Fate/Grand Order (Mobile RPG)

[Kohakuren]

Originally Posted by GDB

I don't care for her at all, but anyone who says she's as low as Artemis is crazy. For 5-stars, Artemis is an entirely different tier of bad, while Attila I'd say is just at the low end of the mediocre tier (will move up whenever her interlude comes out that increases her NP damage). Attila is still of 5 star quality, while I'd say Artemis isn't even as good as many 4-stars.

well, i think i would use Alter over her though. so yea, thats that if i had to rate sabers it would go Arturia=Okita>Alter>Atilla>Nero>Seig>D'eon
For 5* Atilla really meh. Her skills are hard to use properly (For example NP damage up is nice - but you need NP chain for it to be better than normal charisma) overall she have only stats. to be valid she need revamp or at least buff of skills.

[GDB]

Alter, like Herc, is in a weird place where she's basically a 5-star in terms of attack, NP, ascension materials required, and skills, but has lower health in order to keep her at a 4-star's sortie cost. As such, I try not to use those two as comparisons for star power since they're such outliers.

In fact, because of her lower sortie cost, I'd actually rank Alter higher than regular Arturia since the regular's stats are only marginally better. I feel Okita's the best, but not by much since Alter/Arturia are better team players (so it'd come down to team composition, not that most people would ever need to decide between them). Nero's in a weird spot, since she's not a team player at all, yet depending on your team and CE of choice can either be a one-Empress army (seriously saw someone solo the Rider 40AP with her) or a massive DPS engine when paired with art boosters like Tamamo no Mae (since Nero is the only gold Servant with an AoE Art NP). Seigfried I'd definitely put at the bottom, though. Sure, he might be "stronger" than d'Eon, but he's outclassed in almost every way by most gold Servants, whereas d'Eon at least has a niche as a gold taunter.

[Tenzen12]

At least she is not Arthuria, that's always plus. And her NP is burst with defense debuff.

[Kohakuren]

Lol, just now YOLO rolled 2nd Meido raida CE - i guess time to burn Apples is here now

[iNoto]

Originally Posted by Unknown Soldier

I dunno about that, she generates stars just fine on her own. She's no Gilgamesh or Drake in terms of broken OP stargen, not surprising since Gil and Drake were limited-time super-whale gacha servants and Nobu is a free event servant. But I hit an AQQ Brave chain with her that popped out 26 stars yesterday, so I think her star generation is pretty decent. She's worlds better than poor Nyatalanta there, that's for damn sure.

What's up with Atalanta? I heard she is scrub tier 4 star... dunno why all the hate. I saw her NP @ youtube and it looked pretty good.

[MartianMage]

Originally Posted by iNoto

What's up with Atalanta? I heard she is scrub tier 4 star... dunno why all the hate. I saw her NP @ youtube and it looked pretty good.

Atalanta suffers from low stats and being overly reliant on her NP but the problem is... she's so bad at building NP... when running Atalanta and you want to use her NP you have to make sure you have a way to get that NP bar full and it's not gonna be easy really. Either you put an arts chainer into the party or give her a kscope.

[iNoto]

Originally Posted by MartianMage

Atalanta suffers from low stats and being overly reliant on her NP but the problem is... she's so bad at building NP... when running Atalanta and you want to use her NP you have to make sure you have a way to get that NP bar full and it's not gonna be easy really. Either you put an arts chainer into the party or give her a kscope.

Hopefully I'm able to get her in my next roll along with marie. I have 1 kaleido.

[El Rue]

I still want my own Atalanya...


Got my 4th Nobu for Lv4 NP. Man, I honestly gave up back then on reaching it but the 1AP quest have been getting very generous. Nobu~ NOBU~!

Still hard at work buying those Mats & Fou's, thank you fake Benkei for being a swell punching bag who can stun or poison at most.

Free ticket results in predictable disappointment. Mm, I really have low luck for this event after all huh...

[kuroishinigami]

Originally Posted by Kohakuren

well, i think i would use Alter over her though. so yea, thats that if i had to rate sabers it would go Arturia=Okita>Alter>Atilla>Nero>Seig>D'eon
For 5* Atilla really meh. Her skills are hard to use properly (For example NP damage up is nice - but you need NP chain for it to be better than normal charisma) overall she have only stats. to be valid she need revamp or at least buff of skills.

Is Attila really that bad? Her first skill is situational, and her second skill is pretty meh, but her third skill IMO is really good. She really hits enemy hards with her third skill activated, more than Alter with charisma activated

[GDB]

Her first skill is bad because it's NP only, and no stronger than most Charisma buffs (9%). Further, unlike Charisma, it only lasts 1 turn instead of 3.

Her second skill is god awful. I'm used to it because of Nero, but at least Nero can make use of it if you go for the Empress tank build (using Tamamo Maid CE). Without it, it's awful.

Her third skill isn't awful, but it's not that good either. Stars on demand is always nice, but most self-only attack buffs aren't any better than Charisma. This grants 10%, which is 0.5% weaker than Gil's Charisma.

Her NP's defense down is only 10% too, so nothing special really.

Basically low-end mediocre across the board (other than her attack stat) until her NP interlude comes out, at which point she'll probably be high-end mediocre. Unless they start power creeping Servants too hard.

[Unknown Soldier]

Originally Posted by El Rue

I still want my own Atalanya...

I've had her forever and I rarely ever use her. She's just so bad at everything. I don't have a K-scope either so trying to build up to her NP is awful, and I've never found a team built with the servants I have which makes her valuable. I mean even if she starts with 80% NP charge, it would probably take her 2 turns to reach 100%, that's how bad her NP charge rate is.

Meanwhile, some of the broken NP chargers in this game like Gil, Drake, and Okita can Brave chain out 50% of their bar by themselves. Of course servants who can Brave Arts chain with themselves like Emiya, Caster Lizzy, and Medea can shit out 75% of their bars in a single turn before NP charge buffs or crits. NP growth is so brokenly unbalanced in this game, and servants which have shit NP growth like Nyatalanta are borderline useless because of how important burst damage is unless you have Kintoki or Heracles.

[5596050]

Just did a 10 roll, got spooked by Gilles, Mephis and Shinjis.... Saw a golden Archer card and was hoping for it to be either Artemis or Atalanta... But nope it was EMIYA OTL.

Also gold saber card but it was Siegfried welp.

[Starway]

Originally Posted by Unknown Soldier

I've had her forever and I rarely ever use her. She's just so bad at everything. I don't have a K-scope either so trying to build up to her NP is awful, and I've never found a team built with the servants I have which makes her valuable. I mean even if she starts with 80% NP charge, it would probably take her 2 turns to reach 100%, that's how bad her NP charge rate is.

Meanwhile, some of the broken NP chargers in this game like Gil, Drake, and Okita can Brave chain out 50% of their bar by themselves. Of course servants who can Brave Arts chain with themselves like Emiya, Caster Lizzy, and Medea can shit out 75% of their bars in a single turn before NP charge buffs or crits. NP growth is so brokenly unbalanced in this game, and servants which have shit NP growth like Nyatalanta are borderline useless because of how important burst damage is unless you have Kintoki or Heracles.

Emiya np growth is horrible only 7 odd points per arts card the only reason people don't notice is because he has 3 arts all archer even Gil seem to have horrible np growth like Artemis who's quicks give more than her arts.

[LowCholesterol]

tbh i want Sieg.
his design is cool, but i got second d'Eon from my ticket...

[Unknown Soldier]

Originally Posted by Starway

Emiya np growth is horrible only 7 odd points per arts card the only reason people don't notice is because he has 3 arts all archer even Gil seem to have horrible np growth like Artemis who's quicks give more than her arts.

His per hit NP growth isn't good but he has 3 Arts cards, per hit NP growth means fuck-all to him

[kuroishinigami]

Originally Posted by GDB

Her first skill is bad because it's NP only, and no stronger than most Charisma buffs (9%). Further, unlike Charisma, it only lasts 1 turn instead of 3.

Her second skill is god awful. I'm used to it because of Nero, but at least Nero can make use of it if you go for the Empress tank build (using Tamamo Maid CE). Without it, it's awful.

Her third skill isn't awful, but it's not that good either. Stars on demand is always nice, but most self-only attack buffs aren't any better than Charisma. This grants 10%, which is 0.5% weaker than Gil's Charisma.

Her NP's defense down is only 10% too, so nothing special really.

Basically low-end mediocre across the board (other than her attack stat) until her NP interlude comes out, at which point she'll probably be high-end mediocre. Unless they start power creeping Servants too hard.

I don't know, I've been using her for a while and Gil aside(because he's broken, and do remember, Gil has that 0.95 multiplier), I never feel her to be inferior to other max level saber(sans Okita) like Alter or Arturia. In fact, she's the only saber for me to manage killing lancer enemy with 180k HP in one brave chain. It might be just personal bias speaking though

[R.LocK]

Correction to Atalanta: she's not awful, she's just very high maintenance. And I'd not advise putting any NP-charge CE on her. If you're using her, then most likely you're using Lancelot who needs it way more badly.

Then again, it's me, and I have a max-ascended Moon Festa.

[Starlightz]

29 Hiragumo + 16.2k EP from the new Caster daily (using my normal point farming team @440% + 1 Maidusa CE from support), with the Demon being on the 2nd wave as expected (hearts, hearts, hearts). Was a bit tight since my point farming team's lvl wasn't high, plus my Rider (Ushi) is only at lvl. 50. Anyway, at this rate, getting 40 Hiragumo per run from Avicii isn't that far fetched

If you don't have a Rider and isn't using your A team, I think you should look for one in support or blow your NP on the Demon as it can does 3 hits in one turn and capable of critting up to 3-4k on a neutral servant. Not sure about Giles since I finished him before he got to use his NP (Ushi's BNPQ chain does 150k in a turn).

Edit: I think I like this kind of drops

Spoiler:

[belatkuro]

Just like in the Rider quest, using Herc does the job well. This time I have Medusa doing additional damage since I didn't use another Assassin for Drake. Gonna use an apple or two I guess. Almost close to buying out the gears, claws and hearts. Once I bought them all I'll buy out the horseshoe next. Gonna save babies last since I still have a lot and only David and Hassan are gonna use it.

[Starway]

Originally Posted by Starlightz

29 Hiragumo + 16.2k EP from the new Caster daily (using my normal point farming team @440% + 1 Maidusa CE from support), with the Demon being on the 2nd wave as expected (hearts, hearts, hearts). Was a bit tight since my point farming team's lvl wasn't high, plus my Rider (Ushi) is only at lvl. 50. Anyway, at this rate, getting 40 Hiragumo per run from Avicii isn't that far fetched

If you don't have a Rider and isn't using your A team, I think you should look for one in support or blow your NP on the Demon as it can does 3 hits in one turn and capable of critting up to 3-4k on a neutral servant. Not sure about Giles since I finished him before he got to use his NP (Ushi's BNPQ chain does 150k in a turn).

Edit: I think I like this kind of drops

Spoiler:

440% drop and two eyes and a heart In one run man you've got some luck this event congrats I'm on 320% with still zero Ce drops, this event as not been kind rolling drake must of ate all my luck oh well I'll be able to level her soon.

Originally Posted by belatkuro

Just like in the Rider quest, using Herc does the job well. This time I have Medusa doing additional damage since I didn't use another Assassin for Drake. Gonna use an apple or two I guess. Almost close to buying out the gears, claws and hearts. Once I bought them all I'll buy out the horseshoe next. Gonna save babies last since I still have a lot and only David and Hassan are gonna use it.

How many Apples have you spent or how many medusa Ce do you have