AnimeSuki Forums

Ryota · 2004-12-13, 06:19

Even if she did survive, wouldn't she be more like Bartefeld-san? (spelling)

At least with 1 arm instead of 2...

taluss · 2004-12-13, 12:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by ryogax

This is the STUPIDEST TOPIC Yet!
Next to my own topic! Cagali is getting stupider every episode!

I congratulate you for overcoming my stupidity.

In case you have not noticed we are talking about "MAY BE " (possibility ===> can be true / false ) cases since the begining

but If you think you were being stupid then......

K'9999 · 2004-12-13, 15:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by taluss

In case you have not noticed we are talking about "MAY BE " (possibility ===> can be true / false ) cases since the begining

but If you think you were being stupid then......

May be? Even though you think it is "may be", it won't be happened. Impossible. Never. Never. Absolutely no. In that case, maybe Kira is Shinn; Rey is Kira's father (if you think it is "maybe") Take a closer look at episode one, please. "may be" Damn!

eMpTy265 · 2004-12-13, 15:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by taluss

In case you have not noticed we are talking about "MAY BE " (possibility ===> can be true / false ) cases since the begining

but If you think you were being stupid then......

Quote:

Originally Posted by K'9999

May be? Even though you think it "may be", it won't be happening. Impossible. Never. Never. Absolutely not. <snip> Take a closer look at episode one, please. "may be" Damn!

Well, you do have to remember that this IS an anime.... anything's possible.

Granted, the likelihood of Mayu surviving is around the same as Bartfield surviving his MS's explosion (oh wait.. he did.), or Fraga surviving (nevermind....).
[In simple english, she PROBABLY didn't survive, but anything's POSSIBLE (in the anime world.]

Now, as for her being Stella.... I'd say the likelihood of that being true is similar to the probability of Mia being Fllay. (As in the same person, not personality / suggestive-factor etc.)

alyin · 2004-12-13, 16:13

I do agree . I think there is a misunderstanding of this simple english

If she did survive fine! if she died fine !

its just a freaking anime

since its "may be" then everything is possible

only in anime gundams exists

Sanjuronord · 2004-12-13, 16:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by ryogax

looks like it..

incest must be common among coordinators.

Well when you start messing with your genes you also mess w/ the information that makes you technically brother and sister.

Out of curiousity, have they even said whether or not the rest of Shinn's family were coordinators or not?

glyph · 2004-12-13, 16:59

seeing as how we are discussing crackpot premises here

Or maybe the whole first ten minutes of SEED Destiny NEVER ACTUALLY HAPPENED.

Spoiler for Shin's dark secret revealed!:

Spoiler for more about Shin:

ryogax · 2004-12-13, 17:36

better yet!

Spoiler:

Colonel- · 2004-12-13, 17:37

Heh, he's got a point. If and only if Fraga survive a point blank anti-matter blast and survives the vacuum of space without a helmet, then i wouldn't say the chances of Stella being Mayu be nil =)

Is it just me or we got some thought nazis on this forum?

alyin · 2004-12-13, 18:06

Wrong .. wrong ... and wrong

you R all wrong

you got it wrong

I say:

Stellar is shin's mother (real genetic and DNA mother ) thats why when she saw him she freaked out seeing someone like her son\
\she has her first baby(shin) when she was very young \\

now

let's argue

kuroitatsu · 2004-12-13, 19:02

uhh didnt shinn get the cell phonefrom her arm that was blown off?

Sanjuronord · 2004-12-14, 07:29

Quote:

Originally Posted by kuroitatsu

uhh didnt shinn get the cell phonefrom her arm that was blown off?

No he went to retrieve the phone after she dropped it, that's the only reason he survived.

Depresionist · 2004-12-14, 15:39

I think the conclusion is:

Spoiler:

eMpTy265 · 2004-12-14, 16:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by Depresionist

I think the conclusion is:

Spoiler:

Spoiler for because the last post had the spoiler tags:

guess we're completely

now...

mokomoko · 2004-12-15, 17:10

one word for this thread topic = RIDICULOUS

srb · 2004-12-15, 17:36

But it's very funny

.

mokomoko · 2004-12-16, 07:53

Someone's been smoking the peace pipe when he thought of this......

aris385 · 2004-12-16, 09:51

I doubt stellar is shin's little sis. It would ruin their chances at a crazy relationship.
Better idea Stellar is a witch and transformed her remains into her fish.

DwArD · 2004-12-16, 20:16

Stellar is Mayu! Wow! That's a very good guess. Actually, I did thought of that before, but threw away that thought after I remembered the blast scene. Seriously, whose hand can that be when only Shinn and his family were around at that time? We'll eventually find out Stellar past so I won't worry too much about that. My guess is, Shinn will meet Stellar one day again, got to chat with her, and realise that she sort of resembles his sis in some sense! It doesn't necessarily mean Stellar is Mayu. Maybe Stellar sort of reminded Shinn of Mayu! Besides, do we know whether Mayu is a coordinator or not? So far, we only knew Shinn is a coordinator.

Edit: After watching phase 9 again, I agree to a certain extent that Stellar may be Mayu. Look carefully at their eye colour. Both Mayu and Stellar have purple eyes. Jeez, that's a bit creepy. I think I'm freaking out. Heck, if you compare Mayu in phase 9 and Stellar in phase 1, you will also notice they seemed to look very alike when they laughed or smiled!

Tiberium Wolf · 2004-12-17, 02:55

I think Stellar is Mayu!

After watching ep 9 you can clearly see that Mayu has red eyes and so does Stellar.
Then I remembered ep 2 when Auel used the block words on Stellar. She freaked out. Notice here that her right arm is trembling. So remembering ep 1... Mayu had her right harm torn off... So I guess Stellar is Mayu since also because she has a trauma about death and that torn off arm fealing still lingers in her mind.

BTW, no one check if Mayu was alive or dead. The officer there might have taken Shinn right away coz they were evacuating. From the 1st glance they(Shinn family were dead so no need to check if other ppl life were in stake.

2004-12-13, 16:59	Link #67
glyph Senior Member Join Date: Aug 2004	seeing as how we are discussing crackpot premises here Or maybe the whole first ten minutes of SEED Destiny NEVER ACTUALLY HAPPENED. Spoiler for Shin's dark secret revealed!: Shin is really a highly trained deep cover EA agent with his true memories suppressed by a block word (similar to Stellar, Auel & Sting). His dead family and sister never existed - he has been fed false memories of his traumatic past to give him a convincing background and determination to infiltrate ZAFT ranks successfully as a mole after the war. That pink phone is probably bugged and/or he subconsciously uses it to send his reports and get his orders every time he fiddles with it when he's alone. (He's been conditioned by his memories to carry it everywhere he goes as a keepsake). Shin is the reason why the details of Abyss, Gaia and Chaos' top secret development project somehow got leaked to EA. His secondary mission is to locate and (if possible) terminate the meddlesome Freedom with extreme prejudice. (Hence he's been set up to bear a blood feud against its pilot). Unfortunately, it turns out that the Kira and co. weren't hiding out in PLANT after the war after all, so it turns out EA was looking in the wrong place. At some point, probably after he acquires his Destiny Gundam, his handlers will reel him in by calling on the pink phone and activating his block word. Then he will turn on his friends and abruptly defect to EA with the uber mech much to everyone's surprise. Spoiler for more about Shin: or maybe not.

2004-12-13, 17:36	Link #68
ryogax Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2004	better yet! Spoiler: Lacus is really Princess Relina! She was traveling in space and somehow went inside a blackhole! Now shes in a new alternate dimension with new personality! :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers: :fingers:

2004-12-14, 15:39	Link #73
Depresionist Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Canada Age: 38	I think the conclusion is: Spoiler: Stellar cloned Mayu's cellphone. __________________

2004-12-16, 20:16	Link #79
DwArD mAnIaC Join Date: Apr 2003 Location: Somewhere In This World Age: 36	Stellar is Mayu! Wow! That's a very good guess. Actually, I did thought of that before, but threw away that thought after I remembered the blast scene. Seriously, whose hand can that be when only Shinn and his family were around at that time? We'll eventually find out Stellar past so I won't worry too much about that. My guess is, Shinn will meet Stellar one day again, got to chat with her, and realise that she sort of resembles his sis in some sense! It doesn't necessarily mean Stellar is Mayu. Maybe Stellar sort of reminded Shinn of Mayu! Besides, do we know whether Mayu is a coordinator or not? So far, we only knew Shinn is a coordinator. Edit: After watching phase 9 again, I agree to a certain extent that Stellar may be Mayu. Look carefully at their eye colour. Both Mayu and Stellar have purple eyes. Jeez, that's a bit creepy. I think I'm freaking out. Heck, if you compare Mayu in phase 9 and Stellar in phase 1, you will also notice they seemed to look very alike when they laughed or smiled! __________________ If man does find the solution for world peace it will be the most revolutionary reversal of his record we have ever known. George C. Marshall (1880 - 1959) Last edited by DwArD; 2004-12-17 at 02:50.

2004-12-13, 06:19	Link #61
Ryota Nee kikoemasuka? Join Date: May 2003 Location: Still looking for my Happy Place Age: 41	Even if she did survive, wouldn't she be more like Bartefeld-san? (spelling) At least with 1 arm instead of 2...

2004-12-13, 16:13	Link #65
alyin Junior Member Join Date: Dec 2004	I do agree . I think there is a misunderstanding of this simple english If she did survive fine! if she died fine ! its just a freaking anime since its "may be" then everything is possible only in anime gundams exists

2004-12-13, 17:37	Link #69
Colonel- Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Ca	Heh, he's got a point. If and only if Fraga survive a point blank anti-matter blast and survives the vacuum of space without a helmet, then i wouldn't say the chances of Stella being Mayu be nil =) Is it just me or we got some thought nazis on this forum?

2004-12-13, 18:06	Link #70
alyin Junior Member Join Date: Dec 2004	Wrong .. wrong ... and wrong you R all wrong you got it wrong I say: Stellar is shin's mother (real genetic and DNA mother ) thats why when she saw him she freaked out seeing someone like her son\ \she has her first baby(shin) when she was very young \\ now let's argue

2004-12-13, 19:02	Link #71
kuroitatsu Über Alles Join Date: Aug 2004 Age: 37	uhh didnt shinn get the cell phonefrom her arm that was blown off?

2004-12-15, 17:10	Link #75
mokomoko horny mushroom Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: unknown Age: 40	one word for this thread topic = RIDICULOUS

2004-12-15, 17:36	Link #76
srb I can see time itself! Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Kingdom of Sweden Age: 37	But it's very funny .

2004-12-16, 07:53	Link #77
mokomoko horny mushroom Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: unknown Age: 40	Someone's been smoking the peace pipe when he thought of this......

2004-12-16, 09:51	Link #78
aris385 Member Join Date: Dec 2004	I doubt stellar is shin's little sis. It would ruin their chances at a crazy relationship. Better idea Stellar is a witch and transformed her remains into her fish.

2004-12-17, 02:55	Link #80
Tiberium Wolf Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Portugal Age: 44	I think Stellar is Mayu! After watching ep 9 you can clearly see that Mayu has red eyes and so does Stellar. Then I remembered ep 2 when Auel used the block words on Stellar. She freaked out. Notice here that her right arm is trembling. So remembering ep 1... Mayu had her right harm torn off... So I guess Stellar is Mayu since also because she has a trauma about death and that torn off arm fealing still lingers in her mind. BTW, no one check if Mayu was alive or dead. The officer there might have taken Shinn right away coz they were evacuating. From the 1st glance they(Shinn family were dead so no need to check if other ppl life were in stake.