2018-09-28, 07:08 | Link #861 | |
Logician and Romantic
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Within my mind
Age: 43
|
Quote:
Somehow I have a feeling you misinterpreted the situation. Two armies faced each other at a pre-planned battlefield, the same battlefield they fought in every single year for more than a decade. And you are somehow suggesting that NOT killing the armed soldiers makes you a good king? Does that make the King of Re-Estize a bad king too? Because HE would have no hesitation or remorse if he gets to wipe out the Empire forces. He would do it without hesitation, as the ruler of his people. I have no idea what kind of strange idea you have about what a ruler does. But I don't think you realise part of it is to kill those you need to kill. And that if you think otherwise, then literally no ruler in the entire New World are benevolent by your standards, not even later book rulers that have yet to appear.
__________________
|
|
2018-09-28, 07:56 | Link #863 | |||||
Custom User Title
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Ireland
|
Quote:
Let's say I demanded that you give me your sandwich, you refused and were willing to fight me to protect it. Am I justified in beating you up? The "it's okay because they are enemies" argument is nonsense. Ainz choose to pick a fight with the kingdom. Ainz choose to fight on his battlefield. Ainz choose to use a spell that killed over 70k people. He could have simply NOT done any of those things. Quote:
Quote:
Someone willing to kill a million people because he has some "master plan" that ultimately is for the good of everyone is a villain. Someone trying to convince a "hero" to join him by threatening the lives of innocent people is a villain. Quote:
Quote:
Most rulers, most people, don't have such an absolute distinction between allies and enemies. That it is somehow acceptable to slaughter hundreds of thousands of human beings because they are "enemies" today. |
|||||
2018-09-28, 09:21 | Link #864 | |
The Mage of Four Hearts
Author
Join Date: Mar 2010
Age: 34
|
Quote:
Killing the people that you have to kill might be a requirement as a king, but doing so without remorse shows the caliber of a person. Lest we forget, Ainz did not just kill remorselessly, he enjoyed the process of it, if not the actual killing itself. He enjoyed it so much, that he decided to kill a hundred thousand more people, just for fun. He even demanded people applaud him for it.
__________________
|
|
2018-09-28, 09:53 | Link #866 | |||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2013
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||||
2018-09-28, 09:55 | Link #867 | ||||
"Senior" "Member"
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Still, you are right that this point at least, is definitly as villain-like as it comes, no matter whether it's premediated or not. But only for the blackmail aspect of it, not for the killing of the soldiers. Quote:
Even the Emperor was doing these wars for the purpose of weakening and culling the Kingdom's population to a level that he could control. As for the King "hesitating"... that's actually considered a bad trait for him, because it's the sole reason why the kingdom has had all its current internal struggles: because the King just kept "hesitating" about his decision of who to give his throne to. The first victims of these internal struggles are the citizen of the Kingdom and it creates a status-quo where any changes are seen as weakness, which is why any of the necessary military reforms to at least slightly close the gap in army quality against the Empire cannot be done, causing the Empire to slowly chip away the Kingdom's manpower until one day nothing would be left and the Kingdom gets annected by the Empire - even without Ainz's intervention, given enough time. So no the King wasn't "wise" or "empathetic", he was just procrastinating and not doing his job.
__________________
|
||||
2018-09-28, 10:05 | Link #868 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2014
|
Prince Barbro who wanted to use the carne villagers as cannon fodder and deciding to raze the village is a villain
Ramposa III who wanted to kill an unknown mage at the cost of casualties is a villain Jircniv wipes out opposers, attacks the kingdom annually at harvest to kill the kingdom slowly, and plans to backstab ainz is a villain Quote:
the king rejected gazef's proposal despite his warnings so that opinion is worth jack. In our history, Thailand acted as a buffer state, where the British colonies are on the west and French on the east. Based on the map, using nazarick as the center point the kingdom is northwest and Baharuth Empire is north east and Azerlisia Mountains is in the north of nazarick. Katze Plains where the battle took place is in the south of nazarick. Guess who hesitated?
__________________
Last edited by eiyuuou; 2018-09-28 at 10:18. |
|
2018-09-28, 10:28 | Link #869 | ||||||
Custom User Title
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Ireland
|
What are you talking about? Obviously stuff like alignments and karma doesn't apply to characters in the novel.
It's all just fans imposing their own morals onto the characters, the morals within the show are different. Spoiler for character sheet:
Quote:
Plus, if he told the Empire "hey don't do the war this year" they would have agreed. In first place, Ainz doesn't care about how many people he kills so why does he care about helping the people of the Kingdom? Quote:
I'd call doing that blackmail but it's worse. Quote:
- For Truman, the choice whether or not to use the atomic bomb was the most difficult decision of his life - Critics have charged that Truman's decision was a barbaric act that brought negative long-term consequences to the United States Quote:
Because the Soviet Union was all about sacrificing millions of people "for the greater good". Quote:
In any case, most of the soldiers on the Kingdom's side are peasant levies. He basically killed a I-don't-know-how-large portion of the Kingdom's farmers. Quote:
|
||||||
2018-09-28, 10:42 | Link #870 | |
"Senior" "Member"
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
Quote:
It's a disability (from a human POV), a species trait. He CANNOT have remorse. The situation was caused by an unknown phenomenom (the world transfer), not by his choice. You are blaming him just for existing. A decision which you would find justifiable if it was done by humans, as long as they feel remorse are unjustifiable just because he happens to be in an undead body? That's... well... racism? Speciecism? Something like that.
__________________
Last edited by GreyZone; 2018-09-28 at 10:58. |
|
2018-09-28, 10:55 | Link #871 | |||||||
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2013
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
|||||||
2018-09-28, 11:07 | Link #872 | |
The Mage of Four Hearts
Author
Join Date: Mar 2010
Age: 34
|
Quote:
Secondly, even if Ainz was completely unable to feel anything at all, even regard for life in general, he can still think, he would be perfectly capable of regretting the necessity of what happened from an intellectual point. But again, that point didn't even cross his mind. it has nothing to do with Ainz being an undead, Ainz is just a horrible person. If Ainz were human, I'm sure he'd be doing exactly the same thing he is now.
__________________
|
|
2018-09-28, 12:08 | Link #873 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Somewhere in this Universe
|
Quote:
The show did pretty good on setting up some relatable or honorable characters like Arche and Gazef, only to kill them later (poor Gazef with all his red flags ). I feel like half the reasons others defend Ainz are because he is the main character. But then again, Ainz himself said he is a hypocrite, so what can you expect ?? |
|
2018-09-28, 12:17 | Link #874 | ||
The Mage of Four Hearts
Author
Join Date: Mar 2010
Age: 34
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||
2018-09-28, 15:58 | Link #876 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2015
Location: Portugal
|
I don't agree with this. He not caring for humans is an undead trait. Undead hating the living is a common trope. In season 1 while looking at the massacre occurring in Carne's village, Ainz said that before being trapped in the game, he would almost faint if he saw blood or any of the other cruelties being displayed in the magic seeing mirror. So you can see there is a clear difference between personalities before and after. The only reason as to why Ainz is not killing any living being on site is because of his past human memories. Because an undead OP overlord would definitely not act like him, lore-wise. What we have is someone with a body programmed to destroy the mortal races with emotion suppression abilities, evil allignment and natural disdain for humans, but with an human mind. The mix between these two extremes creates current Ainz. A messed up combo and the reason why his character gives origin to so many discussions regarding his actions.
|
2018-09-28, 17:04 | Link #877 | |
Porcupine
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Norway
Age: 65
|
Quote:
This is found in some Buddhist faiths that claim that humans have an inner Buddha-nature that is innately good and divine, but covered in dirt from our incarnation, which must then be purified through spiritual practice. The Christian apostle Paul laments the fact that even though he wants to be good, the evil in his flesh is imprisoning him and making him do what he does not want. And of course the primary preachers of this type of philosophy were the gnostics, who believed that the pure human spirit was imprisoned in an evil body created by the Demiurge, a twisted creator-god of a lower order than the primordial God. The appearance of the name Demiurge in a central (evil) character is a strong hint that the author is at least somewhat familiar with this philosophy. So basically we have a decent person trapped in a body that is inherently evil by human standards, and this inner person is able to occasionally mitigate the evil that his body naturally lends itself to. But at other times, he finds himself drawn into agreement with his body, even though he knows that it is not right. We get a glimpse of this inner monolog in this episode where the human player inside Ainz briefly reflects on the fact that he should feel bad about this, but feels only excitement. |
|
2018-09-28, 17:58 | Link #878 | |
"Senior" "Member"
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
Quote:
On top of that Ainz is a very, very special case, even for a human that becomes an undead. I am sure in-universe in YGGDRASSIL and/or the New World there are probably methods for a human to become an independent (as in not controlled by a necromancer) undead by transforming their own body into an undead, I'd think. But Ainz isn't like that. He didn't go through any such "proper" ritual, but rather appearently got his human mind forcefully fused into his Overlord (species name) body by whatever process that turned the DMMO characters into real entities in another world. This might cause several mental problems other than just adjusting to the mental resistences, but also the messy fusion of science-world human mind to magic-world undead Overlord body. Now Ainz has become unable to sympathize with anyone who he has a neutral or negative relationship with. However strangely, he can still have quite human-like feelings towards those he takes a liking to - more importantly, even though he feels nothing when he killed unknown people or those he doesn't care about or those he dislikes, he still can take a liking to people. Example: Niphrea, Ninya and Nemu. Niphrea was the first one. Despite him discovering that Ainz = Momon, he didn't re-write his memories. The scene after subduing Hamsuke where Ainz rejected Niphrea from joining Nazarick, he still showed good will towards him. Ainz also saves him over preserving that Crown of Wisdom from the Slane Theocracy, though in that case he already made a deal with Niphrea and Ainz takes such transactions and promises very seriously. Still, it's evident that Ainz has taken a liking to him. Ninya was someone Ainz didn't get along too well at first and he actually did the "sacrilege" of belittling Ainz's comrades. The fact that after that Ainz still went as far as to give Clementine a "hypocritical hug" as an eye for an eye for Ninya, shows that he not only has forgiven her, but also held enough attachment that he was willing to take revenge for her. Nemu's case was special because only a short while before meeting her again since the time he saved her and Enri from the disguised Slane Theocracy knights, Ainz told Aura that he only appreciates people who are Nazarick residents from the beginning and otherwise only those who are useful for him and Nazarick. But here is the thing: That's a total lie. Niphrea was useful because of his special skill and his value as an alchemist, while Ninya still left him that one useful book behind. But Nemu is merely Enri's sister and perhaps counts as her emotional support, but while "keeping her alive to keep Enri emotionally stable" might be rational reason to add Nemu to the list, it's clearly NOT the reason he did it. He added her mostly because of her attitude of a Nazarick fangirl. Therefore he lied when he spoke to Aura, but it was proably more of a lie to himself, rather than to Aura. Now I am waiting for the episode 13 PVs... hopefully before I go asleep.
__________________
|
|
2018-09-28, 19:51 | Link #879 |
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2014
|
If some of you guys hate ainz because he's evil, villain, no humanity, murderer etc, then why are you following this series? It was established from episode 1 that these nazarick people is not your do goodies, saving the world, help someone in trouble kind of people. Nazarick was made for player who play as non human race to band together and fight back against other human race player from their constant abuse of PKing and discrimination.
I mean, the root of ainz villain or non human trait is pretty much set in stone from episode 1, and was further shown with the floor guardian. |
2018-09-28, 20:20 | Link #880 | |
"Senior" "Member"
Join Date: Jan 2012
|
Quote:
Damn it, where's that preview? I am getting sleepy here... it's past 3 a.m. here.
__________________
|
|
|
|