Mahouka [LN/M] - Character Speculation/Theories: Miyuki

[bietchie11]

Originally Posted by Ravagerblade

^
IMO, they were surprised that "She" used an A-ranked magic not that she used an "A-ranked Magic". Also I think knowing the AS plays a part in using magic btw so of course they'd be surprised when she uses certain magic.

What's "AS"?

[Ravagerblade]

Originally Posted by bietchie11

What's "AS"?

Activation Sequence.

[bietchie11]

Originally Posted by Ravagerblade

Activation Sequence.

Oh ok.

Then again, the LN spelled it out that everyone is shocked because Nilfhelm and Inferno are extremely difficult but Miyuki used it at ease, not because of the rareness of the AS. (after all it is used to test every magicians on a general exam, how rare can it be?)

Their reaction is totally different compared to when she used Flying-magic for the first time. (which is an example of shock due to rare spells.)

[Ravagerblade]

Originally Posted by bietchie11

Oh ok.

Then again, the LN spelled it out that everyone is shocked because Nilfhelm and Inferno are extremely difficult but Miyuki used it at ease, not because of the rareness of the AS. (after all it is used to test every magicians on a general exam, how rare can it be?)

Their reaction is totally different compared to when she used Flying-magic for the first time. (which is an example of shock due to rare spells.)

The reaction is different because it was just invented not even on the market and somebody already has it in use (suspicious much) at least something like that.

[Echizen777]

Originally Posted by bietchie11

Inferno is mentioned as another A-rank magic.
Mist Dispersion is classified.
Rupture is above B-rank as Tatsuya commented how Masaki has to use B-rank magic in 9-sc shows being powerful is sometime bothersome.

But whatever, may be you are right.
However, like i said before, if Mari and Mayumi could do it, they wouldn't react like they did in 9-sc

Mist Dispersion is A rank

Spoiler for QUOTE:

"Fujibayashi-san, the Juumonji Family's 'Phalanx' ability is defensive magic, so there's no destructive power involved. Likewise, the greatest advantage in the Saegusa Family's 'Magic Shooter' is its sheer flexibility in force applied, so its destructive power also varies. On the other hand, 'Mist Dispersal' is indisputably an A-rank magic in destructive power that is able to reduce an object down to its molecular level, so they cannot be compared side by side."

Rupture is A rank

Spoiler for Rupture:

("Rupture" is a magic that possesses A-Rank destructive power...... Maybe.)

Masaki's Bias Release was not B rank, he was using a low level magic so that he would not exceed the level of firepower authorized since his shots are too powerful.

For Naotsugu, he detected but failed to block. "Taken by surprised" is not a really convincing excuse as both Tatsuya and Nao sensed the attack coming..
[spoiler="Yep, he can't block it"]
an intense sense of danger assaulted Tatsuya.

Naotsugu probably sensed it as well. Tatsuya hit the deck and Naotsugu raised his kodachi almost simultaneously.

Brionac is impossible to block completely. Both sensed it but Naotsugu was the only one attacked here. He managed to block it but the plasma charges knocked him down, it was undoubtedly a surprise attack. Tatsuya can't block it either.

I am not saying that Mari or Mayumi knows Inferno, this is not even fitting their fighting styles. Why would Mari learn this? I don't think she has the skills either but her antipersonel magic is A class and techniques like Dojigiri are undoutebly A class. Mayumi can probably master it, maybe she knows it even but she fights mainly with psion bullets. Inferno and Niflheim are AOE and Ice magics, Miyuki's specialty. Miyuki was surprised by Heated and Suffocating Turbulence as well. Inferno is not the only way to make a magician A rank. Many magicians at 1st high have the level to be A rank, you a greatly mistaken if you think Mayumi and Mari aren't A rank magicians. I gave more explanations below regarding Miyuki's magic.

Spoiler for Lucky Lu:

"Lu Gonghu!?"

"Erika, do you know who he is?"

Erika nodded in raw excitement at Leo's inquiry.

"He's a strong one!"

"Eh~"

Still, upon hearing Erika's concise answer, Leo didn't seem cowed in the slightest and his eyes seemed to glow even brighter. Because of this, the pair of upperclassmen felt a headache eclipsing their initial worries.

Catching sight of the approaching enemy unit, Miyuki pulled out her CAD.

"Miyuki-chan, STOP!"

Mayumi was completely focused on Erika, but managed to catch wind of the danger in time and frantically stopped her.

"Do you want the Magic Association members' magic to fail as well!?"

Miyuki's favored magic targeted whole areas. Magic with weak interference strength would fizzle away when Miyuki unleashed her magic. If she could identify each individual situation, then she might be able to differentiate them enough to avoid interfering with allied magic, but Mayumi considered this to be impossible at a range where men looked to be the size of ants.

"Don't worry, I will end this in one strike!"

Sure enough, Miyuki's response implied that she was about to unleash a cruel attack that paid no heed to allies in the line of fire.

How could she say something so horrifying despite that adorable appearance, Mayumi felt her headache worsening.

"No, if something goes sideways, is Miyuki-chan the only one who will pay the price?"

While Miyuki's thoughts on Mayumi's comment revolved around "there's no way I would miss any of them", Miyuki still obediently put her CAD away since Mayumi was concerned on her behalf after all.

"Miyuki-chan, please protect the branch headquarters itself. I know this seems like I'm leaving all the responsibility to you, but the only one who can hold the fort is probably Miyuki-chan."

"Understood."

Although Mayumi's "request" strategy was plain to see, Miyuki still accepted her new mission.

OK, you are right. But it doesn't mean he would have been OHKOed.

Originally Posted by Ravagerblade

The reaction is different because it was just invented not even on the market and somebody already has it in use (suspicious much) at least something like that.

No, they are surprised because it is a very difficult magic, method for testing A rank magician that Miyuki, a first year, used with ease. There is also the fact that they think of her as a member of a mundane family. The activation sequence is well known.

[zerozeronine]

Originally Posted by My Zodiac Aries

i concur. i can't see miyuki do any dirty work like an assasin.
she's prepared to manage a clan like Yotsuba Maya.
Miyuki is not prepared be a combatant like Tatsuya, Ayako or Fumiya.

Not sure about this,but you forgot that Fumiya is also a heir candidate,and he is sent in missions and from the story,Miyuki is calm in battle especially in the Yokohama arc.

Originally Posted by Echizen777

OK, you are right. But it doesn't mean he would have been OHKOed.



No, they are surprised because it is a very difficult magic, method for testing A rank magician that Miyuki, a first year, used with ease. There is also the fact that they think of her as a member of a mundane family. The activation sequence is well known.

For Lu,if Miyuki took action he would be defeated in minutes.

For Miyuki,wasn't it stated that some of her magic she used in 9SC,AS wasn't published yet and probably would be only available to those who was going to get test for being an A-rank magician or has graduated from university?(I think it was A-chan who mentioned it in vol 4).

[Raskreia]

I think it was pretty well done.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ViFWYfBGAT0

[Navinor]

What to do you think about the character of Miyuki?

She seems to be nice to people, but yet she is an evil person which try to achieve her goals with manipulation.

She thinks of other men nothing or lesser than "beans". But in the same time she has a huge brother complex. Even trying to sleep next to tatsuya.

And that driven by "love" towards her brother.

I think this huge psychological problem was developed due to the near death experience.

She can be icecold when it comes to terms of geting advantage of something.

In her deep core she is a Yotsuba to the fulliest and would commit cruel things, only make sure Tatsuya could live a normal life.

Otherwise, when there would be a chance of geting freedom from the Yotsuba, Miyuki would anhilate her own clan without a doubt.

Everything for Tatsuya. Still this "hardcore neediness" realy is not normal.

[Ophis]

Originally Posted by Navinor

What to do you think about the character of Miyuki?

She seems to be nice to people, but yet she is an evil person which try to achieve her goals with manipulation.

She thinks of other men nothing or lesser than "beans". But in the same time she has a huge brother complex. Even trying to sleep next to tatsuya.

And that driven by "love" towards her brother.

I think this huge psychological problem was developed due to the near death experience.

She can be icecold when it comes to terms of geting advantage of something.

In her deep core she is a Yotsuba to the fulliest and would commit cruel things, only make sure Tatsuya could live a normal life.

Otherwise, when there would be a chance of geting freedom from the Yotsuba, Miyuki would anhilate her own clan without a doubt.

Everything for Tatsuya. Still this "hardcore neediness" realy is not normal.

I get that you hate Miyuki but I think you should pay more atention when reading the novel because most of what you wrote there is pure nonsense.

PS: No, I'm not a Miyuki fanboy and particularly like both Lina and Honoka more than Miyuki. But you totally distorted Miyuki's character into some evil, manipulative and cold hearted villain, which she's not.

[IceHism]

Ehhh, Miyuki is not evil nor a villain but I think she is pretty cold to people and can be cruel when necessary. She, like Tatsuya, always wears a mask/facade when she interacts with people (though I suppose almost everyone in Mahouka has something to hide). I think her real personality lies somewhere between her happy bubbly self and her yotsuba characteristics


Hmm, I wonder if Miyuki has some sort of power fetish.

[bietchie11]

Originally Posted by Navinor

What to do you think about the character of Miyuki?

She seems to be nice to people, but yet she is an evil person which try to achieve her goals with manipulation.

She thinks of other men nothing or lesser than "beans". But in the same time she has a huge brother complex. Even trying to sleep next to tatsuya.

And that driven by "love" towards her brother.

I think this huge psychological problem was developed due to the near death experience.

She can be icecold when it comes to terms of geting advantage of something.

In her deep core she is a Yotsuba to the fulliest and would commit cruel things, only make sure Tatsuya could live a normal life.

Otherwise, when there would be a chance of geting freedom from the Yotsuba, Miyuki would anhilate her own clan without a doubt.

Everything for Tatsuya. Still this "hardcore neediness" realy is not normal.

Well, i think you simply read too much about stereo-type characters to really comprehend her.

[TrueAlchemist]

Originally Posted by IceHism

Ehhh, Miyuki is not evil nor a villain but I think she is pretty cold to people and can be cruel when necessary. She, like Tatsuya, always wears a mask/facade when she interacts with people (though I suppose almost everyone in Mahouka has something to hide). I think her real personality lies somewhere between her happy bubbly self and her yotsuba characteristics


Hmm, I wonder if Miyuki has some sort of power fetish.

lol, I agree with you.
And, she is not evil, but she will do anything in order to help Tatsuya.
I think, her real self shows up when she is with Tatsuya.

In the public, she acts as the way she supposed to act. But, she seems to be a little open to her friends.

For power fetish part, yes, she may be.
She gets really irritated when she cannot help Tatsuya, and others such as Ayako can help him. If Miyuki desires power, it is for the sake of Tatsuya not herself.

[Navinor]

Originally Posted by Ophis

I get that you hate Miyuki but I think you should pay more atention when reading the novel because most of what you wrote there is pure nonsense.

PS: No, I'm not a Miyuki fanboy and particularly like both Lina and Honoka more than Miyuki. But you totally distorted Miyuki's character into some evil, manipulative and cold hearted villain, which she's not.

What are you blabbering here?

I do not hate Miyuki. The only thing i do not agree with is the incest. But i am still reading this light novel, because it is the only bad point it has.


When you look it from a realistic psychological aspect, Miyuki has lots of that aspects. Maybe not in their 100 % pure form. Miyuki is not Sauron of course.

But still she is not the shiny angal some people want her to be.

And Miyuki has some daker sides to her, wich maybe will revealed throuh the ongoing series.

[I'm-here-present]

Originally Posted by Navinor

What are you blabbering here?

I do not hate Miyuki. The only thing i do not agree with is the incest. But i am still reading this light novel, because it is the only bad point it has.


When you look it from a realistic psychological aspect, Miyuki has lots of that aspects. Maybe not in their 100 % pure form. Miyuki is not Sauron of course.

But still she is not the shiny angal some people want her to be.

And Miyuki has some daker sides to her, wich maybe will revealed throuh the ongoing series.

You know some may hate Miyuki for those reason, especially about the incest part, but honest it is what sells her character and for so many to like her.

Cuz she has very unique quirk compared to the rest of the mainstream Mahouka characters.

[OHIMESAMA]

Well Miyuki is a very unusual girl with a very usual bro-con persona

[TheDisruptiveOne]

Personality wise, Miyuki is a lot like her late mother.

[Lucarion]

I can't wait for the day Miyuki gets pregnant...Her children are destined to be gods among men.

[renuac]

Originally Posted by Lucarion

I can't wait for the day Miyuki gets pregnant...Her children are destined to be gods among men.

Twins, of course? ^^

[CatRules]

Originally Posted by Lucarion

I can't wait for the day Miyuki gets pregnant...Her children are destined to be gods among men.

With Fumiya or Masaki?

[BalorView]

Originally Posted by CatRules

With Fumiya or Masaki?

Or with Katsuto-kun