AnimeSuki Forums

eLLuSioNiST · 2004-10-17, 22:19

Wassab Guys this is my 1st Time doing a Sig and i want ur comments :P :``) Thanks guys

Sai · 2004-10-17, 22:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by eLLuSioNiST

Wassab Guys this is my 1st Time doing a Sig and i want ur comments :P :``) Thanks guys

eLLuSioNiST: 9 i think you did a really good job for first time

anyways i made a new sig what do you guys think?

eLLuSioNiST · 2004-10-17, 22:26

Hell ya Sai .. i love Sai He's the 2nd best anime Character for me :```)

Sai: 9.5 Really Like The Colors and Great Job

MikoKikyo · 2004-10-17, 22:29

GustaveElazul - good, hopefully this is a real transparency, I'm not going to check, BG is not to my liking though, text is pretty good 9/10

sOnJoOL- think I already rated this.

MS- it's cute, though I find it could use further top cropping 8/10

aahhsin- OMFG naruto is soooo cool!!111!!! 7/10

JOJO- already rated.. methinks.

Shay- BG rules 8.5/10

USB500- lovely, and welcome. 9/10

...I'll rate the rest lata.

Prince of Chronics · 2004-10-17, 22:30

eLLuSioNiST --> nice with the swirling water merging the swirling rasengan.... I don't like the text... but overall.... it's good... [ 85% ]

Sai --> looks like that dude with the really messed up name in Otogizoushi... that guy is pretty tough for a dancer.... [ 84% ]

PriestessKikyo --> looks similar in the design to that red one you were usin a few weeks ago... nice still .... [ 85% ]

eLLuSioNiST · 2004-10-17, 22:36

Prince of Chronics --> 8 nice and simple but too small for sig

PriestessKikyo --> 8.5 Like the Colors :```)

sarcasteak · 2004-10-17, 22:50

GustaveElazul - Good work extracting it, but I've never been a big fan of Pacifica and I don't like the aqua green background at all.

Midori - It's too blurry and unlike silly aahhsin I actually prefer white backgrounds. It's very cute (exchanging animals!), but I like the overall laid back feel of your previous one.

eLLuSioNiST - Very interesting and good lookin'. Good job with what you did, but I simply don't like the excessive special effects done to it. Your second one is just plain awful in my view as the OMG COOL BORDER!!11 doesn't match the character and the scene at all, and don't get me started about your font choice; ugh, don't ever use it.

Sai - How very fitting! It's not great, but it's good enough.

MidoriShinobi · 2004-10-17, 23:03

@Sarcasteak - I can't help it. I'm a ShikaIno fan. It's too good of a pun. 8/10

Real · 2004-10-17, 23:20

Ellusionest : Very cool effects, I like it a lot. Only the lettering keeps it from perfection 9.5/10

Prince of Chronics: I really like the coloring, seems perfect. Can't beat that expression very nice. could be a tad bigger maybe 9.5/10

sig by Mezu (thanks again

)

Desparado · 2004-10-17, 23:56

eLLuSioNiST: i give it a 9/10. i like the grafics.

Real: i give it an 9/10 as well. not much secial to it but there dosent need to be. i love how the name stands out yet blends in all at the same time. it maches the rest of the sig perfectly.

GustaveElazul · 2004-10-18, 00:12

I didn't like the aqua green either, I put it in since I couldn't make up my mind

I'll probably work on a changing it or making a new sig with a similiar design.

sarcasteak · 2004-10-18, 00:46

Real - My goodness, where should I start? I don't want to be mean or anything...okay, fine, I'm going to be downright mean like aahhsin and tell it like it is!

The background, while "OMG cool lookin!!1 lol," does not match the theme of this sig. The name is well-placed yet poorly done, and while blue is my favorite color, I can't stand the clash of the solid light blue against the fancy blueness in the background.

Now there is NOTHING wrong with the theme of this sig. You want to do Hokages, fine. But my gawd why are their images all condensed disproportionally?! And what's with the pixely edges?! The contrast/lighting/coloring of the 3rd vs the 1st + the 2nd vs the 4th don't match AT ALL.

God, I hate to be mean, but this is awful. No border, too. And this Mezu person actually has the shamelessness to put his name on it? My goodness.

F

Desparado - Yours is not as bad as the above one, but it's not much better.

It's nice that you are trying to create a dark moody sig, but this image is awfully low quality. Being dark and foggy is one thing; being blurry and crappy is another.

The damn black text is impossible to read; it's downright stupid looking the way it is.

The double-frame pixel-style border looks COMPLETELY out-of-place with the dark blurry moody theme of the picture. And don't get me started on the white stripe design...it's atrocious! Can't you see how the whites clash so strongly with the rest of the sig yet adds no value at all whatsoever? How is this cool I simply cannot comprehend.

F

Note: nothing against you guys personally, but I just can't understand how you can actually think these sigs looks good.

GustaveElazul · 2004-10-18, 01:28

Made a new signature. I went through all my old anime files and found an untitled picture with a girl sitting on a bench in the snow. It looked cool so I decided to make it my sig

. I thought she was more neutral compared to using popular or well known characters like Pacifica from Scrapped Princess.

Before

After (below)

sarcasteak · 2004-10-18, 01:31

GustaveElazul - Once again I commend your image cropping and clean-up. I think you should've zoomed in closer so we can see her cute face better...that would sacrfice some of the miko-outfit, but I think it's worth it. The background and name this time work PERFECTLY; this is how you make a sig and some of these guys should learn a thing or two from you!

GustaveElazul · 2004-10-18, 01:35

Thankyou sarcasteak, that kind of reponse makes it well worth the effort to make a sig like this

.

eLLuSioNiST · 2004-10-18, 02:56

MidoriShinobi -- > 9 Simply Cute and nice :``)

GustaveElazul --> 8 Like sarcasteak Said "Once again I commend your image cropping and clean-up"

Desparado --> 9 Simple Nice and Dark :`)

sarcasteak --> 8 not that bad of a Quality and nothing new Cut & paste

Evan · 2004-10-18, 03:40

GustaveElazul 8 for the wonderful sweet gal~

eLLuSioNiST 7 kinda dark for the BG~

sarcasteak 9 is that yuri? lol

sarcasteak · 2004-10-18, 04:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by eLLuSioNiST

sarcasteak --> 8 not that bad of a Quality and nothing new Cut & paste

Just because I don't like fancy effects doesn't mean it's an instant-sig.

Quote:

Originally Posted by <EvAnGeLiOn>

sarcasteak 9 is that yuri? lol

You bet it is!

<EvAnGeLiOn> - How cute!

Since I'm a fan of Seed which you should already have known

, I like this a lot!

eLLuSioNiST - A lot better this time because of the font change; good work.

Evan · 2004-10-18, 04:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by sarcasteak

<EvAnGeLiOn> - How cute!

Since I'm a fan of Seed which you should already have known

, I like this a lot!

Heehee,me too

I love the "gay" thing for seed~ lol

Don't mind I give myself a 10/10? lol

Ayame · 2004-10-18, 11:43

MidoriShinobi:....KAWAII!!!!!! Shika and Ino ^.^!!! YAY! 10/10!

2004-10-17, 22:29	Link #5124
MikoKikyo * Join Date: Mar 2004 Age: 37	GustaveElazul - good, hopefully this is a real transparency, I'm not going to check, BG is not to my liking though, text is pretty good 9/10 sOnJoOL- think I already rated this. MS- it's cute, though I find it could use further top cropping 8/10 aahhsin- OMFG naruto is soooo cool!!111!!! 7/10 JOJO- already rated.. methinks. Shay- BG rules 8.5/10 USB500- lovely, and welcome. 9/10 ...I'll rate the rest lata. Last edited by MikoKikyo; 2004-10-17 at 23:48.

2004-10-17, 22:30	Link #5125
Prince of Chronics One Piece fan Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Toronto, Canada	eLLuSioNiST --> nice with the swirling water merging the swirling rasengan.... I don't like the text... but overall.... it's good... [ 85% ] Sai --> looks like that dude with the really messed up name in Otogizoushi... that guy is pretty tough for a dancer.... [ 84% ] PriestessKikyo --> looks similar in the design to that red one you were usin a few weeks ago... nice still .... [ 85% ] __________________ MyAnimeList page

2004-10-17, 22:36	Link #5126
eLLuSioNiST Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: KuwaiT Age: 42	Prince of Chronics --> 8 nice and simple but too small for sig PriestessKikyo --> 8.5 Like the Colors :```) Last edited by eLLuSioNiST; 2004-10-17 at 22:55.

2004-10-17, 23:20	Link #5129
Real ....Elemental.... Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: Shores of Valinor.....	Ellusionest : Very cool effects, I like it a lot. Only the lettering keeps it from perfection 9.5/10 Prince of Chronics: I really like the coloring, seems perfect. Can't beat that expression very nice. could be a tad bigger maybe 9.5/10 sig by Mezu (thanks again)

2004-10-17, 22:19	Link #5121
eLLuSioNiST Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: KuwaiT Age: 42	Wassab Guys this is my 1st Time doing a Sig and i want ur comments :P :``) Thanks guys

2004-10-17, 22:26	Link #5123
eLLuSioNiST Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: KuwaiT Age: 42	Hell ya Sai .. i love Sai He's the 2nd best anime Character for me :```) Sai: 9.5 Really Like The Colors and Great Job

2004-10-17, 22:50	Link #5127
sarcasteak WAHA~ Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: World overloaded with fun Age: 40	GustaveElazul - Good work extracting it, but I've never been a big fan of Pacifica and I don't like the aqua green background at all. Midori - It's too blurry and unlike silly aahhsin I actually prefer white backgrounds. It's very cute (exchanging animals!), but I like the overall laid back feel of your previous one. eLLuSioNiST - Very interesting and good lookin'. Good job with what you did, but I simply don't like the excessive special effects done to it. Your second one is just plain awful in my view as the OMG COOL BORDER!!11 doesn't match the character and the scene at all, and don't get me started about your font choice; ugh, don't ever use it. Sai - How very fitting! It's not great, but it's good enough.

2004-10-17, 23:03	Link #5128
MidoriShinobi Boha-haha!! Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: 東京 Age: 36	@Sarcasteak - I can't help it. I'm a ShikaIno fan. It's too good of a pun. 8/10

2004-10-17, 23:56	Link #5130
Desparado Junior Member Join Date: Oct 2004 Location: Federal Way Washington U.S.A. Age: 42	eLLuSioNiST: i give it a 9/10. i like the grafics. Real: i give it an 9/10 as well. not much secial to it but there dosent need to be. i love how the name stands out yet blends in all at the same time. it maches the rest of the sig perfectly.

2004-10-18, 00:12	Link #5131
GustaveElazul Gus Join Date: Oct 2004	I didn't like the aqua green either, I put it in since I couldn't make up my mind I'll probably work on a changing it or making a new sig with a similiar design.

2004-10-18, 00:46	Link #5132
sarcasteak WAHA~ Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: World overloaded with fun Age: 40	Real - My goodness, where should I start? I don't want to be mean or anything...okay, fine, I'm going to be downright mean like aahhsin and tell it like it is! The background, while "OMG cool lookin!!1 lol," does not match the theme of this sig. The name is well-placed yet poorly done, and while blue is my favorite color, I can't stand the clash of the solid light blue against the fancy blueness in the background. Now there is NOTHING wrong with the theme of this sig. You want to do Hokages, fine. But my gawd why are their images all condensed disproportionally?! And what's with the pixely edges?! The contrast/lighting/coloring of the 3rd vs the 1st + the 2nd vs the 4th don't match AT ALL. God, I hate to be mean, but this is awful. No border, too. And this Mezu person actually has the shamelessness to put his name on it? My goodness. F Desparado - Yours is not as bad as the above one, but it's not much better. It's nice that you are trying to create a dark moody sig, but this image is awfully low quality. Being dark and foggy is one thing; being blurry and crappy is another. The damn black text is impossible to read; it's downright stupid looking the way it is. The double-frame pixel-style border looks COMPLETELY out-of-place with the dark blurry moody theme of the picture. And don't get me started on the white stripe design...it's atrocious! Can't you see how the whites clash so strongly with the rest of the sig yet adds no value at all whatsoever? How is this cool I simply cannot comprehend. F Note: nothing against you guys personally, but I just can't understand how you can actually think these sigs looks good.

2004-10-18, 01:28	Link #5133
GustaveElazul Gus Join Date: Oct 2004	Made a new signature. I went through all my old anime files and found an untitled picture with a girl sitting on a bench in the snow. It looked cool so I decided to make it my sig . I thought she was more neutral compared to using popular or well known characters like Pacifica from Scrapped Princess. Before After (below)

2004-10-18, 01:31	Link #5134
sarcasteak WAHA~ Join Date: Mar 2004 Location: World overloaded with fun Age: 40	GustaveElazul - Once again I commend your image cropping and clean-up. I think you should've zoomed in closer so we can see her cute face better...that would sacrfice some of the miko-outfit, but I think it's worth it. The background and name this time work PERFECTLY; this is how you make a sig and some of these guys should learn a thing or two from you!

2004-10-18, 01:35	Link #5135
GustaveElazul Gus Join Date: Oct 2004	Thankyou sarcasteak, that kind of reponse makes it well worth the effort to make a sig like this .

2004-10-18, 02:56	Link #5136
eLLuSioNiST Junior Member Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: KuwaiT Age: 42	MidoriShinobi -- > 9 Simply Cute and nice :``) GustaveElazul --> 8 Like sarcasteak Said "Once again I commend your image cropping and clean-up" Desparado --> 9 Simple Nice and Dark :`) sarcasteak --> 8 not that bad of a Quality and nothing new Cut & paste

2004-10-18, 03:40	Link #5137
Evan 天使我爱你 Join Date: Jul 2003 Location: With My Hime Natsuki-sama	GustaveElazul 8 for the wonderful sweet gal~ eLLuSioNiST 7 kinda dark for the BG~ sarcasteak 9 is that yuri? lol

2004-10-18, 11:43	Link #5140
Ayame Inuzuka Kiba Glomper Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Holland Age: 32	MidoriShinobi:....KAWAII!!!!!! Shika and Ino ^.^!!! YAY! 10/10!