfect, then we see that logic miserably fail when Haku commits suicide. We all know that Haku's death happened because the plot needed it, so we can overlook the plot hole. I guess it's the same situation with Itachi. |
|
2008-05-17, 10:01 | Link #171 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2004
|
Quote:
What an emotional plot back then...unlike this 'spectacular' wow Sasuke is so distraught. I just can't connect with him. Then again, I can't connect with any character in the manga at this moment. |
|
2008-05-17, 11:38 | Link #173 | ||
The Ironman
Join Date: Sep 2006
|
Quote:
Quote:
I'd like to know what happened Team Hebi and Kisame. I gotta say, it was rather sloppy how Kishi set up that situation. He showed team Kakashi's battle, but then team Hebi was just forgotten. If the story goes back to them and they are still fighting, won't seem believable they're still in battle after all this time has passed and if the fight is over, it will seem like a major cop out. Regardless, they need to show the conclusion to that fight soon so it won't be a loose end.
__________________
|
||
2008-05-17, 11:54 | Link #174 | |
Prospective Cog
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Los Angeles, CA
|
Quote:
|
|
2008-05-17, 11:59 | Link #176 | |
Bubbly and super fun
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Doesn't look like Kansas
|
Quote:
Oh well it's kind of pointless to list the many better possibilities than the planned extinction of their strongest clan, it's like listing what Shikamaru could have done if he realistically had 200 IQ. Obviously at this point we are supposed to buy that these were the only two realistic choices with Sarutobi lacking the time to set things right. I can't wait to learn Danzou's side of the story though. |
|
2008-05-17, 12:28 | Link #177 | ||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Hidden Village of Sake
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Last edited by Ero-Senn1n; 2008-05-17 at 12:45. |
||||
2008-05-17, 12:28 | Link #178 | ||
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: ny
|
Quote:
On the other hand, it could also be that the only reason he actually went through with this mission is because of the mental conditioning that Ambu seems to subject their members to. Itachi and Sai share many characteristics as far as showing emotional qualities and their behavior when carrying out mission goals is concerned. If this is the case, Itachi’s love for his younger brother must have been enormous in order to still remain after enduring Ambu’s conditioning. Quote:
I think it is true for the most part, but Madara very likely twisted certain facts. If Madara is smart – which he appears to be – he will not blatantly lie, he’ll subtly mix in lies with the truth. For instance, I don’t believe that the nine tails attack was incidental, nor do I believe Kohona to be as oppressive as he made them seem. And, the way he stated “I just…. wanted to protect the Uchiha clan, that’s all!”… I don’t really believe that’s *all* he wanted to do… It seems pretty obvious to me that he wanted to be on the top of the ninja world along with his clan. The way he introduced Shodai in his story(“he stood at the top of the ninja world and was the man I admired the most”) sounded like it was from the perspective of an up an coming prospect, who had ambitions of becoming the best. You’re seriously worried about naruto of all people, with all that’s going on? |
||
2008-05-17, 13:36 | Link #180 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: The Dark Side of The Moon
|
Quote:
1) his age - so young and tramuatized because of war. true he's unbeleivably skilled as a ninja, with combatical intelligence to match. But he's also easily manipulated. He has talent, and loyalty, but im not sure he had the strength to give orders and lead an entire village @ his age. And i dunno if Sarutobi announcing itachi as his successor would help or hurt matters. I think the clan would be pressuring Itachi twice as much as before, trying to manipulate him to doing things their way, and eventually he would have lost his mind 2) his personality - lol i never thought of all ppl itachi would originally been a pacifist. such an ugly ironic juxtaposition. True he can fight when it's neccessary, but i don't think he does if it's not needed (even now i guess) For example, with him and kisame vs the old geezer jinchuuriki, it looked like he deliberately didn't help kisame (although after double checking kisame stated he wanted to fight it alone) The 'cold hearted' itachi we've all known seems to have been created after he killed his clan, which is to be expected of course. But the soft kind hearted 11yr old itachi probaly wouldn't have bene able to be a very effective hokage. dats what i think but rereading the old chapters and looking @ the akatsuki agendas and stuff makes me wonder WTF??? Itachi kills his clan, to create peace and stop a war... then joins akatsuki who's plan is the exact same thing? WAHHHHHH
__________________
|
|
|
|